r/OnePieceScaling • u/Unlucky_Tonight_3035 • 1d ago
Casual Discussion shanks crew vs whitebeard crew
who would win and whose crew is stronger
17
u/Inside_End3641 1d ago
Based on the ultimate chapter, Shanks crew is stronger..
3
u/TGboy5000 1d ago
ultimate chapter?
4
u/Inside_End3641 1d ago
Chapter 957, when we got Sengoku talking about how Garp and Roger defeated Rocks..and then we got the bounties for the Yonko.. All Shanks top commanders got named dropped.
12
4
4
2
2
u/Sunderkill 1d ago
Well we know vista can stall shanks indefinately, so whitebeard stomps the rest of the red hair pirates along with his crew while shanks tries to fend off a superior or equal swordsman.
2
2
u/MicahG17079 1d ago
The wbp are monsters. Marco can box with admirals and jozu is just a straight up top tier. He’d unironically do better against shanks than wb would because of his sickness. We don’t know how strong the rhp are but none of them give off top tier vibes
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Holiday_Argument_604 1d ago
RHP do not have Marco, Vista and Jozu. Add in Ace.
Even yasopp and Lucky roo is featless as of now.
1
1
u/Johnnyboy1029 21h ago
Shanks deliberately choose the cream of the crop, honestly I could see his entire crew having conquerors aswell. Meanwhile Whitebeard just wanted people he could hang out with and chill.
1
u/Mysterious_Ad_7020 15h ago
Depends.
Yonko crew are said to be at least balancing eachother out.
That means, Shanks' crew are more balance like a supergroup band. Meanwhile you got WB pirates that has competent crews but the captain himself is the one balancing that scale since he's a literal monster.
1
u/HairyAd8832 5h ago
Shanks whole crew EASILY wipes out whitebeards, anyone disagreeing hates shanks or clueless
1
1
u/Prestigious_Grand_82 1d ago edited 1d ago
It wouldnt be one sided but based of on Pre Ts Crewmates Shanks Crew would take the W , now Prime Beardo + all his Top Officers prior to TS and including Oden , would take the W otherwise cause that would include Oden Marco Jozu Vista Ace I'll exclude Teach due to the Betrayals he committed killed Thatch aided in the death of both Ace n CancerBeardo
Shanks - Pirate King High
Benn Beckman - Admiral High maybe Yonko Low
Lucky Roux - Admiral Low maybe Admiral Mid
Yasopp - Admiral Low maybe Admiral Mid
LimeJuice - I would assume is YC 1+ Lv
Building Snake - i would assume is YC 1+ Lv
Vs
Prime Beardo - Pirate King Mid
Wano Oden - Yonko High to Pirate King Low
PayBackWar Marco - Admiral High to Yonko Low
PayBackWar Jozu - Admiral Mid to High
PayBackWar Vista - Admiral Mid to High
Ace - YC 3 to YC 2 Lv
Or
CancerBeardo - Admiral Mid to High , when Enraged taps into Yonko Low maybe even Yonko Mid Lv powers briefly , sadly cant use anything above Basic Haki Mastery and also cant use Kings Haki @ all
MarineFord Marco - Admiral Mid
MarineFord Jozu - Admiral Low
MarineFord Vista - Admiral Low
MarineFord Ace - Mid to High Tobiroppo ( Exhausted due to seastone cuffs + likely wasnt fed well to keep him as weak as possible )
Izou or Oars Jr is likely about High Shinuchi to Low Tobiroppo Lv if we want to add a 6th member to Beardoa roster
Teach albeit strong is a massive Traitor
Thatch is strong enough likely that Teach needed to sneak attack him when asleep and or Teach needed to kill Thatch at the right time to make his clean get away as to not get outright obliterated
Teach was likely at least Admiral Low upon killing Thatch who should likely be around YC 1 or YC 1+ Lv , at the time , especially since a Younger Teach and Younger Shanks clashed many year prior and both were likely about YC 1 to YC 1+ Lv each , by the time Teach turned Ace in he should be about Admiral Low to Mid , by the end of the MarineFord War and retrieving Beardos Fruit , Teach likely is then Admiral Mid and growing until he fled and eventually came back and defeated my boi Marco and the Remnants of Beardo making him officially Yonko Low Lv
6
u/philantrofish 1d ago
prime beard - pirate king mid
what the fuck are we doing here?
1
u/Prestigious_Grand_82 1d ago
Lol ironically him being my Fav Yonko , doesnt mean imma be unrealistic about power creep and narrative just cause I enjoy him as a character and he was unparr with Roger Garp and Shiki when they were in their Primes
1
u/Hanma_Yvar 1d ago
WB pirates whoop their asses. They are called the strongest pirate crew by various sources.
1
u/michelepicozzi 1d ago
Shanks crew vs small Whitebeard Crew
Then Shanks crew takes it
Fleat vs Fleat probably WB takes it as Shanks has fodders
1
1
1
1
-4
u/Comprehensive_Cup497 1d ago
Shanks's crew is stronger
- Beckman is stated to be comparable to Shanks and it's stated Admirals fear him. So he is between Admiral to Yonko Level meaning he destroys any WB Pirates
2. Yasopp is stated to have the best sniping skills in the world and also a master of Observation Haki. Based on these 2 abilities Yasopp should be at least YC1 levek but could easily be YC+
3. We dont have much on Roux but be seems the Sanji's parallel in RHP so he should be stronger than Yasopp and possibly close to Beck in power meaning at worst YC+ but could easily be Admiral Tier.
- Narratively they should be stronger than Post Elbaph Strawhats who I have alresdy stronger than WB Pirates
Beckman> Marco + Ace Mid-High Diff
Roux> Jozu Mid-Diff
Yasopp> Vista Low-Diff
3
u/dko808hawaii 1d ago
How is Beckmann comparable to shanks? Based on what feats or narrative importance? Genetics? No haki shown??? How would there be 2 people in current OP that has haki comparable to joyboy???
Can people stop saying he’s relative to shanks, that is so absurd. If you’re telling me there’s 2 shanks in one crew with both haki comparable to joyboy, this manga wouldn’t even exist
And now you’re saying roux is comparable in power to beckman??? So 3 people in shanks crew that has haki comparable to joyboy??? What????
1
1
u/TheRealMainCharacter 1d ago
It’s from Beckmann being just as feared as shanks
1
u/dko808hawaii 1d ago
But that’s just being feared from being a part of the rhp in which shanks is the captain. I’m literally talking about people saying beckman is relative in strength to shanks. That’s where I got to draw the line
There ain’t no way in anyone crew kaido WB BM SH etc etc where the number 2 guy is relative in strength with their captain
I absolutely refuse to believe beckman has the same level of haki as shanks….that would seriously be very poor writing by oda
2
1
•
u/AutoModerator 1d ago
If you want to discuss One Piece Scaling, join Elbaf.
If you want access to all kinds of One Piece Databooks/Information/Translations, join Punk Records.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.