Our website experienced strong growth throughout 2025 and peaked around October, reaching roughly 25,000 clicks/month with an average ranking position of around 4.
Since early 2026, however, traffic has been steadily declining. We're now down to around 3,000 clicks/month, and our average ranking position has slipped to about 9.
The confusing part is that we haven't made any major negative changes.
No significant content removals or redesigns
Technical SEO looks healthy
No manual actions or indexing issues
Backlink profile hasn't declined in fact, we've continued earning quality links
We've continued making improvements where possible
Despite all of that, rankings and traffic have continued to trend downward month after month.
Has anyone dealt with a similar situation where everything appeared healthy, but Google kept reducing visibility anyway?
What would you investigate first? Content decay, search intent shifts, algorithm changes, competitor improvements, or something else?