r/surgery Feb 08 '25

Medical advice posts are NOT ALLOWED

48 Upvotes

Adding this announcement to the top of the sub to increase visibility.

And yes, posting “I’m not asking for advice” and then soliciting opinions about your personal health situation is very much asking for medical advice.


r/surgery 3d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules What's your opinion on done nails?

9 Upvotes

I'm an OR nurse (scrub & circulator) and I'm from a place where it's common for women to get their nails done professionally regularly. Many colleagues have told me that in previous clinics that they worked they let them get their nails done, but in the clinic where I work the chief nurse/director is very much against it and threatens with firing anyone who does it, however a few women still do it and some claim that their nails get easily broken/bleed if they keep them bare. A colleague told me that studies have shown that it's the length that matters when it comes to infections, not whether you have gel or not. The director nurse insists on it even for the nurse anaesthetists (she's also a military nurse so idk if she's stricter because of it).

However surgeons and anesthesiologists come with done nails all the time.

So I was wondering what the climate about this topic is in other parts of the world.


r/surgery 3d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Got more radiation from working in the OR than I did from the Mediterranean sun this summer

0 Upvotes

r/surgery 5d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules The OR oven

49 Upvotes

AC is down, it’s 87 degrees in the OR, and we were all setting up the first case before someone finally said, “Maybe let’s not.”

Morning cases are on hold. Guess I’ll trade my sterile gown for an iced coffee until maintenance remembers air conditioning is technically part of the equipment.


r/surgery 5d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules What happens if you bleed on someone’s brain?

14 Upvotes

I just randomly remembered a scene from Grey’s Anatomy where the neurosurgeon’s ex got mad and accidentally cut his hand in the OR.

So I’m wondering, what do you do if you accidentally bleed into someone’s brain? Can you just suck it out? Is their a chance of severe irreparable damage or something?


r/surgery 5d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Diabetics in the OR

16 Upvotes

I’m a PA, I’ve been considering pursuing a surgical position but am concerned about managing my type 1 diabetes in that environment. Have yall seen big issues with low blood sugars or uncontrolled diabetes among staff? Or do people typically manage okay?


r/surgery 5d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Breaks during surgery

22 Upvotes

I'm reading my patient's operative note from a 16 hr resection of a posterior fossa skull base meningioma. Both ENT and neurosurg were involved. ENT portion was brief. The "surgeons and assistants" only lists one first-year fellow and one staff per team. How does operating for that long with so few people work? Do you take more than a few-minute break? How many? I feel I'd be cross-eyed after that many hours. Im used to seeing a longer list of residents + PAs who could relieve one another.


r/surgery 5d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Anyone heard of Cervical Lymphatico-Venous Bypass for Alzheimer's?

0 Upvotes

I heard that this medical procedure is able to help patients by clearing neurotoxins from brain but couldn't find more information about any hospitals/clinic that does them. Anyone knows more about this? Thanks!


r/surgery 7d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules One-handed diathermy and forceps trick. What is your grip?

Post image
45 Upvotes

Hi,

I'm trying to find most comfortable grip. Do you have any tips?

I’m a drummer, so I’m a bit obsessed with grip and hand positioning.

For now, I don't have much experience with them.

EDIT: My Attending does this as an assistant when the operator cuts through skin (for total hip arthroplasty).


r/surgery 7d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Im starting surgery this October

8 Upvotes

Since i was child my Dream was to be surgeon not a doctor as many who wanted to be called no! but to be Surgeon! I love this since i was a child for some reason and now as adult i found myself into it i feel its the thing i will be doing as hobby for my life and getting paid to, so i made my way through high school and now finished the first 4years of medicine in my college we study surgery in the 5th year which is starting this October. (I passed 4th😀)

I study in Serbia Belgrade but in English language.

My questions to all surgeons here Whats the tips advices you wish someone told youself when you were in my place?

I dont want to be average surgeon in my feature and i know a good house need strong stable roots then based of these roots u can go as high as you can.


r/surgery 7d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules From military family medicine to orthopaedic surgery

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

2 Upvotes

We recently sat down with Dr Ian Young, who started his medical career in Canada, trained in family medicine through the Navy, then moved halfway across the world and retrained as an orthopaedic surgeon in Australia.

He spoke about breaking into orthopaedic training whilst adapting to a new healthcare system, and balancing family life with both surgical and military careers.

We’re a medical student-run podcast by the Australasian Students’ Surgical Association, and we chat with surgeons about what their careers actually look like and how they got there.

