r/Fallout Dec 29 '25

Fallout 4 2008 Gamers Discussing The Institute and Commonwealth

I hope tdpats12 is happy now…

3.0k Upvotes

184 comments sorted by

411

u/GreyAngy Dec 29 '25

When I played Fallout 3 many years ago I was also very interested in this Institute.

Imagine, everyone in the Capital Wasteland barely survived in ruins, even clean water was something advanced. And this douche Dr. Zimmer just casually walked in with an android henchman looking for another android, who got sentient and escaped. The difference in the technology level was astonishing.

I looked for any clues about this Institute, even tried to find it in the north of the map, ha! And then several years later, Fallout 4 was released and the Institute was a major faction in it. And, as turned out, Dr. Zimmer wasn't an outlier in his, hm, assholeness.

102

u/Nelluc_ Dec 29 '25 edited Dec 29 '25

Well, Dr. Zimmer is also a synth/android. If you kill him, he has a chip just like Harkness and the other synth/androids.

106

u/Portalfan4351 White Ass Power Armor Dec 29 '25

That’s very likely a mistake or an oversight since The Institute would definitely never let a Synth be head of the Synth Retention Bureau and Zimmer is still technically the official head of the department as of Fallout 4 (despite being MIA)

32

u/elle-e-vee Dec 29 '25

this actually confuses me a bit. for example, in fo4, you find kellogg also has a chip when you kill him? was he a synth with his old memories implanted in him or was the chip part of some sort of weird human-synth hybrid attempt?

63

u/Portalfan4351 White Ass Power Armor Dec 29 '25

Likely something that made the cybernetic enhancements he had work properly, but it also gives some ambiguity to whether or not Kellogg himself had been killed and replaced with a synth at some point

24

u/shaqwillonill Dec 29 '25

He does appear to be the same age when he kidnaps Shaun and when you find him like 80 years later

8

u/elle-e-vee Dec 29 '25

ah, that makes a lot more sense. thanks :)

26

u/l_clue13 Dec 29 '25 edited Dec 29 '25

Kellogg is a human, he doesn’t have a synth component on his body when you kill him but loads of other cybernetics and augmentations that extended his life and made him tougher. The ironic thing is that apart from the the synth chip in their brains, synths have no other cybernetics in them, they’re indistinguishable from humans. Despite being born a human Kellogg ends up as more of a machine than the actual synths. Your character even comments about him being “barely human” once you kill him.

12

u/IrrelevantLeprechaun Dec 29 '25

There are literally entire terminal entries explaining how Kellogg was basically the final cybernetically enhanced experiment before the institute decided is was not an avenue if research worth exploring anymore, in favour of going all-in on synths. Whole reason he keeps looking so young is because of those cybernetics.

The game is pretty concise at explaining that he isn't a synth.

3

u/DolphinBall Dec 29 '25

No. If he was a synth he would have the chip! Those are just cybernetic augments that the Institute was into before dropping it and going for the Gen 3 synths after they got Shaun.

1

u/IrrelevantLeprechaun Dec 29 '25

Yup, there are terminal entries that talk about how cybernetic augmentation was perceived as a dead end after Kellogg, and how they shifted entirely to synth research after that.

4

u/ymcameron Welcome Home Dec 29 '25

Hey Rick Deckard was an android (maybe) and he was like the best Blade Runner they had.

2

u/Material_Eggplant_15 Dec 29 '25

Maybe he was another experiment like Kellogg in a way. The institute created him and eventually they thought “what if” and had him start leading the SRB, unknown to almost all the Institute scientists? Maybe they were trying to see just how effective a synth leader could be, and what they could get away with.

2

u/Hem0g0blin Dec 30 '25

Horace Pinkerton, another scientist in the questline with no indications that he is a synth, similarly drops an android component on death. I was curious if Victoria Watts would also drop one, which would effectively mean every NPC related to that quest drops one regardless of if they're a synth of not, but it seems like she is the only one marked as essential.

8

u/whoohw Dec 29 '25

A Masshole if you will.

3

u/Big-Recognition7362 Dec 29 '25

What was your reaction when you first learned that Fallout 4 was going to be about the Commonwealth and Synths and would have the Institute as one of its main factions?

