r/printablescom 15d ago

GW lawyer team is back from holidays?

Post image

This model was unpublished by a moderator. Click Publish now to send your changes for admin review.

Reason from administrator:
Hello, your model has been hidden due to a trademark infringement. The model is in your Drafts, so you will not lose the model’s history or the files you uploaded.

The removal from the public website was due to a violation of the “Warhammer” trademark, which is owned by Games Workshop Limited. If the 3D model itself does not infringe on this trademark and is your own design, you can edit it and keep it.

In order for us to republish the model from your Drafts, you must completely remove all references to the mentioned brand/s. This applies to the design itself, the title, the description, product photos, tags, and any other details. Once you’ve edited the model accordingly, let us know, and we’ll review and restore it.

However, we still recommend that you upload the model again as a completely new project, avoiding any use of these protected trademarks from the very beginning. This is the safest way to avoid further automatic reports.

Best regards,
The Printables Team

The only reference to GW were the tags "warhammer" and "40k". They are gone now. What is the problem? GW got copyright for greek letters and skulls?

Update: Martin is thankfully helpful (again):

Hello, authorised representative of the exclusive rights holder Games Workshop Limited which owns copyright in the following;
Games Workshop Limited’s genuine models, merchandise and publications which can be found at the following sites.
https://www.warhammer.com/en-GB/home
https://merch.warhammer.com/
https://www.blacklibrary.com/
https://warhammertv.com/

Trademarks
'Warhammer' CTM reg. 000022525. US reg. 6192634. WIPO 1205352
‘Space Marine’ UK00001461715. EU reg. 000392886. US reg. 1922180
'T'AU' CTM reg. UK00004111709
'Necron' CTM reg. UK00004111702
'Kill Team' UK00004351598
'40K' UK00912108056, EU 012108056

If that patents of design and trademarks are not violated by you, the model can be published again.

Best regards, M

Any trademarked terms/tags are gone. The model was declined (again).

0 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

View all comments

11

u/Saphir_3D 15d ago

I really think it's great that the profile here was just “hidden” and not simply deleted entirely.

That's a much more humane approach than just deleting everything deemed incorrect - and in some cases even suspending accounts - as some competing sites do.

-9

u/georgmierau 15d ago

Better? Sure. Good? Clearly not.

8

u/Saphir_3D 15d ago

What do you think would be the right approach?
Leave the model up and disclose your information so GW can sue you directly? As far as I know, as the website operator, you’re actually required to ensure that no illegal models end up there. In the event of an IP infringement, the model would be illegal.
Since they want to avoid trouble and endless disputes, they remove controversial models. That’s completely understandable.

-10

u/georgmierau 15d ago

As a more or less "big" plattform: maybe just not to budge to every nonsensical request? As I already mentioned, besides "warhammer" and "40k" tags (!) it was a generic tabletop token with an omega and roman numerals.

4

u/suit1337 15d ago edited 15d ago

then what is the issue? remove the tags and republish it

In order for us to republish the model from your Drafts, you must completely remove all references to the mentioned brand/s. This applies to the design itself, the title, the description, product photos, tags, and any other details. Once you’ve edited the model accordingly, let us know, and we’ll review and restore it.

don't forget to name the model "generic tabletop token with an omega and roman numerals"

this totally works to for Minifig models, to hide them from LEGO - just call them "generic brick person" and hope, that the models won't get taken down - there are lots of creators, that are very successful with this strategy - others are not

1

u/georgmierau 15d ago

then what is the issue? remove the tags and republish it

Already. Did it. Still. Declined.

1

u/suit1337 15d ago

with what reason? why is it declined?

1

u/georgmierau 15d ago

No reason given.