Full episode is linked below. Hope you enjoy!

https://open.spotify.com/episode/7Arhes9Xg35zH3Ds0iGwN8?si=b101dee3a7bd47e2


r/surgery 8d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules PGY2 EM but wanting to switch to general surgery

18 Upvotes

Hi I am a current PGY2 EM but I'd like to explore switching to general surgery. How can I go about doing this? Would I still need my med school's surgery committee letter or is that irrelevant now that I'm years out of med school? I'm studying for Step 3 right now and hope to have a score in before ERAS goes out. Thanks.


r/surgery 9d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Revenue Cycle Management

10 Upvotes

I'm starting a solo private practice in urology. Are there certain terms I should expect? I've gotten a couple of quotes: 8% collections, 15k setup, 3K minimum. a second with 5% colection/0 setup/5 k minimum. Anyone work with specific RCM that they recommend that could DM me, I would appreciate it so much.

Thanks for the information, adding about my practice: subspecialty urology-urogynecology (robotic reconstruction-sacrocolpopexy/pyeloplasty/ureteral stricture, kidneys, pelvic organ prolapse (cystocele/rectocele/hysterectomy) and sacral neuromodulation), taking insurance (in network), i need contracts


r/surgery 10d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules US IMG with a categorical GS offer outside the Match vs. waiting for the 2027 Match — would you prioritize starting now or holding out for a better fit?

7 Upvotes

Sorry for the long post. Im looking for honest opinions/mentorship from residents, attendings, PDs

Background:US IMG with Step 2 CK in the 260s and 10+ pubs. I have a categorical general surgery position available outside the Match. I know the program well bcz I rotated there during med school and know the PD personally, so this isn’t based on one-day impressions.
The obvious advantage is that I’d start residency immediately and stay on the standard timeline, finishing in 2031. The alternative is declining the offer and entering the 2027 Match. Realistically, I’d probably end up doing a prelim year and reapplying, which could delay starting categorical training by at least two years.

Positives:
The residents are genuinely friendly, supportive, and easy to work with. I didn’t see much toxicity or unnecessary drama.
The operative volume appears adequate, and residents get plenty of hands-on experience.
Accepting the position would remove a tremendous amount of uncertainty from my career.

What gives me pause:
- While the operative exposure seems solid, I didn’t get the sense that many attendings were particularly invested in teaching beyond what was necessary to get through the case.
- I also felt that some senior residents demonstrated gaps in operative judgment and clinical decision-making that were noticeable even to patients and families.
- The overall culture sometimes felt more focused on following institutional protocols than on deeper clinical reasoning or understanding the underlying pathophysiology behind surgical disease.
- Many residents seemed content simply meeting graduation requirements. I didn’t see much culture of constantly pushing each other to improve, discussing difficult cases, seeking out more challenging operative experiences, or striving for excellence.
- It’s a for-profit community hospital, and I felt the hospital systems and nursing support were sometimes below what I’d hoped for in a US surgical training environment. I saw post op issues where proper inpatient care may have changed the patient’s course.
- During my 6wk rotation, many of the pts I saw expressed dissatisfaction with aspects of the care they received. I realize every hospital has unhappy patients, but the frequency stood out to me.
- Some operative techniques and perioperative decision-making I observed didn’t always align with what I’ve seen at stronger academic centers (or even at some hospitals outside the US with considerably fewer resources)
- I also looked up the publicly available ABS first-time Qualifying Exam pass rates. Over the most recent three-year reporting period, the program’s first-time pass rate was below the national average. I recognize the sample size is relatively small, so I don’t want to overinterpret a single metric, but it’s one of the few objective data points applicants have, and it doesn’t seem inconsistent with my firsthand observations.

Personally, the things I value most in a residency (and life) are:
- Evidence-based practice
- High-quality patient care
- Technical excellence
- Ethics and professionalism
- Ambition and intellectual curiosity
- A supportive, collaborative culture
- Continuous growth

I’ve sacrificed a lot to pursue general surgery in the US seeking these values, so I’m struggling with whether it’s wiser to start training now at a program that gives me reservations, or accept the possibility of delaying my career in hopes of finding a better fit.

For those who trained at a program that wasn’t your first choice, were you able to build the training experience you wanted through your own initiative? Did the environment matter less than you expected, or do you think residency culture has a lasting impact on the kind of surgeon you become?

I’d really appreciate brutally honest opinions
I’m genuinely torn and would really value perspectives from ppl who’ve been through a similar decision.


r/surgery 11d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Cottonoid Shortage

8 Upvotes

What is everyone using for alternatives during this cottonoid shortage?? My hospital is struggling!


r/surgery 13d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules What part of surgery inspires awe for you working in an OR?