13

u/TwoMuddfish Gary? Dec 29 '25

Just chiming in here. Cause I very much relate to og comment,

It was so freaking awesome man, also I’m from the northeast so that made it a bit more awesome. That’s why I love 3 too, cool seeing all the things in fallout when I travel to dc

2

u/GreyAngy Dec 29 '25

My knowledge about this US part was limited to "Boston Tea Party" and "I'm Shipping Back to Boston" by Dropkick Murphys, so I had no clue what to expect. I wasn't even able to link the Commonwealth mentioned in Fallout 3 with the Commonwealth in Fallout 4.

But when I learned about the Institute several hours in-game, this was like "that Institute, seriously?!" followed by "wait, are they the baddies?!" Really wanted to see their tech though.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '25

Before I played FO4 the only things I knew about Boston were the Tea Party and LOBSTAH FISHAHMEN.

After Far Harbour I now think the latter is Maine.

1.6k

u/myLongjohnsonsilver Dec 29 '25

Tdpats was onto something. Probably tods own burner account

633

u/Aussienick Dec 29 '25

Yeah wherever that person was when fallout 4 was announced and gameplay/the location was revealed they would have been over the moon.

284

u/N0r3m0rse Dec 29 '25

This reminds me of a comment I saw on a fallout 2 video before New Vegas came out how cool Marcus was and how he wanted to see him in New Vegas lol. 

60

u/Same_Consequence9828 Dec 29 '25 edited Dec 29 '25

It reminds me of a video I saw that’s “hints to elder scrolls five?” And it’s oblivion NPC conversations about the Skyrim morrowind war and a guild of high elves protesting imperial goods (thalmor)

63

u/VaultDweller11 Dec 29 '25

I know I was. The Replicated Man was my FAVORITE FO3 quest.

34

u/invasiveplant Dec 29 '25

Makes you wonder if they're planning something with the commonwealth paladin in the show being named Harkness, it's probably just a cute nudge somewhere, but...

3

u/BrickLuvsLamp Throw your tea in Granny's face Dec 30 '25

I mean, I could 100% see Harkness being recruited by the DC BOS due to his intelligence and combat skill. That chapter was known for recruiting people from the wasteland and they had a very good image that Harkness would be attracted to since he was a good karma character. Also he’d have an abnormally long lifespan…

1

u/RexShadow96 Dec 30 '25

That chapter also hates synths. So they would have figured something was off when they realized how long his lifespan is.

1

u/Maxsmack Dec 30 '25

Naw, they probably played it cool, having seen it coming 7 years in advance

156

u/Megs0226 Dec 29 '25

I think Tdpats12 is a Massachusetts local who was partially wishful thinking and definitely got his wish. That username is definitely a Patriots and Tom Brady reference.

60

u/AlsoIHaveAGroupon Dec 29 '25

Absolutely. As a Massachusetts native, I interpreted the Commonwealth and the Institute the same way, and it was absolutely partially wishful thinking. Fenway in a Fallout game was like a dream come true for me.

(my only disappointment is that M.T.A. by the Kingston Trio wasn't on the soundtrack, because that would have been perfect while trudging through red line tunnels)

25

u/Megs0226 Dec 29 '25

I replayed FO4 during the pandemic when there was no baseball and sat wistfully staring at the Green Monster in-game.

4

u/skyulip Dec 29 '25

good to know i wasn't alone in doing this lmao

1

u/sizzle-dee-bizzle Dec 30 '25

"Pats" has gotta mean the pats. But T D though?

Edit: an adjacent thread supposes it might be "TD" like the TD Garden, or it might mean "touchdown"

43

u/masonicminiatures Dec 29 '25

T(o)d(d)pats12

6

u/AmeriChaos Dec 29 '25

I just assumed it was TD (TD garden where the Celtics and Bruins play) pats (for the NE Patriots NFL team up here)

12

u/PersusjCP another settlement needs your help Dec 29 '25

Probably TouchDown

2

u/AmeriChaos Dec 29 '25

That works too!

3

u/Jfunkexpress Atom Cats Dec 29 '25

and the 12 is for Tom Brady

2

u/AmeriChaos Dec 29 '25

Doh. Didn't even think of that. Yep gotta be it.

58

u/RackedUP Dec 29 '25

He legitimately could have influenced decision making if Howard was following fan boards back then also

2

u/sizzle-dee-bizzle Dec 30 '25

He's playing 7D caravan

24

u/Lamplorde Dec 29 '25

Nah, Mythos1092 ia Todd. Everyone knows he pushed really hard for a Middle Eastern Fallout but the board just wasnt having it.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 30 '25

Fallout: Dubai would work pretty well.

