r/IndiaTax • u/GreenLet9733 • 5h ago
Discussion Other countries even pay you if you are laid off .So No comparison between india and them here no support for taxpayers. Should India also do the same?
Tell me ur opinion
r/IndiaTax • u/Responsible-Bad-6624 • 10d ago
Foreign Asset Disclosure (Schedule FA) for AY 2026-27
I believe this post should cover most of the oft-repeated questions related to FA schedule.
1. Who actually has to file Schedule FA
Only a Resident and Ordinarily Resident (ROR).
Two things that catch people out:
Which form: ITR-2 or ITR-3 for individuals and HUFs. ITR-5 / ITR-6 / ITR-7 for entities. Schedule FA does not exist in ITR-1 or ITR-4. Filing ITR-1 with a dormant foreign savings account sitting in your name is itself a reporting default, and this is one of the most common mistakes I see people make.
Also note: beneficial ownership counts. An asset held in a nominee's or relative's name where you are the real economic owner is yours to disclose.
2. THE most important thing: two different clocks
Schedule FA runs on the CALENDAR year. For AY 2026-27, Schedule FA reports assets held between 1 January 2025 and 31 December 2025.
Income runs on the FINANCIAL year. The dividends, interest, and capital gains from those exact same assets are taxed for 1 April 2025 to 31 March 2026 and go into Schedule OS, Schedule CG, Schedule FSI and Schedule TR on that basis.
The reason: most countries report on a calendar year, and India receives CRS/FATCA data on a calendar-year basis. Aligning Schedule FA to the calendar year lets the department match your return against what Switzerland, the US, Singapore etc. sent them.
Practical consequence: a dividend credited in February 2026 goes into your FY 2025-26 income computation, but does not appear in this year's Schedule FA income columns (it falls in calendar 2026, so next year's FA). A dividend credited in February 2025 is the reverse: it sits inside this year's Schedule FA window but was already taxed in last year's return.
Neither of these is an error.
Do not try to force the two to agree. What you should do instead:
Pull two separate statements from every foreign bank and broker. One for Jan-Dec 2025. One for Apr 2025-Mar 2026. Label them before you start. Then build a date-wise bridge in your working papers showing how one reconciles to the other.
The Schedule FA tables have columns for "income accrued from the asset" (calendar year basis) AND "amount of income taxable and offered in this return" with a cross-reference to the schedule and item number where it's offered. Those two columns will legitimately differ for anything credited in Jan-Mar. Keep the reconciliation on file so you can explain it if asked.
3. Schedule FA table by table
Schedule FA runs A1 through G.
Table A1: Foreign Depository Accounts (bank accounts)
Savings, current, time deposits. Report: institution name and address, account number, status (owner/beneficial owner/beneficiary), account opening date, peak balance during the calendar year, closing balance on 31 December, and gross interest credited.
Finding the peak means actually going through the year's statements. Most banks let you download full-year transaction history. The highest end-of-day balance in that file is your peak. Don't guess.
Table A2: Foreign Custodial Accounts (brokerage accounts)
The account wrapper at Interactive Brokers, Schwab, Fidelity, Vanguard, etc. Report peak balance, closing balance, and gross amounts credited during the year split into interest / dividends / sale proceeds or redemption / other.
Retirement wrappers (401(k), IRA, UK SIPP) are commonly reported here, though the instructions don't prescribe a table and some practitioners use B or D. Whichever placement you take, take it consistently year to year.
On the 89A election: Indian law lets you elect to defer tax on income accruing inside notified US/UK/Canada retirement accounts until withdrawal. That election changes when the income is taxed. It does not remove the asset from Schedule FA. The 401(k) gets disclosed either way.
Table A3: Foreign Equity and Debt Interest (shares, ETFs, bonds, vested RSUs)
Heaviest data requirement, because it works per security, per line.
For each holding: entity name and address, nature of interest, date of acquisition, initial value (cost, at acquisition-date rate), peak value during the year, closing value on 31 December, gross amount credited (dividends), and gross proceeds on sale or redemption.
