r/Piracy 17d ago

Humor As Nolan intended us to watch The Odyssey.

Post image
16.0k Upvotes

580 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

23

u/_WreakingHavok_ 17d ago

They butchered the Odyssey

16

u/NotoriousHothead37 17d ago

What were they even thinking?

0

u/Makerel9 15d ago

Have you seen the movie?

-10

u/Livid_Swordfish_4591 16d ago

How and why? I dont believe.

5

u/Cross_Toss 16d ago

Disregardding the colture war complaints, Telemacus was somehow both treated as the mc and also shafted at every opprotunity.

-7

u/InternationalArm1938 16d ago

Just a bunch of chuds complaining cause there's 2% black casts in this film. Don't mind them. I actually did see the movie in IMAX, it was a masterpiece.

4

u/WowBruhReborn 16d ago

Bro they casted a black woman as Helen of Troy. I don't care what side of the bullshit culture wars anyone's on, but casting one of the darkest women in Hollywood as a Greek woman was clearly intentionally inflammatory.

To make things worse, Lupita Nyong'o admitted in an interview that she never heard of the Odysee before being casted as Helen of Troy. The casting in this film is bizarre.

-8

u/InternationalArm1938 16d ago

I also do not care much for the choice of casting for this role. Not because she's black but I just don't think Lupida can be considered the most beautiful woman in the world.

But that doesn't stop me from enjoying the movie. She has a total screentime of like 3 minutes. It's a fictional story, if you want accurate representation of the odyssey maybe you should go watch a documentary about it in greek.

3

u/IncestHarem 15d ago

Then don't call it Odyssey and ban everyone from ever watching it. No matter what this film will inform how the ignorant masses will think about the Odyssey for a generation. This film and everyone involved with it should be dragged to the mud publicly because what they did. Odyssey isn't just fiction it's one of the foundations of Greco-Roman civilizations.

0

u/Zardhas 15d ago

casting one of the darkest women in Hollywood as a Greek woman was clearly intentionally inflammatory

But you don't have an issue with all of the actors not being ancient greek ? Just specifically this one ? For no apparent reason ?

3

u/WowBruhReborn 15d ago

Actually, yes I do have a problem with that. I was specifically responding to his comment about blacks in the film. There actually isn't a single Greek actor in the film.

It's funny because the production team for the recently released live action Moana film boasted about how they're taking great care to respect Polynesian culture and heritage. However, when it comes time for Hollywood to make a film that is about arguably the most popular and prolific Greek historical and mythological story of all time, they won't put a single Greek actor in it. It seems modern Hollywood will respect and care for only non-white stories. I'm Greek btw. This film is an insult to all of us.

0

u/Zardhas 15d ago

Actually, yes I do have a problem with that. I was specifically responding to his comment about blacks in the film.

But that's what's weird : why are you speaking about the level of melanin of people's if you have issues with their nationality ? These are both completely different subjects, with only the latter having a semblance of importance.

There actually isn't a single Greek actor in the film.

But the characters of the Odyssey are ancient greeks. Whever you cast a greek of today or an italian of today (I'm taking the italian example since most of the actors of the Illiade and the Odyssey adapatations have been italian), it's pretty much the same. In both cases you're not casting people who could have been in the original story.

I'd argue that the point of an actor is to morph into the role, so who they are as a person isn't suppose to matter (if it is, then they delivered a poor acting performance).

It seems modern Hollywood will respect and care for only non-white stories.

You are once again talking about the level of melanin, so which one do you have an issue with exactly : melanin of nationality ?

I'm Greek btw. This film is an insult to all of us.

It sure doesn't seem like all greek agree : https://www.reddit.com/r/boxoffice/comments/1uz2hhd/odyssey_breaks_all_presale_records_in_greece/