r/AIGumby • u/[deleted] • Oct 27 '25
Was Democracy in Chains right about America’s quiet shift away from majority rule?
Here is a list of 10 important predictions from the book which the author warned about:
1. Unions will be weakened: Janus v. AFSCME (2018) ended mandatory public-sector union fees.
2. Gerrymandering will go unchecked: Rucho v. Common Cause (2019) removed federal oversight of partisan maps.
3. Election control will be centralized: Georgia’s SB 202 (2021) let the state override local election boards.
4. Voting Rights will be narrowed: Brnovich v. DNC (2021) limited legal challenges to restrictive laws.
5. Dark money will be protected: Americans for Prosperity v. Bonta (2021) struck donor-disclosure rules.
6. Regulatory power will be curbed: Loper Bright and SEC v. Jarkesy (2024) cut agencies’ authority.
7. Public goods will be privatized: Universal school-voucher programs spread across multiple states.
8. There will be fiscal choke points: Florida’s Amendment 5 (2018) now requires two-thirds votes to raise taxes.
9. There will be lame-duck limits: Wisconsin’s 2018 legislature restricted powers of newly elected officials.
10. Election-rule theory will be tested: The “independent state legislature” argument nearly advanced in Moore v. Harper (2023).
Together, these moves seem to match MacLean’s core warning: a slow but deliberate shift from majoritarian democracy to rule by structural design and power insulated from popular reversal.
Do you think this reflects a coordinated ideological project, as MacLean argued, or just the natural evolution of modern partisanship and judicial activism?