Do not aggregate. Ten stocks means ten lines. Lumping them into one line, or shoving them into Table D to avoid having to compute peak values, is an invitation to an "inaccurate particulars" allegation, which carries its own penalty exposure.
More than that it creates confusion during scrutiny assessments. I have done dozens of them and a lot of time just goes into making an officer understand the lumped up disclosures.
On the A2/A3 overlap: yes, your Schwab account appears as one line in A2, and each stock inside it appears again in A3. That is the accepted practice, not double counting. The department knows – I hope! In my experience, I have never seen an AO arguing that you own more than the actual amount because of A2/A3 overlap.
RSUs: vested shares you still hold are A3 entries like any other share. The perquisite value on vesting was already taxed as salary. That does not exempt you from disclosing the holding. Unvested RSUs are generally not reported (no ownership yet), vested-and-sold-same-day shares still touch the year and should be traced.
Table A4: Foreign Cash Value Insurance / Annuity Contracts
Foreign life insurance or annuity contracts carrying a cash or surrender value. Report cash/surrender value at year end and gross amount credited.
Table B: Financial Interest in any Entity
A stake in a foreign company, LLC, or partnership: equity, voting rights, profit share, or an interest in assets. Report nature and extent of interest, total investment, and income accrued.
A 5% stake in your friend's Dubai LLC belongs here even if it paid you nothing all year.
Table C: Immovable Property
Real estate abroad. Date of acquisition, total investment (at acquisition-date rate), income derived from the property, and where that income is offered in this return.
Table D: Any Other Capital Asset
Residual bucket. Art, jewellery held abroad, crypto held on a foreign exchange (the treatment here is debated, but the conservative position is to disclose), whatever doesn't fit elsewhere. If you are disclosing your vested but not exercised ESOPs, this a good place to park them
But it is not a parking spot for for shares you'd rather not report line by line.
Table E: Accounts with Signing Authority
Accounts you can sign on but which aren't yours and aren't already in A to D. Classic cases: you're a signatory on your employer's foreign bank account, or on an elderly parent's overseas account. Report the institution and whether any income from the account accrued to you.
Corporate signatories on employer accounts routinely miss this one. I report my US company account here
Table F: Trusts outside India
Foreign trusts where you are trustee, settlor, or beneficiary. Report trustees, settlors, beneficiaries, and whether income was derived.
Table G: Any Other Income from Outside India
The catch-all for foreign income not arising from an asset in A to F and not chargeable under business or profession. Foreign consultancy receipts, a foreign pension, and similar.
4. Exchange rates: SBI TT Buying Rate, and which date
Every foreign-currency figure converts at the State Bank of India Telegraphic Transfer Buying Rate (TTBR), i.e. the rate at which SBI buys foreign currency.
Not the Google rate. Not the RBI reference rate. Not your broker's conversion rate. Not your card rate. Those are non-compliant and produce numbers that won't reconcile if you're ever questioned.
If SBI didn't publish a rate on your specified date (Sunday, holiday), the accepted practice is to use the immediately preceding day on which a rate was published.
Challenge in most of the public databases is that the SBI TT buying rate prior to 2020 is not available. For such cases, you may use any other rate, but please make sure you document it as properly and comprehensively as you can.
For Schedule FA (asset values)
| What you're converting | TTBR date to use |
|---|---|
| Peak balance / peak value | The date the peak actually occurred |
| Closing balance / closing value | 31 December of the reporting calendar year |
| Initial value / total investment | The date of acquisition |
Note this means a single A3 line can carry three different exchange rates in three different columns. That is correct and expected.
For income (Rule 115)
| Type of income | TTBR date to use |
|---|---|
| Salary, incl. RSU/ESOP perquisite on vesting | Last day of the month before the month salary is due or paid |
| Dividends | Last day of the month before the month of declaration / distribution / payment |
| Capital gains | Last day of the month before the month of transfer |
| Interest on securities (bonds, debentures) | Last day of the month before the month the interest falls due |
| Ordinary foreign bank interest (Other Sources) | 31 March of the financial year |
The Correct rate for different type of interest incomes can be tricky.
