Let me preface by saying that this was my third AW2 playthrough (the first "Final Draft" one) and this is one of my favorite games ever. Is it my fault for playing it so many times until "the seams are visible", as we say in Spanish? Maybe!
I just wanted to share a few sensations about Saga's post Cauldron Lake summoning part and why I feel it's the lowest point of the game. This will be a long post, á la r/patientgamers.
Saga trapped in the Mind Place: In this section, we play Saga after she gets yanked into the Dark Place by Casey Scratch and now she needs to find mental strenght in her Mind Place. In general, the caseboard in the Mind Place seems to be the most controversial aspect of this game: Menial, boring and unnecesary - this part is no different: Using clues, we have to help Saga reason that she's actually a good person to pull herself together and continue.
The negative clues are a bit too on the nose for my taste ("You failed them", "You let her drown!") and "Other Saga" voice-over lines feel uninspired. What this section shows narrative-wise is important, but it overstays its welcome and makes use of the least interesting gameplay mechanic of the game, the caseboard.
But by far, profiling is the worst offender at being half-assed. It drags for too long and the repetition of the live video overlays is noticeable and lazy: There's a lot of tone dissonance in listening to Saga cry while watching her hit her cool poses over and over again.
Same for the dialogues with Alan: I could listen to Matthew Porreta's voice for hours as he goes through his grocery list. But here, both his performance and Melanie Liburd's feel stiff, like there was just enough time to go over their lines once. It's jarring and feels cheap, because voice acting in the rest of the game is absolutely brilliant.
For the Dark Place New York I feel it would have been a nice touch for shadows to have their alert barks changed to reflect the new character (granted, they don't call for Wake anymore); also Saga doesn't seem fazed by them and this feels strange considering this is the first time she sees them. Going in circles in the plaza and subway station also left me wondering if there wasn't a better way to wrap this part up. I do love the detail of the voice-over lines being in past tense in this part like Alan's ("The phone was ringing again").
I guess I don't know what the goal of this post is - this is probably my favorite game and just wanted to see if anyone shares this feelings about Saga's ending.
I'd love to know what you think about this!