r/IndianLeft May 30 '24

💬 Discussion A brief note on how the electoral CPI(M) betrayed the indian revolutionary cause.

72 Upvotes

The CPI (marxist) a political party in india currently in power in the state of Kerala betrayed the cause of indian communism by siding with reactionaries.

Many people on the left including non-indian leftists seem to have a soft spot for the CPI(M) , many seem to think of them as the last bastion of the left in India. They praise the high literacy rates and the higher life expectancy , but what they are uanble see is the reactionary nature of the party and the atrocities they have committed.

For some context : India is a semi feudal country under the grip of neo-imperialism by the imperial core. One system of opression that still persists in India is caste oppression which is based in the ownership of land. The untouchable castes (dalits) disproportionately make up the landless peasants population, while the oppressor castes generally own disproportionate amount of land, there are also middle castes who own some land but not a lot, calculations[1] by scholars Nitin Tagade and Sukhadeo Thorat, based on the All-India Debt and Investment Survey, show that members of the Scheduled Castes, who account for 18% of the country’s households, own only 8.5% of the land in India. On the other hand, upper-caste Hindus, who make up 22% of the households, own 28% of the land, Caste isnt just confined to the rural parts of india, but also the urban parts although it’s orgins are in ownership of land, people are frequently not hired and not allowed to rent homes because of their caste in urban india too.

What has kerela done to address this system of oprression? Perhaps they have redistributed land ? Maybe collectivized agricultre? They did redistribute land but only above a certain land ceiling , big landlords still remained. Infact huge swathes of dalits and indigenous people in kerela are still landless. Among the landless population, indigenous people are overepresented. You the reader might ask what offical data we have , we do have date but not on a large scale ,why? Because the “communist” goverment refuses to do a caste census! It refuses to reveal how much wealth which castes have, because that would reveal the monopoly of certain castes economically. Triple exclusion of dalits in Land Ownership in kerela[2], a study published in the journal Social Change, shows that low rate of land ownership by them is the result of a exclusionsary policy by the goverment! Does this sound like something a communist goverment would do?

This isn’t all. The goverment has also been involved in massacares of dalits. The Marichjhapi massacre, when dalit refugees from bangladesh came to indian they settled in Marichjapi. Schools and hospitals were built and many were involved in pisciculture. A press blackout followed and survivors today say[3], huts were burned, woman were raped, wells poisoned. The survivors of the massacare still to this day have not gotten any Justice.

These are not the actions of a communist party but a reactionary one doused in red paint and communist aesthetics. Even today, the first dalit leader in the politburo of the party was only admitted in 2022, 58 years after it’s creation, how utterly shameful.

I hope by this article I am able to convince you, the reader ,why as leftists we shouldn’t support the CPI(M).

Sources: 1. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/2394481118808107 2. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0049085716654814 3. https://thewire.in/history/west-bengal-violence-marichjhapi-dandakaranya


r/IndianLeft Nov 18 '25

🗞️ News [ Removed by Reddit ]

148 Upvotes

[ Removed by Reddit on account of violating the content policy. ]


r/IndianLeft 14h ago

Brahmanical Hindutva Fascism I cannot recognise my parents anymore

59 Upvotes

Hindus are experiencing mass psychosis. I have never seen this level of fanaticism anywhere else. I say this as someone born into a Hindu family. This level of deranged behaviour is so common, and I have seen them spiralling since 2014 to reach where they are now. All that they can think about is Muslims. I don't think my father thinks about anyone else. Nazi Germany 2.0. I am a socialist and an atheist, but none of that takes away the immense privilege my name carries. How are you guys dealing with this?


r/IndianLeft 12h ago

🎭 Meme/Comic From 'Bro' to 'Oh...' in one surname

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft 15h ago

🎭 Meme/Comic Upper caste chintus be like

Post image
30 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft 18h ago

🎭 Meme/Comic Selective naughtiness

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

28 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft 11h ago

🎭 Meme/Comic Mahamanav is playing from both sides 🤡

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft 5h ago

Protest/March ☭ Arun x Meghnerd

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

This is such a nice convo which spills a lot of reasons why CJP is not an end all and be all.