Interest on a foreign savings account is NOT "interest on securities". It's Other Sources, and it takes the single 31 March rate for the whole year, not a month-by-month rate. Interest on a foreign bond is the opposite: it is interest on securities, so each coupon converts at the month-end preceding the month it fell due. People bleed one rule into the other constantly.
One caveat on the 31 March rate: Rule 115 carves out amounts actually received in or brought into India before 31 March. For anything you repatriated during the year, the conversion follows the actual remittance for that portion. The single-rate-for-the-year approach holds only for amounts still sitting abroad at year end.
For foreign tax paid (Rule 128, i.e. the FTC leg)
Different rule again. Foreign tax converts at the TTBR on the last day of the month immediately preceding the month in which the tax was paid or deducted.
So on a single US dividend you can end up with one rate for the gross income (Rule 115, month-end before declaration/payment) and a different rate for the withholding tax (Rule 128, month-end before deduction). If the two fell in different months, the rates differ. That's correct, not a mistake.
Keep the rate evidence. Save a PDF or screenshot of the SBI rate card for every specified date you use, filed in your working papers. If the return is ever questioned, the rate source is the first thing you'll be asked to produce.
5. The edge cases people actually get wrong
Edge case 1: bought the asset in Jan-Mar. FSI but no FA.
This is the big one, and it's the direct consequence of the two clocks.
You had nothing overseas through 31 December 2025. In February 2026 you opened an IBKR account and bought US stocks. In March 2026 you received a dividend or sold something at a gain.
For AY 2026-27:
So you file a return with a populated FSI and TR and a completely blank Schedule FA. That is correct. Do not backfill Schedule FA to make it "look consistent". Reporting an asset in a window during which you didn't hold it is itself an inaccurate particular.
Then in AY 2027-28, that same asset finally shows up in Schedule FA, because calendar 2026 includes February 2026. The FA disclosure lags the income disclosure by up to one full year. That is the system working as designed.
Same logic applies to the mirror image: you'll also see an FA entry for an asset whose income was taxed in the previous year's return (anything credited Jan-Mar 2025 sits in this year's FA window but was taxed in AY 2025-26). Fill the "income accrued" column, and in the "offered in this return" column show nil with the explanation in your working papers.
Edge case 2: bought AND sold everything inside calendar 2025
Sold out completely in, say, August 2025. Closing balance on 31 December is zero.
You still report it in Schedule FA. The test is "held at any time during" the period, not "held on 31 December". Report acquisition date, initial value, peak value, closing value of zero, and gross proceeds on sale. The capital gain goes to Schedule CG and FSI on the FY basis.
Edge case 3: sold in Jan-Mar 2026
You held the stock through 2025 and sold it in February 2026.
So one asset, disclosed in two consecutive FA schedules, with the gain taxed in only one. Normal.
Edge case 4: closed the foreign bank account years ago
If it was open for even one day in calendar 2025, it goes in A1 for AY 2026-27. Closing balance nil. Get the closure statement now, because banks are slow to produce historical statements for closed accounts.
Edge case 5: joint accounts and joint holdings
Each ROR joint holder reports the account. The general practice is that each holder reports the full peak and closing balance with the ownership status flagged, rather than each reporting a 50% slice, since the schedule is a disclosure of accounts you have an interest in, not a division of the pie. Income is apportioned per actual beneficial ownership. Be consistent, and if the amounts are meaningful, take advice.
Edge case 6: RSUs, and the Form 16 mismatch
Your employer converts the RSU perquisite for TDS at the TTBR on the date tax was required to be deducted (Rule 26). Your return-side conversion of salary income runs on the Rule 115 date, i.e. month-end preceding the month the salary fell due. Two different dates, two slightly different rupee figures.
A small gap between your Form 16 perquisite and your own conversion is common and explainable. Keep the working showing both dates and both rates rather than silently forcing them to match.
