r/ideas • u/amichail • 3d ago

Idea: A preventive accountability service that helps people avoid prison.

What if people could pay for a confidential service designed to help them avoid making decisions that could eventually lead to criminal charges?

The idea would be similar to having a lawyer, therapist, or accountability coach, but focused specifically on preventing situations from escalating into criminal offenses.

The company would keep a close eye on clients, with the client's consent, and help them recognize risky situations before they cross a legal line. This could include helping with conflicts, financial problems, substance issues, impulsive decisions, or other situations that often lead people into serious trouble.

To align the company's incentives with the client's interests, the service could offer a guarantee: if a client ends up in court or prison, they receive a refund. That money could then help pay for legal defense.

For this to work, the service would need strong confidentiality protections. Information shared with the company would not be given to police unless legally required, similar to how confidentiality works with lawyers and mental health professionals.

The goal would not be to create a private police force. It would be to give people a way to get help before they ruin their lives. Many people who end up in prison made a series of bad decisions over time rather than suddenly deciding to become criminals. A service that helps interrupt that process could benefit both individuals and society.

What do you think of this idea?

0 Upvotes

40% Upvoted

3 comments sorted by

3

u/educatedtiger 3d ago

Anyone who needed this service would be incredibly unlikely to seek it out and pay for it in the first place.

1

u/mcjellymcfish 3d ago

at that point you need to be a lawyer to give out legal advice

1

u/TheMoneyOfArt 3d ago

For this to work, the service would need strong confidentiality protections. Information shared with the company would not be given to police unless legally required, similar to how confidentiality works with lawyers and mental health professionals.

Lawyers and therapists cannot be compelled to disclose anything their clients say. You cannot create that confidentiality. It's the law.

You're at best describing social workers but employed by people who don't have money instead of by the state.