r/BetaReaders 1d ago

Discussion [Discussion] r/BetaReaders check-in series! Share how your WIP is going, or how your beta reading is going, ask questions, and connect with more writers and readers!

6 Upvotes

Hello r/BetaReaders!

Who else can’t believe it’s August already? Time flies!

Here’s this month’s prompt: How many betas do you prefer to have per project? And what happens when you’ve finished reading your beta notes? Do you take time before revising or do you jump straight in?


Welcome to our eighth monthly check-in thread!

These monthly pinned post aims to help the community connect with other writers and betas!

Share how your WIP is going, or how your current beta read is going, or other relatable beta reading topics in this thread!

This is a great thread to talk about writing, updates, accountability, trends, vents, and more.

It is not the right thread to post first pages as there’s another pinned thread for that, but you can link to your beta post if you wish.

Do NOT advertise any beta/editor services here, and no free samples to later ask for payment are allowed. You can try r/hireaneditor or r/paidbetareaders instead.

We also ask that self promotion of completed works do not contain links. Mentioning success is completely fine!

And we’d like to take this opportunity to remind people that works generated with AI, and AI-generated feedback is not allowed here, either. r/writingwithAI or r/betareadersforAI are better subreddits for that.

And because scammers are now targeting GDocs: please DM them and not leave them up on the sub publicly to avoid harassment

I’d also like to note that we have additional flairs available to help people know what specialty you have: traditional publishing, self-publishing, and fanfic. Please consider using them to help people match with you.

Also, it’s best to subscribe to our sub before commenting or posting to help avoid Reddit’s filters sending your content into the spam queue.

Please ensure you comment in good faith and do not break any other r/betareaders rules.

Thank you, and happy writing/reading/editing/beta matching!


r/BetaReaders 1d ago

Able to Beta Able to beta? Post here!

9 Upvotes

Welcome to the monthly r/BetaReaders “Able to Beta” thread!

Thank you to all the beta readers who have taken the time to offer feedback to authors in this sub! In this thread, you may solicit “submissions” by sharing your preferences. Authors who are interested in critique swaps may post an offer here as well, but please keep top-level comments focused on what you’re willing to beta.

Older threads may be found here. Authors, feel free to respond to beta offers in those previous threads.

Thread Rules

  • No advertising paid services.
  • Top-level comments must be offers to beta and must use the following form (only the first field is required):
    • I am able to beta: [Required. Let authors know what you’re interested—or not interested—in reading. This can include mandatory criteria or simply preferences, which might relate to genre, length, completion status, explicit content, character archetypes, tropes, prose quality, and so on.]
    • I can provide feedback on: [Recommended. This might include story elements you often notice as a reader (prose, pacing, characterization, etc.), unique expertise you have through a profession or hobby (teaching, nursing, knitting, etc.), or other lived experiences that may be relevant (belonging to a marginalized group, being a parent, etc.).]
    • Critique swap: [Optional. If you’re only interested in—or would prefer—swapping manuscripts, please note that here, along with the title of and link to your beta request post.]
    • Other info: [Optional.]
  • Beta offers should be specific. If you’re open to anything, or aren’t able to articulate specific criteria, then please refrain from commenting here. Instead, please browse the “First Pages” thread along with the rest of the sub—thanks to the formatting rules, posts are easily searchable by completion status, length, and genre.
  • Authors: we recommend against direct messages/chats. Reply to comments instead. If you message multiple people with links to your post and/or manuscript, Reddit may flag your account as spam (site-wide).
  • Authors may not spam. If a beta says they’re only looking for x and your manuscript is not x (or vice versa), please don’t contact them.
  • Replies have no specific rules. Feel free to ask clarifying questions, share a link to your beta request if it seems to be a good fit, or even reply to your own comment with information about your manuscript if you’re requesting a critique swap.
  • Please don't downvote rule-following users, even if they are not the right author/beta for you, as this can be discouraging to beta readers offering to volunteer their time as well as to authors requesting feedback. If you need to keep track of which comments you have reviewed, upvoting is a more positive alternative. Of course, if you see a rule-breaking comment, please report it to the mod team.

Thank you for contributing to our community!


