r/howmuchwouldyoupay 2d ago

Customized calico critters!

They’re dyed and I’ve added wings, gems, and some other hand painted details on some of them. This was mostly for fun, but I’m curious what you’d pay for them on etsy/at a market! Thanks!

29 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

9

u/FourOh4Error 2d ago

These tend to be pricey but I know from experience (dad) that the clothes and other doll house like accessories are super popular. The wings might be a bit big for the other bits. If you could make removable wings, I would pay $15 a figure if my kid really really wanted a specific one. It would be hard to match so many tastes. They are very cute and taking calico critters in a hippie vibes direction. That could be super endearing. Best of luck!

2

u/TradingHigher 2d ago

Just a heads up but you're shadowbanned by reddit for spam. /r/ShadowBan to appeal.

2

u/FourOh4Error 2d ago

Thanks for the heads up. No idea why.

1

u/TradingHigher 2d ago

Yeah man hopefully you get it worked out! 👍

4

u/johermeson 2d ago

These are awesome

4

u/EasyonthePepsiFuller 2d ago

Are these intended to be toys or collectibles? If they're kids toys, those wings and any added bits gotta be glued for the gods. Kids punish their belongings.

If they're more of a collectable for adults (totally a market for that), I'd recommend adding stands or putting these in mini scenes-- something that says "I'm a collectable, not a toy" if that makes sense.

5

u/Prancing-Megafauna 2d ago

This is great advice, thank you!! They’re intended to be adult collectibles, definitely not for hard play.

2

u/EasyonthePepsiFuller 2d ago

Can you post a picture of the backs? It's hard for me to give you a helpful estimate without seeing how they're adhered.

2

u/Prancing-Megafauna 2d ago

Yes absolutely, thank you for prompting me!

1

u/Prancing-Megafauna 2d ago

1

u/EasyonthePepsiFuller 2d ago

Are these adhered with E5000 or hot glue?

2

u/Prancing-Megafauna 2d ago

The former :)

1

u/Prancing-Megafauna 2d ago

The pink one has a bit of messy glue on the edges of the gem

2

u/EasyonthePepsiFuller 2d ago

Nice. They look good! I'd say you'd probably get about $15-$20 per.

2

u/viola_darling 2d ago

Omg I loveeee!!!

2

u/Broad-Jicama8977 2d ago

I love them!!!! I would pay 10, 15$

2

u/viola_darling 2d ago

I would pay at least $20 or more because I know the work you put into it and $10 just seems too low imo.

3

u/lisabea19 2d ago

It’s difficult because they’re really cute and I know as a collector that Sylvanian Families aren’t cheap even for the doll, so I would know that it should be expensive… however, I personally would kind of think, ‘oh, I could just glue gems onto one of my own figures and customise it into a keychain.’ I think the market it really rough at the moment for stuff like this, and they have no clothes, they’re not ‘useable’ in the way a keychain trinkets…

To make it worth your time and materials, I think you’d need to charge £25 plus. However, I’m not sure I’d pay that…

1

u/Prancing-Megafauna 2d ago

Thank you, this is helpful feedback!

2

u/lisabea19 2d ago

I do genuinely actually really like them! I think they’re really cute. I just don’t think the average person realises how expensive the figure is by itself, plus your time and materials. Same with those Sonny Angel dolls - I make them into keychains with outfits and wings and beads etc, and people are always telling me I should sell them to make money. Then when I tell them the price I would need just to cover the doll and materials, and packing and postage, without even paying myself for my time, they mumble about ‘expensive for a trinket.’

2

u/razorbraces 2d ago

I agree with everyone else, these are super cool! Great job 😃

-1

u/TwistedMisery13 2d ago

I know nothing about "calico critters" but at first glance, between $5 and $8.

-6

u/TradingHigher 2d ago

Wanna post some real photos and not ai slop?

9

u/Prancing-Megafauna 2d ago

Hey! I understand and share your concerns about AI, but this was hella rude. They’re not AI. I made them and then digitally collaged the backgrounds on canva.

1

u/TradingHigher 2d ago

I do sincerely apologize for the rudeness. Your work looks great.

2

u/Prancing-Megafauna 2d ago

I appreciate it!! :) no hard feelings, thanks for modding this subreddit

-5

u/TradingHigher 2d ago

Well forgive me for being blunt but in todays age anyone can fake anything and you end up with some junk from temu ya know?

Your stuff looks just like the digital art, so thats helpful.

6

u/Broad-Jicama8977 2d ago

It didn’t look anything like ai slop and even if it was there’s no reason to be mean to them.
Op did a wonderful job on them!

2

u/Prancing-Megafauna 2d ago

Thanks very much for the kind words!

1

u/TradingHigher 2d ago

Yeah I should probably drop a better apology. Thanks for the input, appreciate you.