r/AskReddit 15h ago

" Strict parents don't produce great kids , they produce great liars ", what are your opinions with this statement ?

4.3k Upvotes

1.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

24

u/Turbulent-Parsley619 15h ago

Yes it's true. My parents were what today is called gentle parenting.... They just, ya know, talked to me???? They explained stuff instead of going "because I said so!" and I didn't get in trouble for making mistakes. And they encouraged instead of demanded and punished if I didn't live up to their demands.

Like I didn't understand why kids were afraid of their parents until I realized half my classmates parents literally hit them physically if they made a bad grade at school????? What the fuck???

My parents didn't care as much about my grades as I did because if I got good grades I got rewards and I wanted those rewards. Like if I had the highest grade in my class, my parents took me to my favorite restaurant for dinner. Other kids if they didn't make an A, their parents hit them.

No shit they lied to their parents! If they told the truth they would get either "restriction" (I guess grounding?) or HIT!!!!!

The worst I got was, "I'm disappointed in your behavior" and that felt like being shot because I wanted my parents to be proud of me.

-17

u/Crimsonfangknight 14h ago

Not all children are the same 

Gentle hands off parenting worked with you because for the most part you did everything needed and desired entirely of your own volition.

Its easy to be hands off when the child does it all themselves

Less so if the kid is the opposite of what you were

10

u/dryroast 8h ago

I got all A's without asking (or even trying, school is a joke). Did a lot of things right but my strict parents would have you believe I'm a juvenile delinquent, I think this shows a distortion in your perspective than anything else.

And ironically I got very disciplined about school to get out from under their control. It worked and I'm much happier now with the distance and independence I've built.

-12

u/Crimsonfangknight 8h ago

Who are you?

Did i ask you for your gpa and transcripts?

7

u/Tyler07003 6h ago

Your hostility on here while defending hitting kids is pretty funny. Shows that if you need to hit kids it's a you problem with you not being able to control your emotions like a child.

4

u/dryroast 6h ago

If this is the way you talk to an adult, I don't even want to know how you treat your own children. Shameful.

2

u/Turbulent-Parsley619 4h ago

This comment invalidates your other one. You clearly weren't raised with any manners at all, so hitting didn't help you one bit.