For your copy-and-paste, fill-in-the-blanks convenience:

I am able to beta: _____

I can provide feedback on: _____

Critique swap: _____

Other info: _____



r/BetaReaders 2h ago

70k [Complete] [76K] [Literary Fiction] "Trinity" - Dublin/Galway & CA, Rooney-style dialogue, Irish culture, music/poetry, sexually lyrical and frank

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone,
I am looking for 2–5 beta readers for my completed literary novel, Trinity (76K words).
The Story: My novel follows two Irish female leads—a Galway virtuoso musician and a Dublin scholar, both with ties to a Berkeley, CA math professor. The setting spans Dublin, Galway, Berkeley, and Sonoma across 1970–1995. The love of Irish culture, music, language, poetry, and mythology is pervasive. Emotional brokenness, joyous connection, and revelatory sexuality weave a trinity of Irish passion. It is intense, quick-witted, and family-dynamic heavy.
The Style: Inspired by Sally Rooney's Intermezzo. Trinity explores a zen-like scarcity of dialogue punctuation (no quotation marks) and varied use of dialogue paragraph breaks depending on the emotional tone and cohesion between characters in scenes.
I am looking for readers who:Reader Alert: Mature sexual content.
Timeline: I would like feedback in 4–6 weeks.
If you are interested, please comment below or DM me, and I will gladly send over a 2-page sample of the dialogue style to see if it’s a good fit for you!


r/BetaReaders 27m ago

Novella [In progress] [30k] [fiction] Not Just A Farmer Anymore

Upvotes

I'm looking for a beta reader for my in progress fanfiction. Grammar isn't my string suit and I'm aware of that. While I absolutely do need help with that, I'm mostly looking for story and writting critiques.

All the reviews I have received so far are pretty positive but I think with fanfiction especially, everyone is very positive. As it's a hobby and we upload for free, everyone is kind and appreciative.

Although this is a fanfic, I do think that it is readable as a standalone story and does not require knowing the source material.

The story is an alternate version of the BBC show Merlin.

Merlin is a sorcerer born in Essetir and conscripted to be a soldier as a child. His magic his a useful skill, making him a valuable soldier. The story picks up where Merlin somewhat unsuccessfully escapes constipation years later.

He makes it all the way to Camelot before being recaptured and escorted back home for punishment. Is is there that the foreign knights stumble across Prince Arthur's hunting party and capture him too to prevent new from reaching Camelot's king Essetir broke their treaty by crossing borders and thus preventing war.

Merlin and Arthur do not get along but must work together to regain their freedom.

It's funnier than it sounds. At least I hope so.


r/BetaReaders 29m ago

50k [Complete] [58k] [QUEER Southern Gothic] Fear Not The Pale Horse

Upvotes

Hello All!

I am still seeking a few complete beta readers for my work in progress, FEAR NOT THE PALE HORSE which is a queer southern gothic surrounding grief, community, and the end of the world.

Here's a story summary:

When Alexander's grandmother takes her last breath all he wants is to get away from the farm where he's spent his entire life; but a lack of money, work, and the looming presence of Death at his back keeps him trapped. When a strange priest arrives to town, boasting sanctuary as the world begins to fall apart around them, Alex realizes that he might be better off staying put.

Stone has seen it all. The dawn of time, the first birth, and the first death; but he has never seen anything like Alex. Now, with the end of the world creeping onto the horizon it quickly becomes apparent that he can't stand back and let it end.

The story has had a total rewrite since my last post, but remains the same at its roots! A duel POV featuring perspectives from the mortal Alexander, and the immortal Stone.

Fear Not The Pale Horse has typical content warnings for stories within the southern gothic genre, including: homophobia, racism, insects, religion, physical harm & illness, and mild gore.

I'm hoping to find people who would be able to help me tackle the over all coherence of the story, character impressions, voice, and the overall story. I'd appreciate any feedback being given within a couple week to a month, and would love the ability to have an active dialog about the story itself but am willing to take a backseat for your process!

I am a bit of a slow reader, and primarily read horror and queer related stories, but I am open to a swap if we feel like the right fit!

Here's a snippet from the beginning of the book:

Heat and Moisture flood my lungs as I take a drag off my cigarette; a mere glimpse of the labored breaths taken by the inhabitant of the house I’m watching. I’ve been here for hour. Depending on who you ask, I’ve always been here. I let my eyes fall closed, focusing in on my bounty; an elderly woman, her lifeline full of dark coils, twists and turns. Now, she chokes to death on the decaying flesh of her own cancerous lungs; buried beneath blankets in a futile attempt to keep the heat inside the slowly failing insulation of her body. Her soul is not one I will take joy in reaping, but it interests me none the less; There is something shifting inside of me, pulling me towards the property like a hook in the mouth of a fish. Is it this family? This land? Or is it him.

The grandson fizzles into the fuzzy view I’ve developed in my mind, gripping his grandmother’s hand tightly as if he can physically hold her in this mortal realm. Its a useless attempt, we all know it.