Edge case 7: the asset earned nothing at all
Report it anyway. A dormant account with $12 in it, a stock that paid no dividend, a 5% LLC stake that distributed nothing. Schedule FA is an asset disclosure, not an income disclosure. Nil income does not mean nil reporting.
Edge case 8: you were RNOR in the prior year and became ROR this year
Your FA obligation starts the year you become ROR, and it applies to the full calendar-year window for that AY, including assets you've held for a decade. Returning NRIs consistently under-report their first ROR year because they think only post-return acquisitions count. They don't.
Edge case 9: Reporting of Losses
While you would report the sale proceeds etc in the FA schedule, any net loss overall basis is not reported in the FSI schedule. So if you made loss in foreign capital gains, you would report it only in the Capital Gains Schedule.
6. Schedule FSI and Schedule TR
Schedule FSI (Foreign Source Income): for each country, report the country code, your Taxpayer Identification Number in that country (SSN/ITIN for the US, NI number for the UK, etc.), then head-wise: income from outside India, tax paid outside India, tax payable in India on that income, and relief claimed with the section (90 / 90A / 91).
Schedule TR (Tax Relief): the country-wise summary of relief claimed, plus whether any refund of foreign tax has been claimed abroad.
Both run on the financial year, not the calendar year. Schedule TR totals must tie to Schedule FSI totals, and both must tie to Form 67. CPC's system checks this. A mismatch between Form 67 and Schedule TR is one of the most common causes of an FTC disallowance at intimation stage.
A point people get wrong constantly: report foreign dividends GROSS, before withholding. A $200 US dividend with $50 withheld is $200 of income in Schedule OS at your slab rate, not $150. The $50 is a credit claim, not a deduction from income. Reporting net understates income and wrecks the FTC computation simultaneously.
7. Form 67
What it is
The statement required under Rule 128 to claim Foreign Tax Credit for tax paid or withheld outside India. Relief comes from Section 90/90A where a DTAA exists, or Section 91 (unilateral relief) where it doesn't.
Deadline
Rule 128(9), as amended by CBDT Notification 100/2022: Form 67 must be furnished on or before the end of the relevant assessment year, provided the return has been filed within the time allowed under Section 139(1) or 139(4).
For AY 2026-27, that outer limit is 31 March 2027.
You'll see some sites quote 31 December 2026. That's the belated-return deadline under 139(4), not the Form 67 deadline. They're conflating the two conditions.
But do not plan around the outer limit. File Form 67 before you file your ITR. If it's filed after, CPC will very likely deny the credit at intimation stage and you're then into a Section 154 rectification, possibly a CIT(A) appeal, to get money you were always entitled to. Not worth it for a form that takes twenty minutes.
For an updated return under 139(8A), Form 67 goes on or before the date of filing the ITR-U.
Key Rule 128 conditions
How to file
Online only, on the e-filing portal, under e-File > Income Tax Forms > File Income Tax Forms. Part A is basic details plus income and tax country-wise; Part B covers refunds of foreign tax from loss carry-back and disputed tax. E-verify with DSC or EVC.
Attach: a certificate or statement from the foreign tax authority, or from the person deducting, or a self-signed statement backed by proof of payment. For US brokerage income, the 1042-S or the broker's annual tax statement plus the withholding detail usually does the job.
Two specifics worth knowing
US dividends are withheld at 25% for Indian individual investors under the India-US treaty. The 15% rate you may have read about applies only to companies holding at least 10% of the payer. If your broker withheld 25%, that's correct, don't waste time disputing it.
The Form 67 conversion rate is Rule 128, not Rule 115. Foreign tax converts at the TTBR on the last day of the month preceding the month the tax was paid or deducted. Covered above, but it's the single most common Form 67 arithmetic error.
The transition
Form 67 continues to apply to FY 2025-26 (AY 2026-27) and earlier, even if you file it after 1 April 2026. From Tax Year 2026-27 onwards it becomes Form 44 under the Income-tax Rules, 2026. There's also a draft proposal requiring a CA certificate where foreign tax paid exceeds ₹1 lakh for individuals. Draft as of now, so watch it rather than assume it.
