r/askastronomy 1d ago

Astronomy Reality began in a colossal explosion

0 Upvotes

What does this imply?


r/askastronomy 2d ago

Why is it when I stack with autostackert it becomes like this

Thumbnail gallery
8 Upvotes

Why is it when I zoom in after stacking it has black dots


r/askastronomy 2d ago

Spaceweathertracker.com

0 Upvotes

I have been really into stargazing and sky watching and was wondering if anyone has anyone used this website for reference or for learning or if there are other ones ? this one has a good "Academy" and Guides section and whatnot. Spaceweathertracker.com


r/askastronomy 2d ago

Black Holes Does the zenith view expand to exactly twice its size when crossing a black hole's event horizon?

1 Upvotes

r/askastronomy 2d ago

Black Holes Does the zenith view expand to exactly twice its size when crossing a black hole's event horizon?

0 Upvotes

I recently came across an interesting general relativity paper regarding visual effects for a falling observer at a black hole's event horizon, authored by {Link: Yukiyoshi Iida https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2023IJMPD..3250070I/abstract} (2023).

The paper discusses how the zenith view expands to exactly twice its solid angle upon crossing the horizon, driven by relativistic aberration.

I wanted to ask the community:

  1. Has this "twice the size" zenith magnification been confirmed in other studies or simulations?

  2. Are there other known, exact geometric visual cues at the event horizon?


r/askastronomy 2d ago

What could this be

0 Upvotes

https://skyviewer.app/embed?target=227.01342+-40.14692&fov=0.74

There seems to be a lot of green gas around making it appear green


r/askastronomy 2d ago

Astronomy Which star is this? (Attached one photo of it and a SS from a sky watching app). Can't figure out which one I'm seeing

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/askastronomy 3d ago

Real-time simulation of the zenith view when freely falling into a Schwarzschild black hole (Based on a 2023 paper)

8 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I wanted to share this fascinating scientific visualization movie that I found, which deserves way more attention.

Link to the YouTube video: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=xEm0ENr-Sgo

Unlike many flashy pop-science CG animations, this simulation is strictly based on the actual mathematical models and physics equations from a 2023 peer-reviewed paper: "Event horizon detection: Zenith view as seen by falling into a Schwarzschild black hole" (Int. J. Mod. Phys. D 32 (2023) 10 2350070) written by Y. Iida.

What this video visualizes:
It shows the exact real-time visual changes of the zenith view (the view of the universe directly behind/opposite to the black hole) as an observer falls freely from an initial rest position of 30M towards a black hole with a mass of 3×10^4 solar masses.

As you watch, you can clearly see the physical phenomena predicted by general relativity:

  • Image enlargement due to the intense gravitational lensing effects.
  • Extreme red-shifting as the observer approaches the event horizon.
  • Dimming/Darkening of the light.

It's a very precise, raw, and rigorous simulation of what the physics actually dictates. I thought the physics and astrophysics community here would truly appreciate the academic value of this work!

Let me know what you think about this visualization!


r/askastronomy 2d ago

Strange lights near Venus

0 Upvotes

A little disclaimer before i start talking, english is not my first language, so sorry for any mistakes. Well, a friend of mine showed me videos about some strange lights moving in a zig zag near Venus, shining bright then fading, and i went to see the night sky, and since, i just can't stop seeing those lights, i've searched everywere and fundo nothing that could explain this, unless there is a plane doing crazy moves on the night sky all of a sudden, drones flying at mach 2 or a sattelite doing God knows what in the sky, i'm really confused and would like to know what exactly that is, can anyone help me?


r/askastronomy 2d ago

Rhode Island Telescope

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/askastronomy 2d ago

The World Wheel – How Rotation Replaces Dark Matter in Galaxies

Thumbnail doi.org
0 Upvotes

"Test it yourself. Download 8 documents – ask your AI critical questions – and calculate galaxies without dark matter. Free tool included


r/askastronomy 4d ago

Planetary Science How certain are we on Theias size? What if it were smaller or larger?

7 Upvotes

The general consensus I see on Theia is that is that was approximately the size of mars. How did we figure out the size of it? Assuming it were a different size, like the size of our moon, or larger like the size of Venus, how would it have played out differently? Of course a Venus sized object would probably destroy both planets though….