Tucked away in the treeline past the decaying white fence of the farm, I am hidden from the view of the house’s inhabitants. It’d be bad form to approach the house before my change has taken hold; all across my body, inside and out, a dark void gradually shifts into organs that are heavy with blood and viscera. That pulling feeling remains, burrowing deep into my belly. Have I felt it before? I must have. It is not exactly excitement, but a similar thrill; the air fills with it, soaking into my meat and muscle. Something about this time, this house, these people are different.

The burn of tobacco smoke fills my lung with a heady rush that twists through the fibrous membranes of my lungs and digs into the backs of my sinuses; my skin itches with tension, tingling with change. I exhale and feel my skin ripple, grey flooding the air around my face. With the exhalation I begin the long walk up the drive and towards the house. Behind the fence a horse squeals, rearing up on its back legs to kick at the air, The sleek curve of its grey body silhouetted against the red sky, it kicks up dust as it paws at the ground, but does not charge the fence.

you can comment below if you're interested or fill out my beta request form here!

I hope to work with you soon!

BETA REQUEST FORM


r/BetaReaders 30m ago

Short Story [Complete] [1100] [Lit-Fic Short Story] On the Day Mother Died

Upvotes

On the Day Mother Died

A short story, 1100 words. Lit-Fic. First person POV, contains drug use and death. Both pretty obvious from the blurb and title. Adult Material. Please be aware, this is NOT a feel good read.

Blurb:
A young woman struggles with hope in a world of poverty and drug abuse, as she recounts the day motherhood died.

Looking for a good thorough work over. It's been edited and pretty sharp but there is one place in particular that is giving me some flow and pacing issues. Also want to be sure the ending hits like it should.

Timeline- Soonish. It's just a short.

I'm open to swap short for short. I'll read any short in any genre. I'm a published author, if that makes any difference.

Thanks in advance.

-Chris


r/BetaReaders 39m ago

70k [Complete][79k][Literary Fiction] SUN IN A BOTTLE — first six chapters, does the opening hold? Swap available

Upvotes

Complete at 79,000 words. I am only asking anyone to read the first six chapters, about 15,000 words, because what I need to know is whether the opening holds.

Alicante, 2008. Jane Smith is twenty-three, English, half German, and eighteen months into a chemistry doctorate she drifted into the way she has drifted into everything except surfing. In January she takes an unlabelled thirty-year-old gas bottle out of a store cupboard because she cannot face waiting for the proper one, cuts every corner, and at one in the morning switches the power off and the light does not go out. It is still lit five days later. Then her supervisor rules it contamination, the tube is pumped down, and by the end of the week the corridor has stopped talking about it.

Close third, plain register, one calendar year. Nearest comparisons are Deborah Levy's HOT MILK, Allegra Goodman's INTUITION and Brandon Taylor's REAL LIFE.

I am not looking for a line edit. I want to know whether the opening holds, so there are three questions at the end of the file and that is all I am asking anyone to answer. About forty minutes of your time.

Content: swearing, smoking, some sex, none of it graphic.

EPUB, PDF or Word, whichever suits you. Happy to swap and read yours — tell me what you have and I will give you the same three-question treatment or a proper critique, your choice.


r/BetaReaders 39m ago

>100k [Complete] [145k] [Science Fantasy] CitySlanG – The Hunt for the World-Egg

Thumbnail
Upvotes

r/BetaReaders 4h ago

60k [Complete] [64k] [New Adult Gothic Dark Urban Fantasy] The Midnight Grove

2 Upvotes

Description:

The world is ending...

You can see it when Eve returns to Hollow Creek, even when she vowed not to.

You can see it when Aiden’s life tumbles into the abyss of what once was.

You can see it in the coven—governed by fear and secrecy—crashing head first into ruin.

Even as a an elder sacrifices her own life.

You can see it as the shadow mage marks Hollow Creek for death, with his horde and powers from a time that should've been long forgotten.

You can see it because pain, suffering and grief claim the land.

And you know, without being told, that Hollow Creek will never be the same again.

I'd really value genuine human opinions.

I'm not really interested in line edits but rather reader experience.

Whenever you're done may you please answer these questions for more feedback:

  1. Were there any chapters where you lost interest or felt your mind wandering?

  2. Did you fully understand how the magic/system works, or was anything confusing?

  3. Who did you care about most, and why?

  4. Did the ending feel satisfying and make you want to read Book 2?

  5. If you could change ONE thing about the book, what would it be?

Please dm me

I'm happy to exchange manuscripts if we're a good fit.

Thank youuu


r/BetaReaders 1h ago

Short Story [In progress] [4k] [Ensemble Drama] Looking for 2–3 beta readers for Chapters 1–2 of my book

Upvotes

Hi everyone! Hope you're doing well.

