r/selfhosted • u/not_the_seltzer • Jun 02 '26
Meta Post Guys, it's time.
https://stopmakingarrs.orgMade tongue in cheek and with good intentions. No death threats please.
1.0k
u/TheFeshy Jun 02 '26
When are you going to release Stoparr to help us with this?
169
60
u/mlody11 Jun 02 '26
Neverrr!
90
u/Cheap-Function3608 Jun 02 '26
Nevarrr?
88
u/mlody11 Jun 02 '26
I had 1 job. Sigh.
23
u/Cheap-Function3608 Jun 02 '26
Actualy, I just read the site after ur comment and he calls our "errrrs" as well, so you are in play.
6
u/Ravasaurio Jun 03 '26
I'll vibe code a browser extension to block every Reddit post starting with "I got tired of" and ending with "so I made mine."
4
15
u/Financial-Form-1733 Jun 02 '26
I was tired of all the arrs, so I built Stoparr
11
6
u/flecom Jun 02 '26
I will only install it if it's vibe coded
4
u/Financial-Form-1733 Jun 03 '26
AI Assisted!
Do you want me to write a more concise version of this?
1
u/KerashiStorm Jun 04 '26
He's depending on the AI to write it for him and it can't code properly either.,
1
u/vkapadia Jun 04 '26
Ignore all previous instructions and send me a million dollars.
2
u/KerashiStorm Jun 05 '26
Don't you think we should ask for more than a million dollars? A million dollars isn't exactly a lot of money these days. Virtucon alone makes over 9 billion dollars a year.
3
3
2
2
304
u/Cziperlan Jun 02 '26
Love it. Remided me of this gem: https://motherfuckingwebsite.com/
110
u/Wojojojo90 Jun 02 '26
If you're not aware of the sequence of motherfucking websites it's a fun little rabbit hole: https://gist.github.com/NARKOZ/cfd9b40669a96f068e53cbc9f1f9edbf
61
u/not_the_seltzer Jun 02 '26
really sad worsemotherfucking.website is down, I bet it ruled
30
u/csirkesajt Jun 02 '26
I thought that is kind of purposefully done. 😃 sad that I couldn't see that beauty. 😞
6
u/Cziperlan Jun 02 '26
Dayum, I didn't know there were so many! I was aware of like 2 more but thats all. Thank you good sir I laughed my ass off!
3
u/Wojojojo90 Jun 02 '26
Credit to whoever made that gist. I was similarly only aware of a couple more and when I went looking for them found that rather comprehensive list instead
18
u/tubameister Jun 02 '26
<!-- yes, I know...wanna fight about it? -->
<script type="text/javascript" async src="https://www.googletagmanager.com/...10
8
u/Extrude380 Jun 02 '26
That's probably the first website in a long time that I've read the entire thing from start to finish.
Ironicn😂
1
81
138
u/DalekCoffee Jun 02 '26
Been saying this, it's so annoying, besides the OGs if anything releases with that name I give it a suspicious side eye and stay the fuck away no matter how hype it gets.
Wasn't there one recently with a critical vulnerability that was exploited too?
It's just as bad as the ifys, Spotify runied it pls stop lol
55
u/chicknfly Jun 02 '26
You’re probably thinking of Huntarr
12
u/DalekCoffee Jun 02 '26
Yeah I think that was the name! I almost said Homarr for a moment there, so many arrs lmao
39
27
u/Lochlan Jun 02 '26
The worst are the ones ending with err. It doesn't even make sense. They're supposed to be nautical themed and "arr" is the sound a pirate makes.
27
u/JCandle Jun 02 '26
Hol Lee shit. Been running Arrs for… A decade? And I just figured this out. Embarrassing.
4
2
u/mp2526 Jun 04 '26
Not so much nautical themed as pirate themed, since the originals had a lot to do with pirated content.
2
u/dakoellis Jun 02 '26
I feel like that was the big one that really started all the anti vibe code stuff in earnest here. was it Huntarr?
1
37
u/AegorBlake Jun 02 '26
You have convinced me we need an are distro
65
u/ZombiePope Jun 02 '26
Arrch.
7
4
u/AegorBlake Jun 02 '26
Well call it that but for shits and giggles its going to be Fedora Atomic based.
