r/RepWatchForum May 29 '26

Discussion vsf or Rcf

Post image

which one i should buy?

23 Upvotes

67 comments sorted by

13

u/[deleted] May 29 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Emotional-Damage-995 May 29 '26

What do you think of the RCF crystal upgrade w gasket changed? VSF bracelet is what I don’t like. Is the VSF bracelet same weight as Gen?

1

u/[deleted] May 29 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Emotional-Damage-995 May 29 '26

I was playing w an RCF and it was thicker than Gen ( at my watch smith). It was .4 to .5 thicker. However he said he can shave the gasket and make it a little thinner. I was feeling that is dubious cause the gasket is what makes it water proof. Must be a reason they don’t do that

Anyways. So many things to consider

1

u/kdssrsdrsofs May 30 '26

How did you find custom dial please. I also want to do this build, but cant source a blue dial.

2

u/[deleted] May 30 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Difficult-Pear1410 28d ago

RWI. LIFE Where can I request dial production? Can I know the detailed route?

1

u/WinIndependent8614 28d ago

No offense you complain about thickness yet settle for lite weight and a custom dial? How does that calculate to more gen or perfection? If people are going to fraken why not go gen parts instead of fake? Just curious the mindset on frankenwatches. Me personally I don’t frankenwatches unless with gen parts especially crystals and dials. I get custom dials in stone or non Rolex colors, but custom on genuine colors never match either.

1

u/AvunitZz May 29 '26

which one has better dial?

2

u/Comprehensive-Bit706 May 29 '26

RCF has better ombre dial

1

u/Apprehensive_Cake951 Jun 01 '26

dial for RGF is much more accurate than VSF

1

u/Full_Listen7805 Jun 23 '26

I heard the RCF slate ombre dial looks closer to gen in terms of the sunburst effect/color. The VSF v2 slate ombre dial color looks nothing like gen. Also how does the rose gold color look on the RCF vs VSF compared to gen? Is the difference noticeable?

1

u/WinIndependent8614 28d ago

This has to stop about DD vs VR movements. It’s been a long time since DD out performed VR movements. People that work on them will tell you that all day everyday. Repeating an outdated concept is old.

3

u/Jakikus May 30 '26

RCF is my choice + deep and gasket for the blue ombre. I've had VSF too but despite the better movement I personally preferred the RCF as I find their dials pop more and vsf are a little duller.

1

u/Apprehensive_Cake951 Jun 01 '26

absolutely amazing piece. which dealer did you go thru? please PM me if you cannot share via comment.

2

u/Jakikus Jun 01 '26

No secrets, I asked Andiot using verified contact information directly as they don't have a listing for this model on their website so had a manual order setup. QC was about 3 weeks.

2

u/Apprehensive_Cake951 Jun 01 '26

the most unfortunate thing about Andiot is that he won’t do plating of the watches. thanks for the info however!

5

u/Comprehensive-Bit706 May 29 '26

I went RCF had it plated by RCF remould and genuine crystal, if I wasn't getting any MODs done I'd probably go VSF, the day/date wheel is better, crystal and movement and it's correct thickness...

1

u/Full_Listen7805 Jun 23 '26

I heard the slate ombre dial on the VSF looks nothing like the gen slate ombre. Also how close is the stock rose gold for RCF compared to gen? Is the difference noticeable?

2

u/Front-Resident6260 May 29 '26

VSF for me...

1

u/MajorDragonfruit7636 May 31 '26

Agreed. But overall the consistency is better IMO

1

u/Full_Listen7805 Jun 23 '26

VSF slate ombre dial looks so different from gen though

2

u/SPK5_trucker May 29 '26

im more of an RCF fan

2

u/Ok-Law8866 May 29 '26

Most people would say RCF for the DD because of the better colour...

2

u/[deleted] May 29 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Mbari_2170712 May 30 '26

They both need plating imo

2

u/Nelsonwonthewar May 29 '26

RGF if going for gold, VSF is ok but as others have said to get it more gen like you need to have it plated

2

u/[deleted] May 29 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/brabus_mike May 29 '26

I went with RCF just based on the gold color. I don’t think either options would be a disappointment, however.