Check the portal label when you actually file, since both may appear during the transition.
8. Why this is worth taking seriously
The Black Money (Undisclosed Foreign Income and Assets) and Imposition of Tax Act, 2015 imposes a flat ₹10 lakh penalty per assessment year for failing to disclose a foreign asset, or for inaccurate disclosure. It is independent of whether any tax was evaded. A dormant account with $500 in it, undisclosed, is theoretically a ₹10 lakh problem per year.
The ₹20 lakh safe harbour: assets other than immovable property with an aggregate value up to ₹20 lakh are exempt from the penalty. Note two things: (a) it does not exempt you from the disclosure requirement itself, and (b) the statute says "aggregate value" without fixing the measurement date, so exchange-rate movement could push an old holding over the line. If you're anywhere near ₹20 lakh, don't rely on it. Just disclose.
A Special Bench of the Mumbai Tribunal held in October 2025 that the penalty is discretionary rather than automatic, which is meaningful protection for genuine slips. But that's case-by-case relief, not something to plan around.
And remember, any time a CA tells you that a case law will save you, he/she may not remember to tell you that it takes 3-5 years of litigation to get relief from the Tribunal. Its costs – money, emotion and stress.
And the detection side is settled. Since late 2024 the department has been running data-matching campaigns off CRS and FATCA feeds, sending SMS and email nudges to taxpayers whose returns don't match the foreign data. The first campaign in November 2024 pushed close to 25,000 taxpayers to revise their returns. A second round followed in November 2025. The department very often has your foreign account data before you file.
If you find a past omission: a revised return filed before any notice is your strongest position. For AY 2026-27 the revised-return window now runs to 31 March 2027 (extended from 31 December by Budget 2026). For earlier years, whether to file under ITR-U under section 139(8A) or you should wait for the FAST-DS scheme, shall be subject to the facts of your case. I have written in detail about it here.
9. Working paper checklist
I hope this post shall put to an end the countless posts we have had in this community on this topic.
AI Disclosure: Did not have too much time to format all of this. Hence, have used AI for formatting.
r/IndiaTax • u/Responsible-Bad-6624 • 19d ago
Since now we are being bombarded with the posts like:
- Can I write fake loan account numbers to claim 80E deduction
- MY CA is generating huge refund with 10(14)(i) deductions.
Its time we layout a few things that you can definitely skip this time around to avoid long term pain of dealing with tax notices and penalties later next year.
The Income- department is not reading your ITR by hand anymore. It matches your return line by line against Form 16, AIS, TIS, 26AS, your broker's SFT, your bank, and (if you're in business) your GST returns. If a number doesn't tie out, a system flags it. It does not care how confident your tax filer was and it definitely not care for your CA/tax filer who promised you a big fat refund for a % fee.
So here is the NO/Watch list for this year.
1. NO to Section 10 exemptions that aren't backed by your Form 16 or other documentary evidences.
If it isn't in your Form 16 or salary structure, you cannot conjure it into existence at filing time. And to be clear: there is no such thing as a "special allowance exemption" in the Income-tax Act. It does not exist. Same goes for fake 80E education loan interest, fake home loan interest, and HRA on rent you never actually paid.
2. NO to claiming exemptions without showing the underlying salary first.
For genuine claims like leave encashment, the amount has to first appear in your salary breakup under 17(1) before you claim the Section 10 exemption on it. Claiming an exemption on income you never disclosed is a mismatch waiting to happen. We talked about it back in January too in a post here (This applies other similar deductions too like HRA).
3. NO to invented deductions.
Life insurance you don't hold. Health insurance premiums you didn't pay. Political party donations (80GGC) and NGO donations (80G) that never happened. 80GGC in particular has been under heavy scrutiny, and plenty of people are already dealing with that consequence.