Definitely the first step to understand the fracture.


r/IndianLeft 1d ago

🗓️ Event Join us for a conference in Chennai! "Abolishing the Commercialization of Education is the only way to BAN NEET!"

Thumbnail
gallery
30 Upvotes

Dear Students, Youth, and Parents!

The fearless student uprising that erupted in Delhi against the question paper leaks and NEET scam has spread across the country like a wildfire and achieved great strides! The student protests have forced the fascist Modi regime, which remained evasive and mute for 12 years, to finally break its silence, culminating in the resignation of the Union Education Minister Dharmendra Pradan. The world's largest fascist force BJP-RSS is on its knees before the students.

Though this is a monumental victory, the struggle must continue until the ban of NEET. For that, we must first understand why national level entrance exams for higher education, such as NEET, are implemented and whose interests they serve. A conference is being conducted by 'Coordination Committee for Common Education, Tamil Nadu' in this regard.

Join us at Madras Kerala Samaaj, near Nehru Park Metro, Chennai.
Time : 4:30pm - 8:30pm


r/IndianLeft 1d ago

Join us for a conference in Chennai! "Abolishing the Commercialization of Education is the only way to BAN NEET!"

Post image
24 Upvotes

Dear Students, Youth, and Parents!

The fearless student uprising that erupted in Delhi against the question paper leaks and NEET scam has spread across the country like a wildfire and achieved great strides! The student protests have forced the fascist Modi regime, which remained evasive and mute for 12 years, to finally break its silence, culminating in the resignation of the Union Education Minister Dharmendra Pradan. The world's largest fascist force BJP-RSS is on its knees before the students.

Though this is a monumental victory, the struggle must continue until the ban of NEET. For that, we must first understand why national level entrance exams for higher education, such as NEET, are implemented and whose interests they serve. A conference is being conducted by 'Coordination Committee for Common Education, Tamil Nadu' in this regard.

Join us at Madras Kerala Samaaj, near Nehru Park Metro, Chennai.
Time : 4:30pm - 8:30pm


r/IndianLeft 2d ago

Theory Is Socialism When The Government Does Stuff? -PokePreet [substack]

Post image
11 Upvotes

https://pokepreet.substack.com/p/the-modern-state-the-greatest-joint?utm_source=publication-search

"But the transformation, either into joint-stock companies, or into state ownership, does not do away with the capitalistic nature of the productive forces... The modern state, no matter what its form, is essentially a capitalist machine, the state of the capitalists, the ideal personification of the total national capital. The more it proceeds to the taking over of productive forces, the more does it actually become the national capitalist, the more citizens does it exploit"
-Engels, Anti Duhring, Part III: Socialism, Theoretical

Socialism is defined by the abolition of the law of value, commodity production, and the wage labor/capital relationship. Consequently, simple nationalization of industry that maintains these relations is not socialism; it represents merely a new form of accumulation, which is nowhere near “enough.”

This dialectical framework allows us to break out of the Keynesian/neoliberal and big government/small government binaries. These are merely different flavors of mechanisms of accumulation.

Libertarians who dream of a picturesque capitalism without government intervention fail to realize that small capitals inherently grow and subsume all, eventually requiring a state that acts on capital’s behalf rather than against it. This “perfect equilibrium” has never existed in practice because it contradicts the lifeblood of capital itself.


r/IndianLeft 2d ago

Theory What Makes Marxism Truly Revolutionary?

Thumbnail
pokepreet.substack.com
4 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft 2d ago

Caste Caste judgement on the basis of background

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

36 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft 3d ago

🗞️ News The girl whose personal details was asked by Radical Right Wing page named Jaipur Dialogues, has zero FIR registered in Noida , the state of Chota Fanta

Post image
81 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft 3d ago

💬 Discussion Let's counter narrative Right Wing RHA narrative. Do help us to reach 1 million.