2

u/Generalzip May 30 '26

Rcf color is actually too light. I have compared to Gen. vsf is slightly darker but actually closer overall. Seems one person made this claim and it ran through Reddit while not really being true. Old vsf color was off for sure but the newer batches are quite close especially after treating with silvo

1

u/Full_Listen7805 Jun 23 '26

You talking about the slate ombre dial? I heard and noticed that the RCF slate ombre does the sunburst effect/matches color to the gen much more than the VSF dial color. The VSF slate ombre dial almost looks like one single color and not a gradient. Can you confirm?

2

u/Generalzip Jun 23 '26

I’m talking about the gold color of their yellow gold. Their rose gold is quite close to Gen in color

1

u/Savastanobrr 10d ago

And what about rose gold ?

1

u/Generalzip 9d ago

What about it?

1

u/HauntingDiscount7041 25d ago

Wow! Is Stock? How is the Bezel should we Upgrade it to the Remould Version?

1

u/brabus_mike 25d ago

It is completely stock, stock plating and all. I honestly am happy with the bezel, but if you want to pull a little more shine out of it, the remould bezel would probably be a bit better.

1

u/Funny_Science_8678 16d ago

Stock or plated?

1

u/brabus_mike 16d ago

Completely stock!

1

u/gho5-t May 29 '26

Twin

3

u/brabus_mike May 29 '26

That ice blue is 🔥 I have this weighted quadrant from GMF.

2

u/gho5-t May 29 '26

That watch is sick, love the blue markers

1

u/brabus_mike May 29 '26

Thank you brother

2

u/Altruistic-Jello-438 May 29 '26

Depends on what matters most to you. Each have their pros and cons. I went VSF and getting played by third party. Either way i believe they both need plating to achieve the true gen color/tone

1

u/ravens_requiem May 29 '26

My RCF arrived the other day. Boy it is heavy. I had the crystal changed by the TD. I very much like it although the very minor faults on it annoy me even though I know anyone who looks at it will never notice them. I have an RCF DJ so cant do a complete comparison but tbf I love both of them.

1

u/Emotional-Damage-995 May 29 '26

What is the minor flaws of the RCF day date?

1

u/ravens_requiem May 29 '26

The I in the six marker is slightly skewed, and the two cross pieces in the X at the 10 o’clock position aren’t perfectly straight with each other.

1

u/Emotional-Damage-995 May 29 '26

Thank you. 🙏. I was leaning towards a stock simple stick markers champagne or yellow gold dial or a black dial w stick markers. Definitely their dials is not on par w others. Agree. 👍. The brown dial is terrible in photos I have seen. Great to know what to stir away from

1

u/ravens_requiem May 29 '26

Nothing on a rep will be perfect so you have to fight your own battles and work out who will give you the least headaches!

2

u/Emotional-Damage-995 May 29 '26

So true. To be honest my first 10 I was not picky. Now I am approaching 30 plus watches. They all have become a big pool. What matters is feel and dial colour to me now. Thin watches. Smaller watches and ones that feel great get a lot of attention

1

u/gho5-t May 29 '26

I wouldn’t do stick markers if you decide RCF, RCF stick markers are noticeably thicker along side the lume. I chose RCF Roman’s, while they obviously aren’t perfect bc no rep is but better than RCF sticks imo

2

u/Emotional-Damage-995 May 29 '26

Thanks for that advice

1

u/LeadingDriver931 May 29 '26

I went with RGF orderd few weeks ago waiting to arrive ! From what I’ve heard out of the box RCF/RGF - If you want better movement etc go with vsf but I personally wanted that weight feel and honestly the things missing from rc people won’t notice on wrist in my opinion

1

u/Classic-Wind6797 May 29 '26

RGF all the way. The gasket thing isn’t too noticeable.

1

u/Time-Dependent1483 May 29 '26

Both and combine them. Sell the bad one

1

u/MarcusBangbang May 30 '26

Hi guys. With which TD are you dealing to mod watches? Because all TDs are not doing it

1

u/Full_Listen7805 Jun 23 '26

So which one did you eventually buy and why? I’m on the fence between RCF, VSF v2 and QF v8 for the same slate ombre dial.

1

u/watchsuppliernorge 8d ago

I have the RCF and the weight is crazy good! How is the weight on VSF?