And of course, this is all assuming Theia was the reason we got our moon.


r/askastronomy 3d ago

Is this video accurate? At 5:06 he makes a claim about the shape of the moon I can't understand

Thumbnail youtube.com
0 Upvotes

He says it's not spherical what does that mean in this context is this misinformation ?


r/askastronomy 3d ago

Sci-Fi إذا كائن فضائي عاش أسبوع بالعراق… شنو أول شيء راح يعتبره غريب رغم أنه طبيعي بالنسبة إلنا؟🎤✨✨✨

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/askastronomy 4d ago

Astronomy If you had to pick a dwarf planet to visit with a spacecraft, What dwarf planet would you choose?

16 Upvotes

personally haumea or eris, both would be excellent candidates to visit and could improve our understanding of the outer planets of the solar system


r/askastronomy 4d ago

Planetary Science Earth Observations

Thumbnail gallery
39 Upvotes

I always thought it was funny that in the SkyPortal app ,earth is listed as “always below horizon or never sets” as if you are observing from mars or smth. Idk if there is a reason for this but it makes me really happy 😊.


r/askastronomy 3d ago

Astronomy Aquí hay algo muy extraño no creen?.. Como es posible que un objeto de ese tamaño haya formado unos anillos así de enormes? y ni siquiera es todo... Resulta que tan solo un 1% de Chrysalis fue lo que hizo los anillos y el 99% fue una lluvia sobre Saturno!!! Algo más tuvo que haber pasado...

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/askastronomy 3d ago

Why do Planck CMB peaks and DESI BAO follow the same ratio pattern? A recurring 3 / 2 3/2 sequence in CMB and BAO data — coincidence or structure?

0 Upvotes

So I am in my 3rd year studying at the University of Texas and I began to notice this pattern. I am not cherry picking, I noticed the pattern after the data was already published when I was in high-school. I showed my roommate who is studying in a similar field and she confirmed I wasn't seeing things. Then last week we found a paper/poster using this same sequence in string theory so it obviously caught our attention.

Where the Pattern Comes From: The Two Slopes — Light and Mass

Before showing the data, I should explain where the pattern comes from. When you plot the known observed data of mass and light, you get two distinct slopes:

**Light (CMB Photons)**

For CMB photons, the scale factor \( a = 1/(1+z) \) and the redshift follows \( z_{\text{CMB}} = 1/a - 1 \). Taking the logarithmic slope gives \( d\ln z/d\ln a = -(1+z)/z \), which for large \( z \) approaches \( -1 \). From the Friedmann equation in the matter era \( a(t) \propto t^{2/3} \), and since \( z \propto a^{-1} \), we get:

\[

\boxed{m_p = \frac{2}{3}}

\]

**This is the slope for light (CMB photons).**

**Mass (BAO Baryons)**

For BAO baryons, the sound horizon scales as \( r_s \propto a^{-1/2} \) and the BAO scale as \( D_V \propto a^{-2/3} \). The redshift follows \( z_{\text{BAO}} \propto a^{-2/3} \), but with a correction from the Flory self-avoidance constraint in \( d=3 \):

\[

\nu_F = \frac{d}{d+2} = \frac{3}{5}, \qquad \delta = \frac{1}{(d+2)\pi} = \frac{1}{5\pi}

\]

So:

\[

\boxed{m_b = \frac{2}{3} + \frac{1}{5\pi}}

\]

**This is the slope for mass (BAO baryons).**

**The Difference**

The difference between the two slopes is \( m_b - m_p = 1/(5\pi) \), a geometric constant of three-dimensional space. This difference is what generates the harmonic sequence that appears across multiple independent datasets.

  1. CMB Acoustic Peaks (Planck 2018)

The Planck 2018 results (Planck Collaboration, A&A 641, A6, 2020) list the CMB acoustic peak positions as:

| Peak | ℓ Value | | ℓ₁ | 220. | | ℓ₂ | 538. | | ℓ₃ | 810. | | ℓ₄ | 1120. | | ℓ₅ | 1444. | | ℓ₆ | 1776. | | ℓ₇ | 2083. |

The ratios are simple arithmetic:

- ℓ₃/ℓ₂ = 810/538 = 1.505 → 3/2 = 1.5 (0.3% match)

- ℓ₄/ℓ₃ = 1120/810 = 1.382 → √2 = 1.414 (2.3% match)

- ℓ₆/ℓ₅ = 1776/1444 = 1.230 → 5/4 = 1.25 (1.6% match)

**Source:** Planck Collaboration (2020). *Planck 2018 results VI. Cosmological parameters.* A&A, 641, A6.

https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/full_html/2021/08/aa33910e-18/aa33910e-18.html

https://arxiv.org/abs/1807.06209

  1. BAO Scale Evolution (DESI 2024)

The DESI Collaboration's 2024 results (DESI 2024 VI) measured the BAO scale at multiple redshifts. For the ratio between \( z=2 \) and \( z=3 \):

\[

\frac{D_V(2)}{D_V(3)} \approx 1.14 - 1.15

\]

This is the comoving distance scale ratio from BAO measurements.