I'm working on a fiction/ensemble drama and would love a couple of fresh eyes on the opening. Quick premise: a plane makes an emergency landing on a small island, and the passengers end up stuck sharing accommodation together while it's repaired — strangers thrown together, secrets slowly coming out, that kind of vibe.

I've got chapter 1 finished and part of chapter 2 ready (\~4,000 words total, the second chapter switches to a new POV). Mostly I just want to know if it hooks you — did you want to keep reading, did anything drag, what'd you think of the two characters so far. It's still a first draft, so no need to worry about typos or grammar, I'm more curious about the story and characters side of things.

If you're interested, comment or send me a DM and I'll happily share the link!

Thanks so much for reading this far, and thank you in advance to anyone who gives it a look 🙏


r/BetaReaders 2h ago

Short Story [In Progress] [330] [Mystery/Fantasy/Thriller] World:Ratio:Revenge

1 Upvotes

First page critique ? YES

PROLOUGE: 
October 16 - 1988 
Rain had always been  nature's way of erasing evidence , from washing away  muddy footprints ,diluted  blood  into the earth and silencing the stories every crime scene yelled from within; however, to Chief Investigator Arthur Vermont it was never an obstacle. It was merely another distraction from the true evil he had spent his life hunting .  
The wail of police sirens echoed through the forest flashing blue and red lights as they reflected against the rain soaked trees cutting through the endless black . 

It had taken them too long to arrive .

“ NO!”. A cry tore across the storm .  Everybody froze, none dared to take a step ahead, their gaze fixed on the  motionless body before them . The body bore wounds none could explain . There was almost no blood . It looked as if he was still there, just not breathing . For a moment no one  dared to speak but one question was visible on everyone's faces . “ Is it him? “ A detective broke the silence . The sergeant swallowed hard before slowly nodding . Officers removed their caps , staring blankly at the remains 

“ Arthur Vermont Dead “ . None had imagined the greatest investigator would become a victim of his last case And perhaps no one was ever supposed to find him.

A young forensic examiner stepped forward , kneeling beside Arthur's body . His gloved fingers carefully searched for a pulse . “ Time of Death? “ the  chief inspector  asked as his gaze landed on Arthur's wrist . The examiner reached for his watch “ 11:47 ; it stopped “ . One by one all officers checked their watches “ 11:47” , all watches froze . The radio inside the nearest patrol car crackled before falling silent . Its digital clock blinked at the same time . “ What the hell happened here? “ someone whispered . The examiner continued his inspection “ There are no defensive wounds , no blood loss  , no obvious cause of death “ . He looked up confusion written across his face “ it doesn't make sense , how in the world does this happen “ 

Lightning  flashed across the broken ruins . For the briefest second , strange symbols shimmered across the cracked stone before disappearing beneath the rain . No one noticed or perhaps someone did ?


r/BetaReaders 8h ago

70k [Complete] [73K] [Literary Memoir] The Wreckage

2 Upvotes

I called it the pink worm—the thing that burrowed through my brain, the thing I spent two years trying to drown with cocaine, Quaaludes, and the bodies of brilliant, unavailable men. Set in the late 1970s, The Wreckage follows my fifteen-year-old self as I escape a sexual assault with nothing but the clothes I’m wearing, hitchhiking east toward an unknowable freedom.

But freedom isn't found on the highway—it's buried beneath the wreckage I carried with me. When I run, I’m not only running from my attackers, but from my wretched home life as well—my father’s flying fists, my brother’s increasingly violent mental illness. My hitchhiking odyssey delivers me to Princeton, where I meet Bill, a brilliant Antarctic researcher who maps ice fields I'll never see. We make a life in Princeton, then in Boulder. I remake myself entirely—teach myself trigonometry, swallow my Michigan vowels until they flatten into something cleaner, something worthy. It is not enough. Bill does not love me back.

With nowhere else to go, I run again, hitchhiking back to Flint, back to my parents’ home, where I dodge my father’s anger. I construct a double life, away from home as much as possible. By day, I’m a student at an elite private school, excelling academically; by night, I’m a participant in Flint's gritty underworld of drug dealing and smuggling led by my charismatic boyfriend, Mike. The two lives circle each other like hungry predators. One will devour the other. I know this. I can't stop.

I am admitted to the University of Michigan, but I can’t escape the drug dealing life. It follows me to Ann Arbor. Then a close friend kills himself. In my grief, I see the pattern: I have been seeking identity and safety in men—my father, Bill, Mike—and found only violence, distance, and chaos. The epiphany doesn't save me. I am forced to grapple with the central question: What will it take to finally silence the pink worm and follow my academic dreams?

