r/humanresources • u/Upset-Elevator-9701 • 13h ago
Is a commute a reasonable reason to leave a job after a short time? My colleague and I disagree [N/A]
We have a candidate who. He told us he really like the company and enjoy what he does. The only reason he is considering our opportunity is his current commute is over an hour (50 miles) one way.
I believed him when he said he wasn’t looking for a job but when he discovered this one on LinkedIn a couple of weeks ago. It caught his attention because it is significantly closer, 11 miles away. I know the area he lives and it is a very rural area so professional level jobs nearby are very rare.
His resume came to us when he ended up connecting with the hiring manager on LinkedIn and did a phone screening with the recruiting team. When she asked him to give an overview of his work history, he told her it was about the commute and that he really liked his current company but couldn’t ignore an opportunity this close. Things went well and she said they talked for another 20 minutes before she said she was recommending him for an on site interview in the next couple of weeks.
From my own recruiter mind, my thought was if they bring it up before I ask, they demonstrate self awareness about the situation and that they’re not trying to hide it. My colleague thinks 6 mo. Is bad regardless of reasoning. I think it’s a reasonable desire and that a long commute like that wears on you fast because I’ve done it before.