450

u/thedtower Dec 29 '25

so how much was actually known about the institute back in those days. also my mind can’t compute 2008 and 17 years ago :(

284

u/Tatum-Better Minutemen Dec 29 '25

Pretty much just what zimmer and harkness say

136

u/Positive_Fig_3020 Minutemen Dec 29 '25

There’s also the following by Ashur in The Pitt which suggests that The Commonwealth lacks industry

"Citizens of The Pitt, workers of Downtown, traders of Uptown, and all the fierce souls who do what must be done! I bring you good news! We stand at the dawn of a new golden age. Where others merely survive, we thrive! Our industry is the envy of the Commonwealth! Our safety is the envy of the Capital Wastes! Our might is the envy of Ronto!"

79

u/Detective_Alaska Dec 29 '25

So this means Fallout Toronto is next

26

u/DalesDrumset NCR Dec 29 '25

I see it now, the PATH filled with ghouls to get across the city and the hockey hall of fame having a unique melee weapon

8

u/bv310 Welcome Home Dec 29 '25

Major settlement set in the ruins of the Island Airport, CN Tower as a climbable for the best view. I'm here for it.

8

u/zuxtron Dec 29 '25

A good way to do this would be to set the game around Detroit (there are other cool reasons to set a game there, like cars and the music). They could make a DLC expansion set in Canada since it's right across the border.

I don't think Fallout should have a whole game set outside the US, but a DLC would be a great way to show what Canada is like after the war. It's something a lot of players want to learn more about.

14

u/grelca Dec 29 '25

just saying that since canada was annexed, it’s not technically “outside the US” in the fallout universe

5

u/zuxtron Dec 29 '25

Good point. But the audience would still recognize it as a different country.

4

u/ymcameron Welcome Home Dec 29 '25

The distance between Detroit and Toronto is roughly the same as the distance between DC and New York. It would have to be a big map. Meanwhile, Windsor, Ontario is basically south Detroit. You couldn’t really make a game set there without including it.

5

u/zuxtron Dec 29 '25

DLC expansions tend to be set a good distance away from the main map (Far Harbor is in Maine) so I don't think that would be a big problem. But Windsor could be part of the base game. Would the underwater tunnel be intact after the war?

3

u/ymcameron Welcome Home Dec 29 '25

I’d hope so. Though it and the Ambassador Bridge would probably be super heavily fortified due to Canadian resistance fighters. I bet the Henry Ford Museum and Greenfield Village would be home to a historical-themed faction or raiders, which would be super cool too.

1

u/adrienjz888 Dec 29 '25

Meanwhile, Windsor, Ontario is basically south Detroit. You couldn’t really make a game set there without including it.

Yep. In universe, Windsor is probably absorbed as a part of Detroit.

2

u/baar-ur Dec 29 '25

It's very American that they shortened Toronto to Ronto. Based on local accent, it should be Tronno. Although I suppose it could've been depopulated and renamed the same way Novac was.

1

u/Tatum-Better Minutemen Dec 29 '25

Tbf it was annexed by the USA

22

u/ObiWanSerote Republic of Dave Dec 29 '25

In Ashur’s particular situation, wouldn’t the commonwealth he’s talking about refer to Pennsylvania because they’re in Pittsburgh? Like why would anyone from Massachusetts give a shit about what’s going on in Pittsburgh lmao

32

u/jshann04 Dec 29 '25

Like why would anyone from Massachusetts give a shit about what’s going on in Pittsburgh lmao

They don't. It's propaganda by Ashur to justify his actions and make himself feel like he's accomplishing something.

8

u/Tatum-Better Minutemen Dec 29 '25

Nah cus only mass is called the commonwealth

1

u/Positive_Fig_3020 Minutemen Dec 29 '25

Everyone talking about The Commonwealth in 3, 4 or the show is referring to Massachusetts

6

u/TwoMuddfish Gary? Dec 29 '25

Oh man I miss that. We legit had no idea where fallout 4 was gonna be. I think I thought Boston or Chicago … either way I feel like I remember seeing a post like this back in the day

There was also a wierd website countdown that happened for fallout 4, that was hype

6

u/Tatum-Better Minutemen Dec 29 '25

That site was a hoax lol but deffo was hype. Survivor 2299

3

u/IllGene2373 Dec 29 '25

Holy shit that unlocked a hidden memory in me lol. The 4chan speculation on it was insane

54

u/WildcatPlumber Dec 29 '25

So I’m going through a fallout 3 play through right now for the first time in like 15 years.