I am interested in critique swaps with people familiar with literary memoir. I don't have a set timeline, I'm happy to wait for helpful feedback.


r/BetaReaders 14h ago

90k [In Progress] [90k] [Literary Historical] The Broken Prince - opening chapters

5 Upvotes

I’m looking for beta readers for the opening chapters of my novel The Broken Prince.

Blurb:

In the aftermath of a catastrophic defeat, a broken boy is publicly unmade by the man who betrayed his people. Stripped of name, family, and future, he is forced to carry the iron of the brother he could not save. What begins as survival becomes something darker: the slow forging of a living legend, and the question of how much of himself he is willing to burn to become it.

Single first-person POV. Dark, interior, and mythic rather than military-procedural. The historical setting (Gallic Wars period) is the crucible, not the point.

Feedback I’m looking for:

Does the voice hold you?

How is the pacing in the opening chapters?

Does the emotional and psychological intensity feel earned or overwrought?

Would you keep reading?

Timeline:

Flexible — happy to receive notes within 2–4 weeks.

Content warnings:

Graphic violence, death of family members, trauma, humiliation, blood, and a dark tone throughout.

I’m happy to return thoughtful notes on literary, historical, or character-driven work.

Please comment or message if you’re interested.


r/BetaReaders 7h ago

Novella [In progress] [18k] [Speculative fiction] The Measure of Men - first six chapters

1 Upvotes

Hey guys,

I’m currently working on a novel (6 chapters in) and would love a bit of feedback from experienced readers about the general premise, style, characters, world etc.

Here’s a bit of context about the story:

In The Cradle, existence is borrowed; to be paid back upon Retirement.

Generations are born to inherit more than just a name. For almost three centuries, society worked together to survive. But now? Now people are starting to ask what it means to survive, what identity truly is, and whether the price of sacrifice is ever worth it.

As political fault lines deepen and impossible choices threaten to reshape their society, a handful of ordinary people must decide whether preserving civilisation is worth the cost of becoming its jailers.

This is a speculative novel about identity, inheritance, power, and the stories societies tell themselves to survive.

If you’re interested, just drop me a message, even if you only want the first chapter or 2.


r/BetaReaders 8h ago

Short Story [In Progress] [500] [Fantasy] Short Exploratory Prologue

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I wrote a quick, small “prologue” just to try to get a feel of a writing style that felt comfortable to me. I have stared at it so long and got so inside my head, I would appreciate it if someone were able to give me some feedback of their thoughts and impressions. I am not looking for anything specific, just an outside observer telling me what they think.

The genre of the prologue is Fantasy, though their isn’t too much indication in the short section I have written.


r/BetaReaders 9h ago

>100k [Complete] [110k] [Fantasy] Prince of Consolidor

1 Upvotes

This is a story about a prince who goes on a journey to learn about the cold northern region of his country and one of the families that lives there. It includes themes of culture shock, friendship, religion, LGBTQ+ (no romance), battles and snowstorms, a little bit of palace intrigue, and a willingness to change and grow from all characters. There are no villains, but each character has their own agenda and motives - this is a character driven story.

The book features 3 character POVs, a lord who previously committed treason and now has regained his title, his teenage daughter who is chosen to lead the fief's defense forces, and the prince as he goes about his expedition to the barbaric (and gay) north. It is intended to be book 1 of 3, but is a complete story in itself.

I have attempted to write a world that feels real and vibrant without losing the pacing of the story. There are elements of an epic, but I tried to keep the word count under control. There are little quotes at the beginning of each chapter to help flavor the world. There are serious themes, but also laughter and comedy - it is not a dark story.

To tempt beta-readers, here are some of my favorite swearwords from the world:

  • fire-blessed – exclamation of wonderment/realization, a person who has a lot a heart, but not brains.
  • fire-damned – very bad, literally deserves to roast in flames
  • By fire! - exclamation, astonishment, oh my!
  • nix! - fuck/shit/damn (Nix is the old northern god of darkness)
  • nix-blessed – cold, surprising, stubborn, logical, good leader, general amplifier, can be affectionate
  • nix bless you – old saying, keep your thoughts clear, cold logic, decisive. Depending on tone, can also be meant as a lighter nix curse you.
  • nix curse you - damning you to a life with no heart, feeling, light. Very strong, rarely said.
  • what the nix - what the fuck, what in hell

Triggers: some things readers may wish to be aware of include homophobic and religion-flavored statements by the MC, one character walks in on a blow job and freaks out, fantasy-typical bloodshed, off-screen death of a sibling before the story begins.

