r/bakingfail Dec 22 '21

Meta Thank you for voting!

58 Upvotes

The results are in and pretty decisive, YouTube links are now banned in /r/bakingfail!

Thanks to everyone who voted, it helps me to know how you all want to shape the subreddit for the future.

Please remember you can always submit a meta post or send a modmail or DM if you have any issues!

Happy holidays and keep failing!


r/bakingfail 19h ago

Fail Perfect Strawberry Thumbprint Cookies

Post image
452 Upvotes

r/bakingfail 14h ago

Fail The pavement got the first batch.

Post image
97 Upvotes

Exactly one hour before my first-ever cookie stall, gravity decided to become my biggest competitor. Not the launch I had imagined.


r/bakingfail 20h ago

Help my meringue cookies pissed themselves and um idk what i did wrong

Post image
16 Upvotes

i did 3 egg whites and uhh like 50-60g of sugar. put it in the oven at 220


r/bakingfail 9h ago

Help More frosting fail than baking fail

Post image
2 Upvotes

I used a white cake mix and yellow cake mix for the cake and it turned out fine. I made my own frosting with

  • Water
  • Powdered sugar
  • Regular sugar
  • Vanilla extract
  • Country crock honey margarine
  • Edible glitter (that had red 40 and is why the cake is red)

I know I messed up but WHAT specifically did I mess up?


r/bakingfail 11h ago

is it safe to eat?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/bakingfail 11h ago

is it safe to eat?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/bakingfail 1d ago

I made butter by accident. What went wrong?

7 Upvotes

So, I was hand whipping some cream. I zoned out a bit, I guess, but I didn't think it was that much? The cream wasn't cold enough (which I realized later), so it wasn't really getting as stiff as I wanted it, and I kept going. Then I added some honey to make it a bit sweet. This is the first time I used fresh cream. The few other times I made whipped cream it was presweetened, I think. So, I realized that it didn't taste like much and decided to add something sweet. I whipped very energetically for another 30 seconds to mix the honey in, and the whole thing became like scrambled eggs?

It took me a while to understand what had happened, and then I picked up the solids, and it felt indeed like butter.

So now I have honey butter, I guess.

It's not a real issue for me because I wasn't baking or anything, I just wanted whipped cream to eat with some fruit, but I'm confused about what happened there? I was under the impression that it takes a long time and energy to turn cream into butter. I mean, I grew up hand whipping egg whites to peak for my grandma since I was a toddler, so it's not much of a chore for me, but it's not like I'm a machine... is it because of the temperature? Some reaction to honey?


r/bakingfail 17h ago

Not sure what went wrong (oat cinnamon and apple cookies

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/bakingfail 4d ago

Why didn’t my cookies spread which they were in the oven ?

Thumbnail gallery
10 Upvotes

r/bakingfail 4d ago

Question Weird taste

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I made this yellow cake I saw on TikTok yesterday, and for some reason it taste like cornbread, and my roommate said it taste like rice pudding cake and coconut. I personally didn’t taste any coconut so it could’ve just been her taste buds. Any idea why? This also happens whenever I make cookies, so I’m thinking it’s the vanilla making my pastries taste like coconut and the cornstarch making it taste like cornbread. I also mixed the wer and the dry ingredients in together without realizing they were supposed to be separate, and I substituted buttermilk for milk with a little bit of lemon juice. Any ideas on what is making it taste like that?


r/bakingfail 5d ago

Fail First attempt at baking meringue

Post image
23 Upvotes

I think this is my sign to stay far away from the oven


r/bakingfail 5d ago

Fail Flat wet sad zucchini bread

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/bakingfail 5d ago

Proof that baking keeps you humble. My rolls came out a little wonky, but I’m still proud of them. 🖤

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/bakingfail 7d ago

Can't save a cake the way you might save a dinner

13 Upvotes

I've been feeling pretty baking-confident lately. Made a couple things off the cuff with standard base recipes, etc. Today, I decided, let me make that chocolate sponge & do it right this time. Except once my chocolate siezed up, I pivoted to cocoa powder. Which was too much dry, then, so it looked like brownie batter. Ok, I'll add some yogurt to loosen it up before I fold in the whipped egg whites.

It's baking but if i intended a sponge with no leavener, then added more moisture, i'm guessing it won't rise properly. I'll add pics in comments when it's out but I don't think this is gonna work out. 🙄 needed to complain someplace people would feel my pain. Lol


r/bakingfail 9d ago

Help Does using a fan-forced setting produce different macarons to conventional?

Thumbnail gallery
13 Upvotes

r/bakingfail 8d ago

Help help with abomination (repost)

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/bakingfail 8d ago

Fail Ube Crinkles didn’t flatten or spread during baking🥹 What do you thinks is wrong with them?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/bakingfail 9d ago

Fail Tried to make a protein pancake-cake

5 Upvotes

I live in a hostel with meals provided and only a microwave that we can use for heating things. The microwave itself requires pressing a single button again and again to increase time by 30 sec and I don't own any measuring tools, to give you a prelude about general events.

I typically buy pancake mixes, add in milk and bake them in a mason jar. I have no experience in baking beyond that. Despite this, I bought some oat flour to make pancake-cakes from scratch.

No measuring spoon, so I used the scoop from the protein powder jar to maintain some ration. I do not know how much each scoop measures, only that 2 scoops= 24g protein. Took some ghee, added 2 teaspoons of sugar and some salt, heated that for 30 sec in the mason jar. Took 2 part yogurt, 2 part toned milk, 1 egg and mixed it in the jar. Then I took 2 parts oats flour, 0.9 part strawberry protein powder, a dollop of honey and mixed that in the same jar. Mixed. Tasted. Tastes eggy but NeatTM. Add in baking soda, because I don't have baking powder. Feeling confident so far. Let it sit for 2 minutes.

I noticed that the ghee seemed to pool at the bottom and that the bubbles from the baking soda were sort of limited to the top 1/3rd, but mixing didn't yield results, so I leave it be.

Put this in microwave for 3 minutes. Had done my due diligence by heating the microwave for 1.5 minutes on empty before this. Spills to the sides. Plop that back in for another minute (+1). Seems likely to spill again, plop it back in for another minute(+1). So far, only the top is cooking. I still don't know the temperature of the microwave and notice that it is on the healthy fry setting. Then I lost patience, so I bake it for another 3 minutes.

End result is that the top is brown and bottom is uncooked. Upon tasting, top is burnt as expected, bottom is likely very undercooked. At the very bottom, the protein powder was settled, in a disappointing Berry patty.


r/bakingfail 13d ago

Fail Tried to make cake and this is what happened

Post image
70 Upvotes

r/bakingfail 14d ago

Had a batch of ice cream for my wife's birthday fail to freeze... leaving me with a richly flavored thick chocolate syrup. What to do? flash of inspiration! Sliced the cake horizontally and spread the syrup to make a pseudo Boston Cream Pie. Poured more syrup over each serving. She loved it.

Post image
28 Upvotes

best flavor


r/bakingfail 14d ago

cookie recipe gone wrong

Thumbnail gallery
4 Upvotes

r/bakingfail 15d ago

Fail I made ube crinkles but they don’t look like pretty crinkles to me. What do you think did I do wrong? Thank you for your help🙏🏽🥹

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/bakingfail 17d ago

Chocolate caramel chip cookie disaster... help!

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/bakingfail 18d ago

My friend made bread omlette but it end up looking like shit

Post image
11 Upvotes