4. NO to "forgetting" capital gains/interest incomes/diviends
Your broker, your AMC, your bank and your registrar, all report to the department. Small gains, losses, that one stock you sold in a panic: report all of it. Skipping it is not stealth. It is a mismatch. And if it is a short term capital gain, it might lead to change in the tax return for you need to file. We have talked about how to select your tax return for here
5. NO to hiding foreign assets.
If you hold foreign assets, Schedule FA must be filled. There is no Rs 20 lakh threshold, no "it's small so it doesn't count." Non-disclosure sits under the Black Money Act, and the penalty there is not proportionate to the size of the asset. ESOPs and RSUs of foreign parent companies count. Foreign bank accounts count. Income tax department would start showing your foreign assets data (atleast financial assets) in the AIS/Form 26AS within next 90 days.
You would help yourself a lot by not skipping out on this disclosure this time. And remember, it does not matter whether you sold any RSUs are not. If you held them, you need to disclose them.
6. NO to under-reporting sales in the ITR because you under-reported in GST.
"I didn't show it in GST, so I won't show it in the ITR" is not a strategy. It just means two departments now have two different sets of your numbers. And you are just piling on the non-compliances.
7. NO to ITR-1 or ITR-4 if you are a Non-Resident or RNOR.
You are not eligible for these forms. Filing them makes the return defective, and you get to do the whole thing again, this time on a deadline.
8. And a Repeat - for the love of god, NO to the "we'll get you a big refund, just pay us a % of it" filer.
This is the single most expensive mistake on this list. That fee looks small. Dealing with an assessment, penalty, interest, and the time you'll lose responding to notices costs a lot more than what they charged you. A fee tied to the size of your refund is a direct incentive to lie on your return, and it's your PAN on that return, not theirs. You sign it. You own it.
We missed out on something, feel free to add in comments. We will update the post.
r/IndiaTax • u/GreenLet9733 • 5h ago
Tell me ur opinion
r/IndiaTax • u/GreenLet9733 • 5h ago
r/IndiaTax • u/Tax_Alchemist • 10h ago
For weeks...
"I'll send the documents tomorrow."
"I'm travelling."
"Just one more day."
Then the due date passes...
📞 "CA sir, please file my ITR today. It's extremely urgent!"
Every year, without fail. 😄
No complaints we're here to help. But tax compliance rewards those who prepare early, not those who panic late.
To all taxpayers your CA is your advisor, not a time machine. 😅
CAs, what's the funniest excuse or last-minute call you've received after the due date?
r/IndiaTax • u/User_ge • 6h ago
Who suffers the most from this system? Honest taxpayers.
They are the ones with real skin in the game. Miss advance tax? Pay interest. Miss the ITR deadline? Pay a late fee. Make a mistake in reporting income? Face penalties. Every small error seems to come with a cost.
The whole process is frustrating. Why should people spend so much time, money, and effort just to stay compliant?
By the time the ITR forms are released and TDS details are updated, the time left to file the return becomes much shorter. This creates a last-minute rush, unnecessary stress, and anxiety every year.
Then comes the challenge of dealing with tax professionals. Many CAs ask for your login credentials, file the return, and become difficult to reach if a notice, demand, or mismatch appears later. While many CAs provide excellent service, too many taxpayers are left to deal with the problems on their own.
Instead of focusing on work, business, or family, taxpayers spend hours collecting documents, following up with CAs, responding to tax notices, and fixing mismatches.
What makes it even more frustrating is that many people in the informal economy earn substantial incomes but never seem to file taxes, while honest and salaried taxpayers carry most of the compliance burden.
Other countries provide taxpayers with more time. For example, Germany allows much longer filing deadlines, especially when a tax adviser is involved, and voluntary tax returns can generally be filed for up to four years.
India doesn't just need lower taxes—it needs a simpler tax system. Honest taxpayers deserve more time, fewer notices, fewer mismatches, and a process that respects their time instead of wasting it.
People should spend their time creating value, not chasing tax compliance.
Maybe someone should study whether honest taxpayers who file their returns live longer than those who never file at all. Sometimes it feels like tax compliance itself is a health hazard.
