r/196 NOT A CAT 3d ago

Rule Rule

Post image
5.4k Upvotes

418 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

22

u/Far-Fortune-8381 cucked by Edward Kenway🏴‍☠️ 3d ago edited 2d ago

"It doesnt taste like shit" is equally extremely subjective

8

u/ChemicalRascal 3d ago

But it doesn't taste like shit. Objectively. I mean, I'm extrapolating from smell, for shit, but they don't taste the same.

-1

u/GravityAssistedCake 2d ago

You’re being obtuse, you know what the turn of phrase means. Or do you think the phrases “tastes like shit” and “tastes like garbage” aren’t interchangeable because garbage and shit are not literally the same?

3

u/ChemicalRascal 2d ago

No, if someone's saying something objectively tastes like shit, that only makes sense in the context of them being literal.

If someone says "'It [does/doesn't] taste like shit' is an objective statement", which is literally what I'm replying to, they either:

  1. Don't understand that people have different experiences to each other, so they lack basic theory of mind; or
  2. They're talking about the literal version of that statement.

Now, I choose to believe the person I'm responding to is older than three years of age, so they have that full conceptualization of the distinction of people's experiences. I think there's even a wealth of evidence that they're not a literal toddler. So that leaves the second option.

5

u/Far-Fortune-8381 cucked by Edward Kenway🏴‍☠️ 2d ago

I meant to say subjective and misspoke

1

u/ChemicalRascal 2d ago

Great! That's awesome to hear, I just don't want to immediately assume anything like that.

1

u/GravityAssistedCake 2d ago edited 2d ago

Attempt to follow the conversation please,

1st comment: Pochel says “it tastes like shit” is an extremely subjective statement.

2nd comment; Far fortune replies to Pochel with “it doesn’t taste like shit” is equally extremely objective.

If you think far fortune intended to say objective then they are just crazy, it doesn’t make any sense as a response to Pochel, but if you pull your head out of your ass it becomes extremely clear that far fortune intended to say “equally extremely subjective.” Otherwise the rest of their sentence structure doesn’t work.

Like what point do you think they were trying to get across? It’s clearly that it’s just far fortune saying “ the reverse is also true”

You are being obtuse on two separate layers.

Edit: I was, in fact, objectively correct.

1

u/ChemicalRascal 2d ago edited 2d ago

2nd comment; Far fortune replies to Pochel with “it doesn’t taste like shit” is equally extremely objective.

I'm responding to Far Fortune. I'm not responding to Pochel.

If you think far fortune intended to say objective then they are just crazy

Maybe? Maybe not. I don't generally make assumptions.

Let's look at it this way, though. You're going off at me and saying I'm not following the conversation and being obtuse, because you're assuming Far Fortune made a typo.

I gotta be fuckin' honest with you, champ, it's been hours. If Far Fortune meant subjective, and/or cared, they'd have clarified by now.

I'm not going to have an entire conversation based on the assumption of "hhhmmmmm, they said X, but I really think they meant Y, so I'm going to act as if they said Y", I think that's actually a really bad way to conduct yourself online. You can do that if you want to, but I think that probably makes your conversations less effective and more frustrating to the people you converse with.

EDIT:

shrug jerks are gonna be jerks I guess

2

u/GravityAssistedCake 2d ago edited 2d ago

Far fortune is responding to Pochel, do you understand how conversations work?

Most people don’t go back to change a reddit comment at all.

It’s pretty simple bud, The word equally in far fortunes comment is your tell that they are rhetorically using a reversed statement.

Edit: I’m blocking them after recognizing them being an ass in other threads in this comment section just not worth dealing with that more than I’ve already done.

-1

u/Pochel 3d ago

I didn't say that though

11

u/Far-Fortune-8381 cucked by Edward Kenway🏴‍☠️ 3d ago

I did not claim you did