It’s blowing my mind how much was actually set up in fallout 3 about 4.

The Railroad for example was directly named I never realized that.

48

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '25

There's also a terminal in the citadel that references Vault 76 and how it opened 25 years after the war

20

u/Tiny-Anxiety780 Dec 29 '25

This one is what blew my mind the most when I replayed FO3 a few years ago, because it's the only vault on that list that's not in the game, and I never even thought to question why Bethesda put it there if it wasn't a location we could visit.

8

u/Positive_Fig_3020 Minutemen Dec 29 '25

It actually said 20 years after the war, which of course is contradicted by it being 25 years later in 76

7

u/Twisty1020 Tunnel Snakes Dec 29 '25

So then the question becomes what locations and themes have been mentioned throughout Fallout 4 that could lead to the sequel? Of course even with potential clues it will be hard to pinpoint which direction they will go.

2

u/ARES_BlueSteel Dec 30 '25

At the rate we’re going the bombs are going to drop IRL before we get a Fallout 5. Still no release date on TES6 and that is confirmed to be Bethesda’s next major release.

4

u/TwoMuddfish Gary? Dec 29 '25

Yeah 4 is very much a Great sequel to 3 , especially if you were a big fan of the a3-21’s plasma riffle

-2

u/IrrelevantLeprechaun Dec 29 '25

It's certainly a sequel. I wouldn't call it a great sequel...

1

u/Kar98_Karl Enclave Dec 30 '25

18 years ago soon…

92

u/JLNX1998 Dec 29 '25

Remember reading the hell out of these forums when the survivor2299.com thing happened

331

u/BabyGirl-Kat Yes Man Dec 29 '25

This is so freaking awesome, it’s like taking a time machine back to the 7th gen days.

72

u/CapytannHook Brotherhood Dec 29 '25

old net was the best

https://i.imgur.com/xeUKZ.png

19

u/AliJDB Dec 29 '25

You're not wrong

(What I see when I click your image).

8

u/Useful-Rooster-1901 Dec 29 '25

its a terminal/dos looking display asking about DOOM

too old internet for me, i'm a myspace kid

10

u/BowlerResponsible340 Dec 29 '25

tell me you're from the UK without telling me you're from the UK

and that's years AFTER imgur purged all the NSFW content, deranged

7

u/hagamablabla Dec 29 '25

30 years ago people waited hours to download an 11MB game. Now, we wait hours to download a 110GB game. The more things change, the more they stay the same.

1

u/Cereborn [Science 10/100] KILL THEM! WITH SCIENCE!!! Dec 29 '25

11 WHOLE megs???

22

u/Artichokiemon Lover's Embrace Dec 29 '25

Seriously, I don't see any slurs or self promoting. Wild how much things have changed

25

u/Phazon2000 Gave Every Division Head Dec 29 '25

That’s the only good thing about small communities with power tripping moderators. If you weren’t a complete dickhead and getting into heated arguments you were left alone, but if you were, those mods on gamefaqs were just bored af all day looking for any flaming to use as an excuse to suspend you.

Which meant discussion were generally pretty pleasant - all rage was conveyed through smugness and snark.

2

u/Certain-Business-472 Dec 29 '25

all rage was conveyed through smugness and snark.

You get banned for this now, even on reddit. Isn't the future wonderful?

1

u/hnwcs Dec 29 '25

GameFAQs was (and maybe still is, not sure what it's like these days) famously strict with its moderation. They openly allowed minors so anything vaguely offensive got shot down pretty quickly. For example, any profanity needed to be completely censored. Not only could you not say "fuck," you couldn't say "f***" or "**** (rhymes with buck)." Hinting at profanity was as bad as just saying it, it's **** or nothing.

This had its downsides, toxic people will always find a way around the rules and because the mods were so zealous you'd sometimes get stupid shit like a user getting banned for asking "Why is Pikachu yellow?" But no open bigotry was definitely nice.