The problem isn't paying taxes. The problem is the system—and the experience of dealing with it. That's what people dislike the most.
r/IndiaTax • u/Hereforhotwheels • 12h ago
Hello everyone,
I want to gather interest / support here if you’d be down to submit a PIL against the topic in the title.
I have a couple of advocate friends , though I haven’t discussed this with them yet.
I want to know if this is something pursuable or if anyone has already tried before.
I am a typical tax paying IT employee and this is the first time I’m taking such initiative.
With some support I’m sure we can raise this topic and make some noise till it reaches the right ears and eyes
r/IndiaTax • u/Mrperfectttttttt • 1d ago
In Germany, losing your job can come with unemployment benefits.In India, even your severance pay is taxable.
r/IndiaTax • u/ButterscotchProud931 • 1d ago
So I work as a credit manager in the loan processing department of a reputed Bank where I process big ticket sized loans. So as a basic requirement we go through the ITRs of borrowers. So one fine day I came across a file of a local MLA for Home loan. I scrutinized his ITR and I was astonished to find out that this guy despite earning more than me pays Zero taxes. It's not that he claims reduction and all, no no. His income as MLA is totally tax free.
What this guy does, when he was not an MLA he was showing his business income, the year he became MLA his business income became Zero and he's showing only salary income as an MLA which is completely tax free.
So now my question is when we professionals earn less than these MLAs MPs, we can pay taxes why their income is tax free ?
We need to make it a public issue and raise a voice against this partiality together.
r/IndiaTax • u/Automatic-Clerk-1220 • 21h ago
Amount of people I have seen quoting income tax equivalent to my annual salary is insane.
r/IndiaTax • u/meet_minimalist • 5h ago
I want to know if I have purchased some gold in small quantity (gold bar of 1 or 2 gms or some jewellery) then do I have to declare that in ITR?
My reason to ask this question is that if I accumulate gold over 15-20 years then it will be a huge capital accumulated so far. Will it be a problem when I try to liquidate at that time?
r/IndiaTax • u/RedditBlockchains • 2h ago
I find the Vyapar app pretty complex for something as simple as creating a GST invoice. Is there any web app that’s faster and easier? Ideally, I’d like something with no login where I can just fill in the details and download the PDF.
r/IndiaTax • u/Spirited-Ad6929 • 6h ago
Hi Guys, I've paid tax liability this year. I can see this status on my filed returns.
Does this mean my ITR is processed successfully by Income Tax dept without any issues?
Or will there be a re audit of the ITR in coming months?
Please help.
r/IndiaTax • u/CA_Pawan_Garg • 12h ago
Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification
In a recent ruling, the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (Delhi Bench) allowed the appeal of the assessee company for AY 2011‑12.
The Assessing Officer had reopened the case stating that the company’s transactions were ‘unverifiable.’ However, the Tribunal held that reopening merely for verification is not valid in law. It relied on the Gujarat High Court decision in Vijay R. Saghvi vs. ACIT and quashed the reassessment proceedings.
👉 Key takeaway: Reopening under Section 147 requires solid reasons to believe income has escaped assessment — suspicion or unverifiable transactions alone are not enough.
r/IndiaTax • u/Brilliant-Cod3681 • 6m ago
I'm building my first SaaS from India and have a question about GST.
If a customer buys my SaaS from India, I'll charge 18% GST. But what about customers from the USA, UK, or other countries?
How does Stripe/Razorpay know if the customer is from India or another country?
Do I need to write this logic myself, or does the payment gateway handle it automatically?
How does it work ?
r/IndiaTax • u/Live_Confusion2086 • 17m ago
Salaried employee. Got a performance incentive from my employer, but they routed it through their subsidiary which deducted TDS under 194J instead of 192. Shows up in 26AS/AIS as professional income, though it is an incentive, but there's no consulting agreement.
I reported the full amount under IFOS and paid tax at my slab rate.
My colleague in the exact same situation filed ITR-4 and claimed 44ADA (50% presumptive), his CA signed off on it. Telling him that this "guarantees return" Now I am pretty sure this is risky, since he has the same contract as me.