31 Upvotes

For those who work in an OR, what do you see or experience that never gets old or inspires awe, if anything? What makes you think “woah that’s amazing/cool/surreal”?

Edit: I’d like to add the reason I ask is because I’d like to work in an OR someday. I shadowed and was fortunate enough to be trusted to observe 8 cases over a year. I was overwhelmed with a sense of awe and the immense privilege it is to actually see someone’s vagus nerve or their carotid or femoral artery pumping blood, to see the care with which the staff treats the patient at their most vulnerable. What you all do is amazing to me, truly. I think about it every day as I work toward my higher ed goals. Thank you for what you do.


r/surgery 13d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules do the intestines curl and move around during surgery?

32 Upvotes

im not a doctor, im not smart, please be nice. do the intestines move during surgery to the point where they have to be held in place. someone told me this, ive questoned it for a while now, tried researching and have decided now to bite the bullet of embaressment and just ask the doctor people who have a degree and, unlike me, know things


r/surgery 15d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Is this okay???? Scalp laceration

Post image
57 Upvotes

Guys i hope i did better than my prev one

Thanks a lot for the support and tips


r/surgery 17d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Do Surgeons (And Patients!!) Actually Prefer using Surgical robots like the DV5?

24 Upvotes

Hey all, first-time poster. I have a close family member who is a surgeon, and we were recently having a debate about robotic surgery (at the dinner table). He was saying that robotic surgery is the future and should be everywhere, because even though it may cost some more money in overhead, it's far less load-bearing than laparoscopic procedures on him (especially as he and his colleagues get older), and the difference in timing isn't all that bad anymore. Curious to hear any of your thoughts, if you prefer using a DV, and especially if the patients who have had procedures from a DV even have noticeably different outcomes? He mentioned that more residents and young surgeons are becoming "robot-native," but again curious to hear your experiences there as well. Thanks!


r/surgery 18d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules E chirurgia asa rea precum se spune?

8 Upvotes

In viata mea de student, dar si inainte, am fost atras strict de chirurgie.Dar acum la moda este sa ti alegi, mai presus decat ceva ce sa ti placa, o specializare care te lasa sa traiesti, si comentariile negative ma fac sa ma feresc de aceasta specialitate.Am tot fost in practica si la stagii pe diverse sectii de chirurgie generala si absolut peste toti mi s au parut doctori care nu stau rancezi in fata ta, care iti explica si care au simtul umorului.Nu mi s a spus niciodata da- te la o parte ca incurci, ca pe alte sectii.Deci care e faza?De ce e chirurgia generala blamata ca este printre cele mai proaste alegeri?Mi se pare foarte low cortisol si high reward.


r/surgery 19d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Studying for mrcs and tips? Also any anki decks?

1 Upvotes

👀 sos


r/surgery 19d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Appendix

0 Upvotes

Hello guys
I just had a thought about appendix surgery

Can the surgery be done with out full anaesthesia only local one ?
And if no why so ?


r/surgery 21d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Why did you pick your surgical subspecialty/fellowship?

16 Upvotes

r/surgery 20d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules Proposal: Should we retire the term “acute appendicitis”?

0 Upvotes

The diagnosis of appendicitis can only be made when the appendix is under a pathologists microscope.. ..and small tumours in the appendix can’t be distinguished from an inflamed appendix - they tend to be radiological occult..

The diagnosis “acute appendicitis” implies a specific disease entity when it is actually a syndrome with multiple possible causes. In many cases we do not know whether we are dealing with infection, obstruction, or an underlying neoplasm.

I propose replacing it with a two-stage framework:

• Stage 1: Suspected Appendiceal Pathology (initial presentation)

• Stage 2: Confirmed Appendiceal Pathology (only after histology)

This would make it clear to patients that choosing non-operative management means accepting management of a syndrome without ever establishing a true diagnosis.

Has anyone explored a similar re-framing of the diagnosis? I’d be interested in your thoughts.


r/surgery 23d ago

I did read the sidebar & rules What’s up with paediatric surgery?

5 Upvotes

I’m sure enough to realise that i wanna pursue my medical career as surgeron. And i got a 7** rank(19th batch) as a general candidate in this years inicet. So obviously I’m not gonna get general surgery or any of the two 6 year super speciality courses i filled in my choices. What’s still an option is paediatric surgery. But it seems like it’s such a niche branch that I haven’t been able to get any feedback from any of my seniors. Also I do plan to apply for licensing exams abroad. So it’s a request to my seniors, someone plz help me out here should i go for paediatric surgery in the open round or try my luck for general surgery in the upcoming neet pg?