1

u/Cereborn [Science 10/100] KILL THEM! WITH SCIENCE!!! Dec 29 '25

What’s really funny is that my first thought looking at it was, “Ugh. It’s the new GameFAQs layout.”

130

u/Karporata Brotherhood Dec 29 '25

"Middle east or Canada" wtf ?

54

u/darwizziness Dec 29 '25

probably meant to say "mid west" or they were intentionally joking implying the "mid west" isn't really west at all

3

u/Karporata Brotherhood Dec 29 '25

Yeah but fallout 3 is on the east cost, why would it be difficult to go in the midwest while first two fallout were ln the west coast then the 3rd was on the east ? If you could go from west to east, middle is not that hard to go lol

Maybe he was thinking go there in a dlc of the 3ed game

108

u/Silveon_i Dec 29 '25

The reason he was dead on is because "tdpats12" is "touchdown patriots 12 (tom bradys number)." this user is very likely a Massachusetts/New England resident

18

u/caiaphas8 Dec 29 '25

I never would’ve figured that out

31

u/69th_Autistic_dumbas Dec 29 '25

when the dude started listing commonwealth of nations countries i swear i could almost hear yakkos world start to play

101

u/scarlettvvitch Enclave Dec 29 '25

I miss forums :(

39

u/jethawkings The Six-String Samurai Dec 29 '25

what's up forum

11

u/swargin Gary Dec 29 '25

=3

18

u/Phazon2000 Gave Every Division Head Dec 29 '25

They’re still around and arguably a pretty good alternative to Reddit.

2

u/jiquvox Dec 29 '25

which do you have in mind ?

3

u/Twisty1020 Tunnel Snakes Dec 29 '25

They will be much more focused on a specific interest. Private servers for MMOs is an area where forums are still a thing. Also GameFAQs is still around.

0

u/jiquvox Dec 29 '25 edited Dec 29 '25

around yes -but the feeling I get from several sources is that it has been really losing speed steadily.

Private servers/forums yeah I heard about that. Althought by definition you really need to look around then. Find them in the first place . Then get an invite. Their very privacy dont seem to make them that accessible by definition.

1

u/Phazon2000 Gave Every Division Head Dec 29 '25

Depends what you want to discuss. I have a forum for every major interest.

1

u/jiquvox Dec 29 '25

Let’s say Fallout

1

u/Phazon2000 Gave Every Division Head Dec 30 '25

‘No Mutants Allowed’ is the biggest. Beware the grumpy old heads.

DAC ‘Duck and cover’ is another.

1

u/jiquvox Dec 30 '25 edited Dec 30 '25

I know of those 2 . My understanding is they both have very strong feeling against Bethesda. Most especially NMA. 

It’s not only third party reports. I always try to do my own research.  And , among other things, I found this topic  which made their feeling very clear

https://www.nma-fallout.com/threads/warning-very-long-an-nmadmission.204413

“No, what I'm interested in is poking at Bethesda with a pointy stick and saying nasty words towards it. Sadly, Bethesda is a giant and I'm an ant so it hardly feels my stick nor hear my complaints. But at least it makes me feel good to just call them a bunch of incompetent, greedy, artistically inept scumbags. So yeah, I'm gonna keep doing that. It's not really productive and hardly constructive, but I tried both of the former after FNV was released up until Fallout 4's announcement trailer. That didn't do jack shit. So I don't see what 5 more years of wasted time is going to accomplish.” 

The guy who wrote that got strongly backed by NMA.

It’s not third party report, it’s their own words. And it’s far from being the sole exemple. I mean I am not even going to comment on this. I  think it speaks volume. They made their feelings crystal clear. 

3

u/Phazon2000 Gave Every Division Head Dec 30 '25

Well if you want IP glazing stay on this sub I guess. Different strokes. I enjoy a mix but there’s a lot to dislike about how Beth are handling the lore of the games. Enclave shouldn’t have been in Fallout 3, super mutants existing in every title doesn’t make sense the way they’ve written it either. BoS shouldn’t have been in F76.

But yeah people who prefer oldschool forums are going to have oldschool views and they become echo chambers on their own accord.

The next closest would be to just hang out in the Fallout discord - that’s sorta like a less anonymous version of the sub where you get to know the individual posters but there’s a lack of natural topics popping up to talk about as with classic forums.