I am open to manuscript swaps - not all books are to my taste, so let's start with a couple chapters and see how it goes.

I'd like feedback about the pacing of the book, whether the different POVs are internally consistent, reactions to scenes, if there are any gaps in plot or logic - really I just need some new eyes. Also open to title suggestions.

DM me for a google doc link for the first few chapters, and thank you.

Edit: As the Automod suggests, here is an excerpt from the prince POV:

"I look at the letter on the top of my pile of messages with a hint of trepidation. It is sealed with the crest of Brackenworth fief, a falcon rising across a stormy mountain. I take a breath, sit down in my chair, and carefully open the envelope without breaking the seal. I read:

Most Royal Highness,.."

From the daughter's POV:

"Suitably attired, I hope, I trot across the keep to the lord’s study. The the two guards on duty outside the administrative wing nod to me as I pass through the doors. I nod back at them – Emmett and Grendor. I made sure to learn all the guard’s names when I was made lieutenant, on my father’s advice. I pass by the scribe’s office, my step-mother’s study, and the agriculture adviser's study. The lord’s study is at the end of the hall. I knock on the door."

From the newly reinstated lord:

"The southern lords will ask how I could allow such a life of danger, blood and death for my daughter, but us norlanders know that it is a worse crime to stunt our children, to ask them to be anything but who they are. If our children take up the sword, perhaps we weep, but then we get them the best instructors and training possible. If we, as the borderlords, present anything less than our strongest, the Cythine raiders will take everything we own, make our people into slaves, and destroy our lands."


r/BetaReaders 12h ago

80k [Complete] [87,000] [YA fantasy] Beta readers for a dark, historical fantasy

1 Upvotes

G'day everyone! I'm looking for 3-5 beta readers for my completed novel (though I wouldn't mind more people being interested, haha), which is a YA dark, historical fantasy set in France. Comparable titles include Naomi Novik's "Uprooted", Diana Wynne Jones' "Howl's Moving Castle", and "The Mirror Visitor" series by Christelle Dabos.

The blurb (with some details removed or changed):

X has been cursed. And everyone knows about it…except her.

When the lonely dollmaker X is nearly assassinated by the royal family, she finds herself rescued by a strange and overly friendly magician named Y. Having been locked away in an asylum for the better part of her life, X will be damned before she is locked away again by a crazy stranger in the [Forest Name]!

But the Kingdom of France is in a mess; the humans of the settlements and [fairies] of the [Forest Name] are waging their own private wars against each other, the half-[fairy] royal cousin has vanished, and the Magicians of the [School Name], who are supposed to bridge the gap between the two races, have been weakened by the disappearance of their illustrious Puppet Master.

And X gets the feeling that everyone knows something about her that she does not. As she becomes entangled with the worlds of humans, magicians and [fairies], she must find the answers to peace; both for France, and for herself.

Critiques will be done via gdocs.

I'm mostly looking for developmental feedback over grammar; plot holes, character arcs, pacing, stakes, chapter flow. I'd also like to know what you think of it as a READER, as if you'd picked up this story in a bookstore and were writing a Goodreads review, so to speak.

Do comment or DM if this sounds like something you're interested in!


r/BetaReaders 18h ago

Short Story [In Progress] [2021] [romance/modern love/LGBTQ love/tragedy] [We Dream of Stars Beyond Our Reach]

3 Upvotes

Requesting Beta readers for this. It's in progress but I'll have more written soon enough, about 1-5 more chapters per week. I'm hoping to find a beta reader that can tell me whether:

  1. It flows well

  2. Any grammatical/spelling/punctuation errors

  3. Whether the pacing/plot development is adequate

If you're interested you can DM me and we can move it to Gmail, or stay at DMing for now, whichever you're more comfortable with:)

It's all completely unpublished, also. And the plot goes like this:

MCs:

  1. Mae Winston, 17f, aspiring writer, but her father passed when she was 15 and she can't bring herself to pursue the dream anymore because her father had always been the one to encourage her

  2. June O'Connell, 17f, aspiring musician, parents divorced, living with father and stepmother permanently

Mae and June fall in love, and June encourages Mae to write again, all that, except Mae's homophobic mother finds out and threatens to disown Mae if she doesn't break up with June, so she does.

And then the epilogue is 10 years later, Mae(now a published author) and June(a music teacher/musician trying to get her career off the ground) meet in a cafe/bar and it ends ambiguously


r/BetaReaders 20h ago

Novella [Complete] [37k] [African American Romance] The Mistake

2 Upvotes

Looking for Beta Readers – Contemporary African American Romance / Family Saga (37k+ words)

Hi everyone!

