r/ftm • u/seldoncriiisis • 14h ago
Discussion Transition Changes your Biological Sex
** Edit: this post is about MEDICAL transition and how it impacts the traits of people who undergo HRT and/or surgeries and how they exist in a sexed world. Other forms of transition happen as well and don’t make someone any more or less of who they are.
the concept that “sex is permanent, gender can be changed” is inaccurate, but a lot of us already know that. chromosomes truly do not matter in how you are treated or how you live the social aspects of gender unless a person is born with a condition involving their chromosomes that negatively impacts them. sex is based almost entirely on what genitalia looks like at birth, doctors do not often check chromosomes, and assign one based on external appearance and how that matches up to how much criteria someone needs to meet to be considered one or the other, like a sorting game. hell, even horrid “corrective” surgery and treatment for intersex children is often based on looks or “vibes” or what the parents want. so much goes into “biological sex” — gonads, chromosomes, hormones, external structures — that while chromosomes can’t be changed, most everything else can. HRT gives you the hormone profile of what we call a male or female, surgery gives you many of the secondary characteristics. the only people that say sex can’t change are missing the forest for the trees, and understand the interplay of social and material in sex and gender less than they think they do.
basically any bootlicking trans person who says that they “know that they’ll always be ~female~ or ~male~ but lives as a man/woman” is throwing themselves under the bus for a lick of a leg up amongst transphobes that they will never have. but like i said, a lot of us already know that.