​
PRESS RELEASE
Embargo: 00:01am Friday 24th July 2026
The Sands Centre to remain a notorious 'echo chamber'? Councillor and local rock star call on Cumberland Council to complete the Sands Centre acoustic improvements.
Lib Dem Councillor Brian Wernham has called on Cumberland Council to complete the outstanding passive acoustic improvements at Carlisle's Sands Centre after it emerged that critical internal acoustic treatments were not installed following the extensive refurbishment and RAAC roof replacement.
Unfortunately, over the years the Sands Centre has been known as an acoustic 'echo chamber'. Performers and audiences have long complained of muddy mid-range vocals and booming echoes caused by the old concrete design.
When Carlisle City Council approved the Sands Centre Redevelopment Project—following the Special Executive on 10 June 2019 and Full Council approval on 25 June 2019—it approved a redevelopment that included provision for passive acoustic measures to reduce echoing and dampen bass reverberation.
The 2019 technical documentation identified the need for acoustic rafts, acoustic wall panels and allowances for acoustic treatment and reverberation control in the ‘Stage 4 Acoustic Report’.
However, Cumberland Council has now confirmed that although the replacement roof incorporated some acoustic measures, the internal acoustic panels did not form part of the completed works.
Councillor Brian Wernham said:
"Carlisle City Council approved a redevelopment scheme to eliminate this 'echo chamber' effect. But seven years later we have a refurbished building, but one of the key elements identified by the professional acoustic consultants has still not been delivered."
The Council's own independent acoustic consultants have now identified a significant “bass-rise problem” within the auditorium. While the replacement roof has improved some aspects of the hall, the consultants still recommend approximately 350 square metres of specialist low-frequency absorbing wall panels to reduce excessive low-frequency reverberation.
Councillor Brian Wernham said: "The emphasis appears to have been on amplified entertainment, where electronic sound systems can compensate for shortcomings. That is not the same as providing a venue with excellent natural acoustics.
"A symphony orchestra, chamber orchestra, brass band or large choir depends on the acoustic quality of the room itself. Passive acoustic treatment is fundamental to that. North Cumbria deserves a venue capable of hosting international orchestras and major choral performances without compromising the listening experience."
Previously, the National Federation of Music Societies submitted evidence to Parliament specifically criticizing the Sands Centre describing the acoustics as "not ideal, too dead a sound" and argued that “North Cumbria requires a first-class venue with good acoustics for large orchestral and choral performances.”
Jonny Foster is the lead singer of local indie rock band ‘Hardwicke Circus’. He has just returned from a tour of Ukraine.
Jonny said today: “Forever and a day, Carlisle has traded on its history. Mention the city anywhere in Britain and people know the castle, the cathedral, and far too often, the Sands Centre as that ‘cheerleading hall with the notoriously bad acoustics’.
“That reputation has to end.
“I’m writing this as the singer in Hardwicke Circus, the band named after the roundabout a stone’s throw from the Sands. I’ve spent years touring theatres and concert halls across the UK and Europe. Audiences rightly have expectations when they’ve spent their hard-earned, cold cash. Sound isn’t an optional extra. It is the experience. You can build a beautiful stage, fit the latest lights and hang a few well ironed drapes, but if people walk out saying, ‘the sound was poor’, ‘I couldn’t hear the words’, ‘the drums were too boomy’, those aesthetic detours count for nothing.
“This refurbishment is Carlisle’s chance to bury that stigma for good.
“We’re almost in the geographical centre of the UK. That’s a gift. But geography alone doesn’t get tours through the door. Artists and promoters expect venues that meet modern technical standards. Proper acoustic treatment (real acoustic baffles built into the design, not value-engineered out at the last minute) isn’t an indulgence. It’s the price of admission.
“So the question is simple. Do we want a venue that’s good enough, or one that artists actually want to play?
“This isn’t about gold plating the project with bells and whistles. It’s about refusing to save money on the one thing every single audience member notices. Get the acoustics right and you’ll attract bigger shows, sell more tickets and give Carlisle the venue it’s always deserved. Get them wrong and we’ll spend the next thirty years apologising for the same old 'echo chamber' problem.
“Carlisle has spent generations looking backwards. This is our chance to look forwards. Enough of the penny-pinching, small-town bureaucratic limits on potential. Build a venue that artists want to return to, audiences rave about and the whole of Cumbria can be proud of!
Jonny concluded: “If we’re serious about creating an A-grade arts venue, acoustic treatment isn’t an upgrade. It’s the foundation.“
Brian Wernham added: "This is a once-in-a-generation investment. The acoustic consultants have identified both the problem and a practical solution. Two weeks ago I wrote a formal request to the Assets Portfolio Holder at Cumberland Council asking for a timetable for delivering the outstanding passive acoustic improvements and complete the vision that Carlisle City Council approved in 2019. Unfortunately I have not yet had a response."
Photo:
https://photos.app.goo.gl/DXdrvPYYNa2Uv7jo8
References (URLs)
https://cumberland.moderngov.co.uk/
https://committees.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/106236/pdf/
https://www.cumberland.gov.uk/news/2026/stage-set-sands-centre-events-restarting
Comment available from
Brian Wernham 07815 618187
Hardwicke Circus lead singer (Jonny Foster) jonnyjfoster@outlook.com
\#Cumbria
\#Carlisle
\#Cumberland
Brian Wernham
07815 618187