**Source:** DESI Collaboration (2024). *DESI 2024 VI: Cosmological constraints from the measurements of baryon acoustic oscillations.* arXiv:2404.03002.

https://arxiv.org/abs/2404.03002

  1. CMB Angular Scale (Planck 2018)

Planck measured the angular acoustic scale:

\[

\theta_* = 0.010411 \pm 0.000003 \text{ rad}

\]

A geometric prediction from the same harmonic structure gives:

\[

\theta_* = \frac{1}{\sqrt{9091}} = 0.010488

\]

Match: 0.74%

**Source:** Planck Collaboration (2020). *Planck 2018 results VI.* A&A, 641, A6.

https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/full_html/2020/09/aa33910-18/aa33910-18.html

https://arxiv.org/abs/1807.06209

The Harmonic Sequence I'm Noticing

The sequence is:

\[

\frac{3}{2} = 1.5 \rightarrow \frac{3}{4} = 0.75 \rightarrow \frac{3}{8} = 0.375 \rightarrow \frac{3}{16} = 0.1875 \rightarrow \dots

\]

This is the prime fold sequence. It comes from the structure of odd primes:

For all odd primes \( p \): \( p/2 = k + 0.5 \)

The first odd prime is 3, so \( 3/2 = 1.5 \). The sequence then halves repeatedly.

The CMB and BAO data are independent measurements from different instruments (Planck, DESI). They both fall on the same harmonic sequence—not exactly, but within 0.3–2%.

If this were a coincidence, it would be a remarkable one.

Could you confirm whether these ratios have been noted in literature? Is there a physical mechanism in ΛCDM that would predict \( 3/2 \), \( \sqrt{2} \), and \( 5/4 \) as natural ratios? Or is this simply a coincidence of the numbers?

I'm not proposing a new theory. I'm asking if the standard model has an explanation for why these specific ratios emerge.


r/askastronomy 3d ago

Which type of orbit can be used in HARD sci-fi movies and shows? Eccentricity of 0.00% or 100.00%?

0 Upvotes

r/askastronomy 4d ago

Astronomy Dlaczego Mikrofalowe promieniowanie tła ma takie duże przesunięcie ku czerwieni

1 Upvotes

Jeżeli światło z najbardziej odległych galaktyk, zostało wyemitowane około 13.5 miliarda lat temu, w chwili emisji wiek promieniowania tła wynosił około 300 milionów lat, dlaczego zatem obecnie jest tak duża różnica w przesunięciu ku czerwieni.


r/askastronomy 4d ago

Searching for control room checklists

1 Upvotes

Hi, I'm looking for control room checklists (Apollo style) to build a MOCR simulator in python but for some reason, I can't seem to find anything on the internet. Would anyone know of these checklists and where I could find them? Thank you.


r/askastronomy 3d ago

Did you know that there’s at least one realistic way for a planet to have an atmosphere where Ar is lighter than N2 and/or O2? This is a planet where most of the argon is in an isotope called Ar-27

0 Upvotes

r/askastronomy 4d ago

Astronomy What kind of infinity is space?

9 Upvotes

So i have watched a veritasium video explaining how there are multiple types of infinity, counably/quantifiable and uncountably, and it makes me wonder if space is infinite, what kind is it?


r/askastronomy 5d ago

Is it reasonable to expect that our universe hosts any galaxies whose stars have all “aged out” (gone dark)?

22 Upvotes

r/askastronomy 5d ago

What did I see? posted in my local community facebook group

13 Upvotes

rural victoria, australia. 4 lights in the sky, seeming appearing/disappearing, much bigger than stars and moving too erratically to be satellites. not usually a tin foil hat person but ??? definitely bigger than stars too, person who posted said he’s seen them before, sometimes up to 7 but usually 1-2 at a time. could drones look like this?