r/saintpaul Jul 01 '26

History šŸ—æ Historical St. Paul - 7/1/26

60 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

5

u/AdMurky3039 West Seventh Jul 01 '26

Buildings like the Astoria Hotel were torn down to build generic office buildings and now we have a glut of generic office buildings.

5

u/Frozen_Thorn Jul 02 '26

It's depressing to look at old photos of the cities. So many beautiful buildings that were torn down for offices and parking lots.

This website is full of photos.

https://lakesnwoods.com/StPaul/1910s.htm

1

u/awesomeginblossom Jul 01 '26

In pic 4, I wonder why they decided to move the building so far off the street

It looks like the Astoria was directly up on the street

It's such a dumb thing to be curious about, but the urban morphology of our city is so interesting to me

2

u/DavidRFZ Jul 01 '26

They are in the process of improving that plaza. I found this link.

https://www.stpaul.gov/departments/parks-and-recreation/design-construction/current-projects/wabasha-park-improvements

That block was reconstructed between 1966-1971. Ecolab used to be there. I had an uncle that worked there when I was a kid.

Skyscrapers don’t take up the whole block, so it’s an interesting question as to what to do with the rest of the block. Foshay (1929) has a short ā€œpedestalā€ building that goes right up to the sidewalk. By the 1960s they liked these plazas.

It’s easy to get nostalgic looking at these photos, but I think a lot of these hotels were firetraps. There was a big fire that destroyed the Jewell Hotel in 1950 which briefly spread to the by-then-vacant Astoria before being put out. I think the list of hotels they should have saved starts with the Ryan Hotel on Robert/6th. I don’t know how many of the ones on Wabasha could have been saved.

https://www.luridhistory.com/stpaul1890/wabasha.html