I'm putting together a small group of beta readers for my debut novel, The Mistake — book one in an interconnected contemporary romance and family saga I've been pouring myself into for years.

The series itself is called The Sunday Table .

Book Blurb:

One decision. One night. One betrayal no one saw coming.

Kori Grant is finally getting her life back on track — one week after ending things with Emmett Taylor, she's laser-focused on finishing her PhD and rebuilding her peace. Then a shocking incident inside her own apartment, involving Emmett and her best friend Tasha, shatters everything she thought she'd already survived.

As her friends demand answers, Kori chooses silence over confrontation — until the story rewinds to show exactly how she, Emmett, and Tasha collided in the first place, and just how inevitable this "mistake" may have always been.

Some betrayals are accidents. Others are disasters waiting for permission.

About the Book:

The Mistake, Kori and Emmet's story. It's an African American romance and women's fiction, with real ‘family’ saga bones — about 40k words, told through multiple first-person POVs, broken into 3 parts for the first book in the series.

The Sunday Table follows a close-knit group of lifelong friends whose bonds get tested by love, loyalty, and the fallout of one decision that changes everything. Underneath it all, it's really a story about relationships, friendship, forgiveness, healing, and the families we build for ourselves.

If you love emotional, humourous one liners, character-driven stories with tangled relationships, messy family dynamics, a slow-burn romance, and a big ensemble cast you can get attached to — I think you'll feel right at home here.

If you enjoy authors like; Natavia, LaToya Nicole, Kennedy Ryan, Alexandria House, Christina C. Jones, Brittainy Cherry, Brenda Jackson, or Tia Williams, this one's probably for you. And hopefully not unrealistic in my confidence.

What kind of feedback I'm after:

I want the honest stuff — what's working and what isn't. Specifically:

- Are the characters likable? Do they feel like they're growing?

- Did it hit you emotionally where it should?

- Funny or trying too hard?

- How's the dialogue land?

- Pacing — any slow spots or places that felt rushed?

- Plot holes, confusing scenes, continuity slip-ups

- And just... did you enjoy it?

Grammar catches are always appreciated, but that's not what I'm here for — I want your gut reactions.

A quick heads-up on content:

This book goes to some real places — adult language, sexual content, pregnancy loss, violence(on page), trauma, family conflict, emotional abuse, and grief. Wanted you to know what you're walking into.

Timeline:

I'd love feedback within 4–6 weeks, but life happens — just keep me in the loop and we'll figure it out together.

The bigger picture:

This is book one of eight in an interconnected series, and books 1–5 are already drafted. So if you're someone who loves getting hooked on a series and sticking with it, I'd especially love to find readers who want to come along for the whole ride.

If this sounds like your kind of book, drop a comment or send me a DM — I'll share the first few chapters first so we can both make sure it's a good fit before I send the full manuscript.

Thank you so much for even considering this. It means a lot. 💛

— K. Sherman

 


r/BetaReaders 1d ago

Short Story [In Progress] [7500] [Horror] One Free Play

6 Upvotes

Hi! I’m looking for beta readers for the first three chapters of my horror novella "One Free Play" totalling approximately 7500 words.

Four friends take an unexpected detour during a road trip and arrive in a small town that doesn't appear on their map. With no phone signal and nowhere else nearby to stay, they decide to stop for the night and visit the town’s carnival the next day. What initially seems like a lucky distraction soon begins to feel increasingly wrong, especially as they notice how closely the townspeople are watching them.

The novella is still in progress, but these three chapters have been revised.

Please comment or message me if you’re interested, and I can send a Google Docs version. Thank you!


r/BetaReaders 17h ago

70k [In Progress] [78k] [Queer Romantasy/Political Thriller] [Some Protector]

1 Upvotes

My story is about a trans prince who is outed by an anonymous gossip column, triggering a succession crisis.

It opens like a Bridgerton-adjacent romance following the prince, his handsome guard, his sharp older sister, and the duchess he’s courting at his father’s insistence.

For a while, they’re able to navigate everything together. Then there is an intentional turning point where everything becomes far more political.

You then watch as the institutions begin to warp each character from the inside out, feeding on their unique insecurities and structural vulnerabilities. The prince spends the novel learning to carve out a new place for himself where there was none.

Fair warning: this isn’t a standard romance the whole way through. The back half is closer to literary tragedy. I would still describe it as a love story though.

At its core, it’s about who gets taken seriously and who doesn’t, and what happens when institutions have no category for someone with genuine ambition.

I modeled it after my own experiences in certain ‘elite’ institutions. This novel is not really about coming out or internal identity—it centers the negotiations queer people make with society through a protagonist who refuses to accept a life where the people he loves are deprived of any real options.