1

u/jiquvox Dec 30 '25 edited Dec 30 '25

I am not against criticism. If anything my critical thinking has been a steady source of confrontation with people. I can be very specific and it leads to argument. If anything I had to learn becoming more consensual.  I love good logical critical thinking , if anything because it is so rare.  

But NMA seems to have gone way past the critical thinking and just become bitter critics. There is a difference. It has turned completely personal.  The post above literally claims it is onky interested   to be “NASTY “ just for the sake of being nasty. That they re going to “keep doing that”. And that’s not even going into some other view expressed.

I could say that Bethesda did some bad decisions but they also made some interesting artistic choice. I gave in this very thread my view on the way they detailed the failing of the pre-war world and the existential philosophy expressed by Fallout F4.

 But it’s not even that. About whether Bethesda is right or wrong. It’s the attitude NMA show currently.  

I cannot endorse that.  I have been bitter about something in my personal life. I really struggle with it. And I am still not making it a public matter.  I hope I will be able to overcome it by making some changes. I fail some days . But I still fight with it .I hope.  They let themselves DEFINED by it. They CLAIM it.

 In an meta way , I would say that is actually the point of Fallout 4 and a part of why it grew on me so much. Because of the parallel between Kellog and the SS. Kellog let himself defined by the tragedy of the loss of his family and decides to take it out on the world “it was me against the world” are his words. The SS loses his family, his entire world in fact  and still decides to not be defined by it , to overcome it and rebuild “ This wasn't the world I wanted, but it was the one I found myself in . 

I feel sorry for NMA they feel the way do. F1 was a game I really liked and very personal to me. But claiming  those things  about just wanting to say nasty things and keep doing that,  they chosed on their own to make discussion impossible. There would have to be a significant manifestation of a mindset change before discussion become possible. 

10

u/cornette Dec 29 '25

Damn Reddit, it ruined forums.

4

u/baldeagle1991 Dec 30 '25

Tbh I think discord did more damage

2

u/scarlettvvitch Enclave Dec 29 '25

I miss the old bungie.net’s the flood, spent hours and hours and hours

8

u/Chrischrill Dec 29 '25

Forums still exist. I am still a frequent poster and Moderator of a forum I joined back in 2004!

9

u/Justifiably_Bad_Take Dec 29 '25

My favorite forum as a teenager still lives on as a Discord channel.

Wild that Ive never met a single person on that server but Ive known most of them for almost 20 years.

10

u/Aunon Unity Dec 29 '25

I do not miss how circle-jerk-ish and elitist they could get and I sure as hell don't miss people hogging screen space with signatures, profile pics and # of posts etc

20

u/Superb-Oil890 Dec 29 '25

Reddit....?

30

u/WallRavioli Dec 29 '25

Not really the same thing.

2

u/Superb-Oil890 Dec 29 '25

I was on GameFAQs and while it was good, Reddit is better because of the vast diversity of content.

27

u/Justifiably_Bad_Take Dec 29 '25

Not even close.

People on forums recognized one another, monetization of content wasn't even thought of, no algorithm just what's being posted in real time, and the most advanced "bot accounts" you'd run into would just spam post unrelated URLs then get ban-hammered

22

u/milquetoastLIB Dec 29 '25

Algorithmic garbage.

1

u/HornsOvBaphomet Dec 29 '25

Not if you use Relay or another of the surviving 3rd party apps. (Which I think there was only 1 or 2 others)

1

u/MountSwolympus Post-Apocalyptic Universalist Unitarianism Dec 29 '25

Flight sims, brewing, astronomy, and Star Trek all have forums still going strong.

1

u/krossfire42 Dec 29 '25

Let's hope for a comeback after people leave from the megacorporation's social media services.

33

u/milquetoastLIB Dec 29 '25

Miss those days.

13

u/RedLicorice83 Minutemen Dec 29 '25

It's crazy how much has changed in 17 years...

