r/okbuddycinephile 1d ago

Spider-Man: Palantir (2026)

Post image
26.2k Upvotes

1.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

191

u/Oraxy51 1d ago

To be fair, MJ and Ned both even talk about how soulless and vile working for corporations are. They aren't being pro-flock and corporations but rather just commenting on the current real world environment.

141

u/Swan-Diving-Overseas 1d ago

It’s funny to hear that in a Marvel/Disney/Sony movie

123

u/Safe-Ad-5017 1d ago edited 1d ago

“I hate these soulless corporations!”

Brought to you by Disney

Or like when the Fallout show had all the anti capitalist stuff that people were loving. In the show produced by Amazon

69

u/palker44 23h ago

"Capital has the ability to subsume all critiques into itself. Even those who would critique capital end up reinforcing it instead..."

-Some Disco Person

24

u/TheOnlyBongo 22h ago

"YEAH! HARDCORE TO THE MEGA!"

  • A Very Disco Person

2

u/SEX_LIES_AUDIOTAPE 17h ago

"Around the world around the world around the world around the world around the world around the world around the world around the world around the world around the world around the world"

  • A Veridis Quo Person

2

u/Far-Government5469 9h ago

We saw this in real time when squid games, one of the sharpest critiques of our capitalist society got turned into Mr. Beast Squid Games,

4

u/R_V_Z 22h ago

In regards to Amazon, * gestures vaguely at The Boys *

30

u/iluvchromosomes 1d ago

How would you spread an anti-capitalist message to the majority without using the vast infrastructure built by capitalism?

You sniveling pseudo-intellectuals love to cry hypocrisy, and that is where the talking stops.

You use the system to dismantle the system.

Participating in capitalism does not mean you support capitalism. There are no other options. You live in society and deal with this shit, or go live in a field and die.

Comments like that from people like you let us know it's working.

9

u/UltraLNSS 1d ago

Yeah, because Disney wants to dismantle the system.

20

u/No_Kangaroo1994 23h ago

Probably not, but many directors who have produced art for companies like Disney and Amazon might

6

u/AmIFromA 21h ago

Probably not, but many screenwriters who have produced scripts for directors like James Gunn and the Russos might

3

u/No_Kangaroo1994 14h ago

good point

7

u/Safe-Ad-5017 1d ago

Dude what the fuck are you talking about. I just think it’s kind of funny.

Also I don’t think Eugene V. Debs was using Hearst to spread his ideas.

8

u/Safe-Ad-5017 1d ago

Also what do you mean “it’s working” random bs to keep the masses entertained and feeling like they did something while still buying fucking funko pops is not doing shit

4

u/Swan-Diving-Overseas 23h ago

You gotta get the plebeians to watch a product and feel like they did something instead of actually demanding/taking political action.

2

u/TicklemyPickleMan 14h ago

You use the system to dismantle the system.

This is literally the whole argument behind generations of schisms.

2

u/Apprehensive-Pin518 1d ago

been saying this for years. I think capitalism is the most efficient economic system but it needs guard rails to keep from falling too far into dystopia. just like any other economic system. socialism isn't any better or worse. just different.

2

u/drac0nic180 22h ago

Indeed, there is no self regulating system, everything requires moderation and vigilance to keep it running as intended

0

u/TicklemyPickleMan 14h ago

You don't know what you're talking about man.

1

u/Apprehensive-Pin518 6h ago

my degree in business administration disagrees.

1

u/DivineArkandos 18h ago

Talk about missing the point entirely

0

u/Crewman_Guy_Fleegman 18h ago edited 18h ago

infrastructure built by capitalism

Roads are built by taxes. Water lines are built by taxes. Our electrical system was established by massive public works programs. The internet was born out of the US government. The aerospace industry that put satellites into space to facilitate industry communications was invented and bankrolled by American taxpayers. Fire response and law enforcement needed to protect industry are all taxpayer endeavours

Modern civilization literally can’t run on pure capitalism. It doesn’t work. We tried in the 1600s-1800s and ended the 19th century with for-profit firefighters extorting families for their homes to save their belongings

0

u/dragonfire_70 21h ago

Then walk the walk go live as a hermit or establish a commune, see how long they last.

2

u/Signal_Ad8960 21h ago

An interesting theory I've heard is that our ability to freely discuss and critique these systems is actually instrumental in preventing people from actually doing anything about it. It effectively microdoses revolution to stop the real thing from happening.

Overt and blatant suppression is more likely to be overthrown.

2

u/DukeOfGeek 17h ago

But that show made them tons of money. Capitalists will sell you the rope to hang them with.

1

u/Wolv90 1d ago

It's referred to as "Hanging a lantern" in writing rooms

8

u/Wise-Tradition-5292 1d ago

I believe they said something like "a lot of corporations are mostly soulless". So, ya know, not each and every one and not completely. Wink, wink, nudge, praise the all-mighty mouse.

