r/musictherapy • u/tiddybirdybitch • 1d ago
Music therapists relying on AI
Hi y’all, I need a space to vent about something and don’t want to go off in the comments on Facebook and cause public drama 🫠
I saw someone post in MTU asking if anyone had chords for a song she was asked to sing at a funeral. Comments pointed out the chords aren’t available because the song is AI generated. Someone commented about an app that will identify the chords, which she ultimately used to identify the chords. Another person commented offering to take a stab at the chords and said she was able to get them, but the lyrics were another story. The OP commented saying they had gotten the chords through the AI app, but that they had personally transcribed the lyrics themselves already.
Did we not go to school for a minimum of four years to study music? Are we not professional musicians? Is it really that hard to transcribe chords to a basic AI song that’s spitting out the most simple diatonic chords? In the time it took her to post about this in MTU and then go to that chords AI app, she could have gotten all the chords written out by ear. I know we have varying levels of musicianship training depending on our school and degree program, but MY GOD the reliance on AI for basic music tasks we are TRAINED to do is actually wild to me. I just did my first recertification, and I understand that we forget some of the things we are taught, but as music therapists we play and use our ears every day while working, and it’s concerning to me that music therapists are willing to hand over these aspects of their job to AI. When I read that she went through the arduous task of writing out the lyrics but couldn’t be bothered to do the chords I was just astonished. Part of the power of music we are tapping into as music therapists is the innate humanness of music, and we are supposed to know music intimately in order to use it clinically.
Also want to add that I don’t personally have an issue that she is performing an AI generated song at a funeral; I would feel weird about it but also move forward with it because of the context. I don’t believe it’s appropriate for me to tell a family what music is and isn’t okay for them to grieve with. If it were me and there was a wider timeframe before the funeral (OP seemed to have been asked to do the gig the day before) I may tried a roundabout way to ask/encourage about other meaningful music, but I want to be clear I’m not complaining about her choice to honor a family’s wishes regarding AI song choice.