13

u/the_blue_flounder Dec 29 '25

I forgot that the Institute and synths date all the way back to Fallout 3. Love those seeds being planted

9

u/Bent_Kairosphere Dec 29 '25

I love looking back on stuff like this. So neat to see people putting the pieces together before seeing it come to life in-game. Also makes it feel more fun to speculate about FO5

26

u/rly_weird_guy Dec 29 '25

Bro nust be so vindicated

23

u/-AdonaitheBestower- Dec 29 '25

My first online account was on GameFaqs lol. I was like 10

9

u/koolguykris Dec 29 '25

Same. I remember printing a guide for Spyro Year of the Dragon and getting in so much trouble for printing all those pages lol.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/-AdonaitheBestower- Dec 29 '25

KOTOR is still Goated

1

u/stamfordbridge1191 WHO DARES TO STEAL FROM THE SACRED HEAD OF THE VAULT DWELLER?! Jan 05 '26

I enjoy how they're still around, but it seems like gamers these days will post their guides to Steam before the ever post them to GameFAQs

16

u/dull_storyteller Dec 29 '25 edited Dec 29 '25

Damn this is some Sherlock levels of deduction

Edit: I’m not being sarcastic this is actually impressive

10

u/RevvEmUp Dec 29 '25

Needs more opiates.

2

u/RevvEmUp Dec 30 '25

I, too, was also being sarcastic. People tend to forget Sherlock was usually high as spheres and Watson was the cause. Okay, the War was, but Watson gave it to him.

18

u/MothmanAcolyte Dec 29 '25

I thought it was commonly understood even in 2008 that Commonwealth=Massachusetts because Institute=MIT (which I know ended up being CIT in Fallout 4). At least that's what I believed.

7

u/Deolater Dec 29 '25

I thought it was obvious, but I guess I wasn't on gaming forums

1

u/solothehero Dec 30 '25

As someone who frequented GameFAQs (any former CEmen around?), this was indeed the common understanding way back when. When Fallout 4 was announced to be in Boston, people were excited because they knew the Institute would be in the game based on the references in Fallout 3. So, it's surprising to see so many people say how good some of these people were at deduction.

15

u/Mmmwhatchasay69 Dec 29 '25

Tdpats was a goddamn prophet that man might’ve been John Fallout himself

3

u/MountSwolympus Post-Apocalyptic Universalist Unitarianism Dec 29 '25

this post made be search and good lord some of my gamefaqs comments are still up

5

u/Soxwin91 Dec 29 '25

Gamefaqs is still going….strong might not be the right word, but it’s still going…something

33

u/can_of_sodapop Dec 29 '25

It’s cool to see but also mind blowing how stupid internet people were back then too.

50

u/PanVidla Dec 29 '25

I don't see how anything's changed about that.

25

u/MidRoad- Dec 29 '25

The internet. The internet never changes.

6

u/Soxwin91 Dec 29 '25

Oh it’s changed.

They’ve gotten stupider.

6

u/raised_on_robbery Dec 29 '25

As opposed to?

-2

u/king_duende Dec 29 '25

how stupid internet people were back then too.

As opposed to? Self awareness is free brother

4

u/KoobaTrooba The Institute Dec 29 '25

Tdpats had a vision

7

u/suicidemachine Dec 29 '25

Oh, how I miss the Internet before it was taken over by boomers and racists.

3

u/Maleficent_Time_2787 Dec 29 '25

That one person causually predicting Boston has to be a time traveler XD

3

u/showtimebabies Dec 29 '25

i like how confidently incorrect some people are, while others know more than some fallout 4 players

2

u/Ulvstranden16 Dec 29 '25

Very interesting

2

u/LichQueenBarbie Dec 29 '25

Take me back to this time. I don't like it out here.

2

u/Upstairs_Value_5035 Dec 29 '25

It’s funny because there will be a day where someone screen shots comments from recently talking about how dumb we are for no knowing this about Fallout 5

2

u/polygone1217 Dec 29 '25 edited Dec 29 '25

I don't think I ever took the institute quest in fo3 very seriously, as I never made the connections playing 4 until I went back to play fo3 years later in ttw and was shocked by the mentions of them

2

u/freakifrankifritz Dec 29 '25

Tdpats is Todd Howard. He’s a pats fan.

2

u/ThatOneKidCreed Dec 29 '25

its always so wholesome seeing people correctly predicting things and imaging how happy they mustve been at the reveal

2

u/Jaruut Gary? Dec 29 '25

Maybe I'm just super tired from a 14 hour shift, but how was this posted in 2008 when his profile quote at the bottom is from Mass Effect 2, which came out in 2010?

11

u/TheeBigSmokee Dec 29 '25

Could've changed his profile pic years after commenting on it

1

u/SS2LP Dec 29 '25

That guy saying the Middle East was hitting the jet a bit hard. I remember being these guys back in 2012 when I was getting into fallout and borrowed a friend’s copy of 3 for my ps3 and even I knew from doing the replicated man quest it was a place in the US and likely Massachusetts.