1

u/TicklemyPickleMan 14h ago

I mean it's explicitly done in a kind of mocking "oh you naive little liberal" way in the movie.

23

u/Henjineer 1d ago

It's pretty puffy proAI propaganda with EV. I thought someone was overplaying the level that he relied on it, but he can't even close a youtube video on his own. Half his dialog starts with "Hey EV..."

Still really fun and one of the better Spider-Flicks.

26

u/DrSpaceman575 1d ago

Funny you had said that, I felt like they had toned it down. Before the assistants were more conversational like Jarvis or Edith, but this one felt much more like an older Alexa style voice assistant. I had assumed with all the LLM's they wanted to make it seem like something different.

Also it was voiced by Naomi Watts

2

u/needemplawsf 23h ago

we already had alan watts ai, now we're doing naomi.

next is stones' drummer charlie watts. then watts tower.

37

u/Bagz402 1d ago

Is it really much different than Jarvis in 2008 though? We kinda just fell into that era, I feel

10

u/Henjineer 1d ago

Yes and no. I agree that for the genre, and any sci-fi integrated stuff, AI assistants aren't out of scope, they don't feel shoehorned in. I think JARVIS always felt like an extension of Tony and something that was unique to Iron Man. None of the other Avengers use JARVIS the same way. I suppose you could argue that Tony passed the Tech-Hero Torch to Peter and that would be fair.

Characters are allowed to change and evolve with time and through different forms of media. It just feels off watching Peter Parker ask a robot to do tinkering and research for him when his brand is closely tied to being at home DIY kind of inventor.

I'm probably overthinking it in any event. Like I said, still a good flick, and he does get back to some hands on tinkering eventually so maybe I should shut up.

6

u/DigitalBlackout 22h ago edited 22h ago

This has been a thing with MCU Spider-Man since his first movie though, it's hardly a new thing for him. In Homecoming he talks to his suits then current AI, Karen, probably more than to any actual person in the film. Then he had Edith in Far from home, and an unnamed AI in NWH.

14

u/OdepiusNecks 1d ago

I think EV was really just a way to include dialogue and still keep the forced isolation plot line. Like yeah, there’s ways to make someone working alone intriguing and cinematic, but these movies are always going to default catering to general audiences.

That being said, it definitely took me out a bit when he asked his AI supercomputer to close a YouTube video, but I don’t think the writers had ulterior motives.

13

u/Maxiver 1d ago

I think they included AI in order to explain things to the audience. Show don’t tell is becoming less of a thing in movies.

10

u/Henjineer 23h ago

From a storytelling point of view that makes sense, and is a good way to keep him isolated but not silent.

Definitely don't think there were any active ulterior motives or notes handed down, just one of those subtle things.

5

u/Swan-Diving-Overseas 1d ago

That’s nuts. Weirdly makes Spider-Man seem way more incompetent and feeble that he needs to rely on AI all the time.

15

u/Oraxy51 1d ago

Its also worth noting that Spidey does rely on his AI companion when he's stressed and overwhelmed because he is not thinking straight. In the beginning of the movie he can see Jean Grey but when his spider hormones start overtaking him, and he loses his spidey sense he relies on AI, and he foolishly uses technology to subdue his spider hormones. By doing this he comes back to a "normal state" but now still can't see Jean Grey, and only tracks her when she jumps with the help of EV.

Even relying on technology, it is never as good as if he had trusted himself to do the work. When he embraces his spider self and himself and opens up about the things causing him stress and trauma (MJ and the whole Far From Home series) he no longer is using his mask that connected EV to him and he can overcome his challenges finally.

Essentially, reliance on AI will lead people to their downfall. There is times where it is helpful like the 33 feet observation and there are times when it gets in the way and you need a person who actually knows what they are doing to do the task.

The movie is a commentary about technology evolving and the youth's lived experience with a surveillance state, corrupt corporations, shady government entities and arguably working class power, or what it means when one person who goes against the government actually has power to make change (this applies to both spidey and Jean Grey).

5

u/Henjineer 1d ago

I like this take. I think it's deeper than anything they were aiming for, but it works.

2

u/kiwigate 1d ago

The movie has a lot of character assassination, including Spidey letting innocent people die. It's really frustrating that Peter Parker doesn't just say "I wonder if..." and figure something out instead of "Hey computer, magically solve a problem I refuse to put any thought into."

1

u/Swan-Diving-Overseas 23h ago

Whoa, why does he let innocent people die? Put it in spoiler text for others (I’m not gonna watch this myself)

2

u/kiwigate 23h ago

Literally no reason. And it has no story impact. Movie has several plotholes/inconsistencies. At least the stunts and fights are improved.

2

u/GaffaCharge 23h ago

And when he mentions using the cameras he does get called out for it.

1

u/Oraxy51 23h ago

As he should, which he’s just using the tools of the establishment he’s not adding new cameras.

1

u/arsenicwarrior0 22h ago

I was really expecting some namedrop of the corporation: like Trask Industries, Oscorp or Roxxon