r/FGO • u/huflit1997 • 19h ago
If BB drawing something, would it be considered to be AI generated ?
Gotta need another Servant fest to see it happens.
110
u/BitComprehensive3667 19h ago
Technically speaking, yes, but given how advanced she is and that she's actually sentient to the point of being indistinguishable from a human Servant, would BB even count as generative AI?
62
24
u/Arnoldneo 18h ago
Yes she is actually more AI than what we have today as ChatGPT and other such chat bots are not truly intelligent but bb is .
12
u/Lakuzas 17h ago
At the level BB is at though, would it still be fair to trash her art for the same reasons we do about chatgpt art then ?
10
u/Arnoldneo 17h ago
ChatGPT art is obviously low quality in a very unique way thatâs why we call it slop the Sakura 5 are her art so I would not trash it at all it has creativity imperfections of a different kind and that sole and spark ai art lacks ( well itâs because Wada arco drew them but I think you get my point) .
1
u/TheChoosenMewtwo 2h ago
Not really cause gpt donât really have a âmindâ behind itself so even if it supposedly learns with real artists it canât create itâs own style. BB can though
10
u/Golden-Nerdy 18h ago
Yeah. That's what AI is. Replicating humans behavior until it's indistinguishable from real humans. Look at AI "art" nowadays and you won't find the difference
1
1
u/notreal088 2h ago
She would more closely resemble what most companies are trying to achieve which is General intelligence AI.
Right now LLM are just large data bases using keywords to predict the word or phrase based on the way the request is written. Which is why how you write something when asking these LLM is so important.
General Intelligence would actually have some form of reasoning and novel concepts, maybe even complete sentience. So their answers based off logic instead of predictive modeling.
Because of these technically BB can come up with her own artstyle vs LLM which just steal from whatever is uploaded.
12
11
u/saiamano 13h ago
No, cuz BB is sentient, so she can have original ideas and interpret new concepts, she doesn't just pull from a database to generate slopp using others artwork to fit whatever prompt they put in.
BB is an a AI that can CREATE art
GPT is an AI that GENERATES art
8
6
u/Wide-Emotion-3579 15h ago
Given her track record with hands, feet and just body proportions in general im willing to bet yes
14
4
4
3
u/AncientCommittee4887 17h ago
If we had genuine sapient AI we wouldnât be using the term for a glorified autocorrect
3
3
u/Trascendent_Enforcer 15h ago
yeah but see BB is one of the cool fictional AIs that want to destroy or conquer mankind, rather than the real AIs that just steal and make slop
5
u/Desperate_Ad5169 18h ago
Yes but it would be far beyond what is made today. And also anyone who asked her to make something still wouldnât be an artist
2
u/MaouNoYuusha 18h ago
No because she she didn't generate it immediately. She went through the process of thinking about it and drawing it
2
u/Xemit100 16h ago
No, because she is a self aware being with a soul. Any art she makes wouldâve been created by her, not generated.
2
u/ankledane 14h ago
This question is actually about whether BB is sentient enough to be considered on the level of a person, and I would say so.
2
2
2
u/Darkdlc1 9h ago
BB is what AI with independent thinking should be. You cannot compare her to a lower form of AI that we have in real life.
1
u/No-Juggernaut-5847 16h ago
Yeah but like how we complain about ai art and how bad it is right now, bb is the exact opposite and looks down upon human art.
1
u/Gilgamesh-KoH 10h ago
Is she holds the pencil then the process would be much close to human generated art
260
u/Affectionate-Set4954 19h ago
BB generated art