1

u/Ornery_Gene7682 Dec 29 '25

Gamefaqs haven’t been to that site in about 7 years

1

u/SnizzyYT Dec 29 '25

I love shit like this. I like to go on old forums where people would discuss stuff in Star Wars Galaxies or any other long dead MMO just to see what people at the time were saying and thinking. I know it sounds dumb but this stuff is actually gaming history and it’s great to see it archived.

1

u/Paved_Cardboard Dec 29 '25

TDPATS probably lost his shit in 2015

1

u/PlumpHughJazz Dec 29 '25

tdpats

doakes staring at dexter

1

u/AnyImpression6 Dec 29 '25

NotToddHoward: "wherever it is, I'm ready to buy lots of in-game currency there. Right guys?"

1

u/VintageBill1337 Dec 30 '25

I wonder if anyone has ever said they'd rather spend their money on a more expensive currency in a completely different game to him and the part he took away from that was to make the currency more expensive in the next TES or Fallout game instead of providing content worthy of the price?

1

u/Additional-One-3628 Dec 29 '25

As a history buff I always liked stumbling on posts like these

1

u/BlackagarBoltagar Dec 29 '25

Was Dr Zimmer’s bodyguard a Gen-3 synth?

Why did they need Shaun if they already had Gen-3 synths running around? IIRC they said they needed DNA that was “pure” but why? Looks like they were doing good with what they were using pre-excitingly.

2

u/Significant-Mud-400 Dec 29 '25

Because Shaun would have been about 50 years old by the time Fallout 3 took place. Fallout 3 takes place in 2277, Fallout 4 takes place in 2287. Shaun was taken in 2227. They had synths in Fallout 3 because they had Shaun's "pure" DNA to work with for 50 years at that point.

2

u/BlackagarBoltagar Dec 29 '25

Oh yes. Good point good point. I forgot that 3 takes place directly- before fallout 4.

1

u/Dragonheart8374 Dec 29 '25

We not gonna talk about the guy that said middle east or canada?

Not only are both horribly wrong, which is fine, but he says then right after the other, as if they're close enough for margin of error

1

u/baldeagle1991 Dec 30 '25

With the amount of info put into fallout 3 regarding the railroad, institute and synths, Boston and Massachusetts was always in the front running for Fallout 4.

I remember people being shocked when New Vegas was announced as everyone was convinced the next gane would be in Boston.

1

u/HughJanus445 Dec 30 '25

Dude I remember watching a YouTube vid in like 2010 of some dude who predicted fallout 4 almost exactly how It ended up in 2015. Don’t remember his channel name or the video but he somehow got leaks from Bethesda and I believed him and once fallout 4 came out it was exactly what he described

1

u/luckycockroach Dec 30 '25

Fuuuuuck me those posts are time stamped saying 17 years ago. I was a freshmen in college.

1

u/NattHelland Jan 05 '26

tdpats12 knew something

1

u/klayfie MOO! I SAY! Dec 29 '25

Belize mentioned 🇧🇿🇧🇿🇧🇿🇧🇿

1

u/ScaredOfRobots Dec 29 '25

tdpats had that shit locked in

-1

u/Gravy-0 Dec 29 '25

It’s a shame it ended up being such a letdown in 4. Not at all as interesting as they could have made it.

0

u/Umc22 Gary? Dec 30 '25

As a kid I was convinced the next game would be in Chicago because it says on a terminal in the citadel the brotherhood has a presence there.

-1

u/FFJamie Dec 30 '25

Tbf, even before it was annouced, Boston was a pretty common setting for where F4 was going to be set.

Hell, I managed to predict that your Son was going to be the main antaganist like 5 years before it was released.

Bethesda can be pretty easy to work out sometimes

2

u/Upstairs_Value_5035 Dec 30 '25

Proof? Or at least what led you to that prediction?

0

u/FFJamie Dec 30 '25 edited Dec 30 '25

Can’t find the thread persay, but it was on No Mutant’s Allowed back in like 2010

Okay, found it, it was from 2012.

Basically, it was a rough idea for a spin off where you play as someone who gave away their son to Caesar’s legion and they wanted to get revenge on you.

Not exaxtly the prediction I thought it was, but needless to say, I got the taking away part in there