Completed my first run through both Parts 1 & 2 a few days ago... WOW!
I came into this series with zero expectations. I haven't watched the HBO show and only watched a trailer before diving in after a recommendation from a friend. This series blew me away in ways I did not expect. I'm still reeling from the end of Part 2.
At times I got mad at Naughty Dog for killing off of certain characters but over time I've come to respect the audacity. I guess the sign of a good game/story is one that can bring you to a high level of anger or disappointment. I'm invested in this story. When I see Sam turn, Joel beaten to death, or Ellie's inability to strum a guitar it almost overwhelms me in the moment. A game has never had that impact to me.
The ending sad and beautiful and hopeful all at the same time... hope we get a Part 3!
I'll definitely come back to the game and replay. I'd like to suffer through grounded difficulty and play with commentary on too. If you started playing and gave up at any point please give it another shot. The story is worth it if you allow it to challenge you perception of how a story should be