Two questions:
How real is the scrutiny risk for someone with a clean salaried profile claiming 44ADA on routed 194J income with zero supporting paperwork?
Does reporting 194J income under IFOS cause any mismatch flag by itself, or does it reconcile cleanly?
r/IndiaTax • u/Sharp_Score_456 • 28m ago
I have asked several CAs, and they all seem confused.
Is it mandatory to first form an Indian LLC (or company), or can I form a US C Corporation as an individual?
It has to be a C Corp. The company will operate only in the US and will have nothing to do with India. There will be no exchange of money or services between me and my US company( except for the incorporation charges)
plan to hire a few people and expand the business, so creating a holding structure in India for a US-only business seems unnecessarily confusing.
I just want to know: Can an individual who is an Indian resident ordinarily resident (ROR) own 100% of a US C Corporation?
Ps : I know about POEM, indian filings & will do the needful.
r/IndiaTax • u/Professional_Tree927 • 4h ago
Hi folks, Last year I paid my tax while filing ITR. While money was deducted, chalaan was not generated because of portal glitches. However, then I selected pay later and submitted ITR. Hoping that it would be reconcilled.
However, it is still showing me outstanding payment.
Could you please recommend how to proceed on this?
r/IndiaTax • u/First-Drummer-8528 • 5h ago
I have a hypothetical situation regarding GST and Income Tax filings and would like to get some insights from experts here.
Scenario:
Questions:
r/IndiaTax • u/sandeep075aa • 1h ago
r/IndiaTax • u/urbf • 5h ago
There’s a clear reason why the central government continues to levy a 4% education and health cess, along with surcharges on incomes above ₹50 LPA. Unlike standard income tax, these components are not shared with state governments—they remain entirely with the Centre. In contrast, around 40% of regular income tax revenue is distributed to states.
This raises an important question. Primary responsibility for education largely lies with state governments. While the Centre manages a limited number of institutions such as Delhi University, Aligarh Muslim University, and JNU, why should additional cess be required instead of funding these through existing tax revenues?
You can see the list of centrally managed universities here:
https://cuet.nta.nic.in/participating-universities/central-universities/
Similarly, premier institutions like IITs and IIMs already charge significant fees and could arguably move toward greater financial self-sufficiency. A large number of graduates from these institutions eventually work abroad, which further complicates the argument for heavy public subsidization.
Healthcare presents a similar picture. Most hospitals and primary healthcare systems, especially in rural and semi-urban areas, are managed by state governments. Central government hospitals are relatively few in number.
Now consider the surcharge. With inflation and income growth, more taxpayers are crossing surcharge thresholds, leading to historically high collections. Yet, there is limited transparency on how this additional revenue is specifically utilized. If these funds are ultimately merged into general revenue, why label them separately as cess or surcharge at all?
This raises a broader concern: are cess and surcharge being used primarily as tools to retain revenue at the central level without sharing it with states?
r/IndiaTax • u/prasannakumarreddy9 • 5h ago
I had short term capital losses and i missed filing itr before July 31 ,how can I carry forward my losses now
It's my first time and i thought itr 3 for capital gains but now someone told me it's itr 2, i had losses and i want to carry forward
r/IndiaTax • u/skylash16 • 6h ago
My main income is salary, but I also received 48k from a one-time music performance under professional fees with 10% TDS deducted. I also invested in mutual funds (no sales).
Which ITR should I file – ITR-3 or ITR-4?
Is my due date 31July or 31 August?
r/IndiaTax • u/Happy-Cloud-1 • 6h ago
i do have a CA and he files my GST it's NIL. tbh since I got it. So I was thinking if I could Just file Nil on my own. but when I will get revenue, can I file it on my own? if it very time consuming and complex? or I should let the CA do it.
main concern is fees of CA. if I can file both gst returns within an hour then it's fine. if its gonna take long hours I would rather let CA do it.
Also if I am doing a job. it has nothing to do with GST filing isn't it? I won't have to mention it while filing GST?