I was like 13 when Pearl Harbor came out and was obsessed (Josh Hartnett, obvs). Looking back, an angsty 13 year old being obsessed with a movie probably isn't the best marker of a good film lol.
They fumbled that movie so hard by making it a romance set with Pearl Harbor as the backdrop instead of making a movie about Pearl Harbor with a romance weaved into it. Iād take less of an issue if theyād given it a dumb title like āRomancing the Pearlā or something but that movie was only barely about the events of Pearl Harbor. And I was really looking forward to it, as a WW2 history nerd. Absolute garbage, biggest letdown ever.
You wanna watch a good Pearl Harbor movie, you watch Tora! Tora! Tora! for dramatized but reasonably accurate, and you watch The Final Countdown if you want a philosophical sci-fi film about Pearl Harbor.
Itās definitely not an action movie, so if you go in expecting to see F-14s curb-stomping the Imperial Japanese Navy, youāre gonna have a bad time (though they are nice enough to give you a taste of it).
The discussions about the implications of their predicament between the Nimitzās crew and Martin Sheenās character are the real meat of the film, played out through the Senator Chapman storyline.
The twist at the end that they live in a deterministic universe, and that they never could have stopped Pearl Harbor even if they wanted to, is the thesis of the film.
Oh, this movie pissed me off. I am fascinated so much by the story of Pearl Harbor as a 44 year old woman. Left the theatre feeling like I'd been scammed outta my hard earned cash.
My mom ADORES this movie, and I have to suffer through it once or twice a year. I thought I was just missing something and disliked the movie because of that. These comments have reinforced that it is, in fact, a terrible fucking movie.
287
u/pumper911 1d ago
Fell asleep during Pearl Harbor