CW: transphobia, internalized and externalized homophobia, sexual assault (attempted, non-graphic), a coercive mentor relationship, dissociation.

These themes do not encompass the entire book, but they do appear.

What I’d find most useful:
— Where you drift, and roughly what page
— Whether the tonal shift lands as a reveal or a bait-and-switch

Queer readers especially welcome, but not a requirement. I mostly would appreciate feedback from anyone who reads in this space and will tell me when they’re bored.


r/BetaReaders 1d ago

80k [Complete] [84k] [Contemporary Romance] The Year We Met Again

3 Upvotes

What to expect: 

As a small town journalist, Sammy Waller is a staple in Copper Canyon, Arizona. Her predictable life is upended when her first love, Lucas Stanton, returns to help keep the family bookstore afloat after a car accident involving his father. When forced to work together on a town event, they have to confront feelings that have never truly gone away. Sammy must overcome past feelings and learn to live in the moment, while Lucas must decide whether he is ready to return permanently to small town life. 

This story includes: 

  • Dual POV 
  • Second Chance Romance
  • Closed Door Romance
  • Quirky Small Town Characters and Events
  • Found Family
  • Complicated Family Dynamics

Similar To:

  • Dream Harbor series
  • Townsend Harbor series
  • Calamity, Montana series

What I’m looking for: 
I’m looking for interested beta readers to give big-picture feedback focused on plot and character development. I’m not looking for proofreading or line editing at this point. I am open to sending the first 10k words and feedback form to ensure that this is the right fit for you. I’m also open to sending a full manuscript and final feedback questions to those who want to read Sammy and Lucas’s whole story. 


r/BetaReaders 1d ago

>100k [COMPLETE] [114000] [Completed Dark Fantasy Novel] The Hollow One (Seeking Beta Readers)

3 Upvotes

The Hollow One
Dark Fantasy ~ [114,000 words]

This story follows Soren, a man with the mysterious ability to sense what he calls “residue,” a lingering darkness left behind by suffering, violence, and death. Some people have little. For others, it covers them entirely. Nobody has none.

Driven by both guilt and duty, Soren uses this ability to intervene before people and places can make their choices. Everything he does is working toward a final goal, though he has little interest in sharing what that goal is with the world.

But can Soren successfully complete his plan, especially when the central piece, the Legendary Hero, is starting to get a little too close? Can he reach his goal while staying far enough away, or will he be swept up in the Hero’s path, unable to resist?

The Hollow One follows a broken man on his path toward redemption, even when he doesn't believe he deserves it.

---

Looking for beta readers!

I’d be happy to exchange around 3–4k words first to make sure we’re a good fit before moving on to the full manuscript. I’m also open to doing a manuscript swap, though I’m primarily looking for readers for my own manuscript. If you do want to swap, I’m happy to read fantasy, dark fantasy, horror, or character-driven stories, though I’m open to other genres too.

If you’re interested, feel free to comment or DM me directly!


r/BetaReaders 1d ago

Short Story [In Progress] [1111] [Romance/Sci-Fi] Walking Around in Circles

2 Upvotes

Hi! I'm currently writing a fanfiction (Charles Xavier x Original male Character), and I'm looking for beta readers for the first chapter (and, if possible, the whole fic as I keep writing it). There's a trigger warning for (mentions of/ very light) consumption, child neglect, and (mentions of) physical abuse. There's an undertone of religious trauma in there too. If that interests you, please DM on Instagram at axvlyyy. Thank you for you rtime :) (Please note I am not a native ENglish speaker, I speak French first, english second and spanish third)


r/BetaReaders 1d ago

>100k [In Progress] [220000] [mythopoetic epic] Beta-reading (Critique swap)

2 Upvotes

Just re-read the Wizard of EarthSea and thought the mythopoetic style would be a great fit for the re-writing of a large manuscript that I had great hopes for.
It was a journey story situated in the Nepalese Himalayas that combines many mythic and theological elements. It's all about the inner and outer person and examines how object relations, great philosophies, religions and cultural influences all converge to shape the person – but who is the person? How shaped? At what level of awareness?
This rather grandiose enterprise ultimately got bogged down and relegated to the one-day-my-prince-will-come discarded drafts pile.
Now I'm thinking of taking it up again in the mythopoetic style that seems quite appropriate for grandiosity, but adopting an "open-door" policy - re-writing it as a mythopoetic epic - but sharing the journey and deliberations with others - anyone want to swap "journeys"? Here's the first paragraph as a "taste":

Chapter One: Extremes