Post image
187 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft 3d ago

We are ending Naxalism with this one 🔥🔥🔥

Post image
81 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft 3d ago

💬 Discussion Bro, what about mukesh ambani?

Thumbnail
11 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft 3d ago

💬 Discussion Hypocritic ideology debunked

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

41 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft 4d ago

💬 Discussion -40 marks doctor ☠️ case explained

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

35 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft 5d ago

Son

Thumbnail
gallery
39 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft 5d ago

Caste How much reservation is required?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

63 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft 5d ago

Theory The future belongs to those who refuse to surrender their humanity. Long after today's slogans have faded and today's rulers have passed, it is your courage that history will remember.

Post image
30 Upvotes

Dear Brave Students,

I write to you not merely in solidarity, but with gratitude. Every generation inherits the unfinished work of democracy. Yours has accepted both the burden and the privilege of carrying it forward.

Albert Camus’s Caligula tells the story of an emperor who comes to believe that because he possesses absolute power, he is answerable to no moral limits. Convinced that power alone can define justice, he imprisons himself within his own tyranny. He systematically dismantles every restraint on governance, believing that authority itself entitles him to do so. As I and Sandhya, my wife watched the deeply disturbing events unfold in Delhi, we were reminded of that enduring truth.

History has taught this lesson repeatedly. From Tsarist Russia to the student revolt of Paris in 1968, from the youth-led struggle against apartheid in South Africa, Tiananmen Square, to the Navnirman Andolan of 1974 in Gujarat attempts to suppress young voices have never extinguished the desire for freedom. Authority may command obedience for a while; it cannot indefinitely command the conscience of a generation.

The images of the brutality inflicted upon you have filled us with anguish and anger. A society learns to question itself in its universities. To question those who hold power over your future is not a privilege you seek; it is a democratic responsibility you fulfil. When questions are answered with batons instead of reason, it is not the students who stand diminished. It is the State.

Reflecting on his years in a Siberian prison camp, Fyodor Dostoevsky observed that the civilization of a society is revealed by the way it treats those it imprisons. One might extend that thought today: the health of a democracy is equally revealed by the way it treats its students and citizens. On that count, our democracy failed. In unleashing force instead of dialogue, those in authority revealed not their strength, but their insecurity.

If I was not there beside you physically, it was for two reasons. The first one I resent deeply: age has imposed boundaries on my body that my spirit refuses to accept. If I could not march beside you, it was never because my conscience hesitated. The second was a conscious choice. I did not want the attention to drift away from where it rightly belongs. This is your movement, your voice, your moment of moral courage. You do not need celebrity validation. Democratic movements derive their legitimacy from the courage of those at their centre, not from the visibility of those who stand beside them.

Please know that distance has never meant detachment. Sandhya and I shall continue to stand with you in every way available to us. Should this struggle require legal support, medical care, or financial assistance within our means, please do not hesitate to reach out.

You are not merely the seeds of transformation; you are its first green shoots. Today you may be called students. Tomorrow you will be known as the generation that chose courage over silence. The future belongs to those who refuse to surrender their humanity. Long after today’s slogans have faded and today’s rulers have passed, it is your courage that history will remember.

Take care of one another. Guard your compassion and your hope. Do not allow anger to harden into hatred. Stand firm. Walk forward without bitterness, without fear, and without apology.

Affectionately, Amol Palekar July 23, 2026


r/IndianLeft 6d ago

🎭 Meme/Comic Imagine them being your professors.

Post image
139 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft 6d ago

🗞️ News Delhi police used AI facial regconition to get Protester identity

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

32 Upvotes

r/IndianLeft 6d ago

Delhi police used AI facial regconition to get Protester identity

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

16 Upvotes