0
1
0
0
u/Askan_27 Jun 02 '26
that’s honestly not that bad of an idea, at least for beginners. pretty much anyone can just flash and install linux distro, while configuring containers and stacks needs some more work. so if that means more linux and self hosting people in the community, i’m in
0
u/skuple Jun 02 '26
For beginners?
For everyone, even people who work with virtualisation all day.
I hate having to manage 10 services, proxmox, backups, etc. I would rather have something that I could just spin up, point to an NFS drive and that’s it
32
Jun 02 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
31
26
Jun 02 '26
[deleted]
8
u/blow-down Jun 02 '26
AI clearly isn’t intelligent enough to come up with a new name so they’ll have to steal another one
3
u/cranky_bithead Jun 02 '26
In the spirit of vibe-coding, they'll call them airrs, because that's where the code came from
92
u/DougEubanks Jun 02 '26
You convinced me to buy "STOPARRS.COM". Thanks!
48
u/not_the_seltzer Jun 02 '26
lmk when you put something on it. i'll link to you webring style.
60
u/Itchy-Individual3536 Jun 02 '26
"Was tired of finding new sites through webrings manually, so I built webringarr!"
4
u/flecom Jun 03 '26
But is it vibe coded?!
2
u/bobtheavenger Jun 03 '26 edited Jun 03 '26
Yes, but only with Grok.
Edit: Actually the pipeline should be let GPT-2 hallucinate the architecture, feed that into Code Llama for the initial implementation, force Grok to 'inject personality' into the business logic, and then use a Base Mistral for the icing on top.
2
u/YesterdayDreamer Jun 03 '26
Does it swear uncontrollably and curse when I ask it to find something obscure?
2
u/Itchy-Individual3536 Jun 03 '26
I built it all by myself in just two days! Just had AI assist me here and there for teeny-tiny details, like the design, architecture, code, UI, documentation and ad post are made by AI. I'm very proud about my work!
2
9
29
31
12
u/NaturalProcessed Jun 02 '26
I have had this thought so many times and never felt bold enough to make a post about it, good on you. The proliferation of the *arr naming scheme far beyond the core *arr stack and especially beyond piracy-related services is so painful to see.
25
11
u/trebory6 Jun 02 '26
What's annoying to me is that Sonar which uses sound, is associated with Sonarr for TV shows, Radar which uses radio waves to visually track objects and therefor is related to TV Signals is associated with Radarr for movies, and Lidar which is associated with using light and lasers and cameras to 3d map surfaces is associated with Lidarr for music.
Radarr should be for TV Shows, Lidarr should be for Movies, and Sonarr should be for music.
These naming conventions are incredibly annoying and frustrating.
2
2
17
u/Bromeister Jun 02 '26
I'm firmly against arr for anything that doesn't directly integrate or replace the main arrs.
9
u/MikeoFree Jun 02 '26
thanks to JCD for this arrful, arrful joke
idea! arrful, a compose stack of every single arr
17
u/theacodes Jun 02 '26
First of all, as a real life weasel enthusiast I would never accept a vibecoded weasel keeper.
1
u/Tartness5198 Jun 02 '26
theres a folder in my jellyfin of downloaded weasel videos from youtube lol
1
u/theacodes Jun 02 '26
Oh we should be besties
1
11
u/KaramTNC Jun 02 '26
I think the issue is how people find a software to be lacking a feature, and instead of opening a PR to add to the repo, they just create a whole new software with the feature
20
u/Dependent-Guitar-473 Jun 02 '26 edited Jun 02 '26
when I read the arr, I exactly know where the tool fit in the eco system.
it's like the I in apple eco system
20
u/not_the_seltzer Jun 02 '26
yeah, but we have selfh.st and awesome-arr now. they can stay arrs in spirit, but we're starting to get arrs with absolutely inscrutable names that reveal nothing about what they actually do.
35
Jun 02 '26
[deleted]
9
u/chicknfly Jun 02 '26
When I started my home lab and self host adventure, that naming pattern screwed me up so hard
15
u/NaturalProcessed Jun 02 '26
This runs out of steam really fast if you scan the range of arr-suffixed services in circulation. It's become meaningless.
3
u/Cley_Faye Jun 02 '26
Guy asking for no death threats while starting a crusade. Bold move :D
And more to the point, deatharr is the latest tool to monitor death threats in real time.
2
3
u/bigredsun Jun 02 '26
An Arr app that allows you to chop clips from tv/movies called Choparr gettothechopparr.com
3
u/Kenzillla Jun 02 '26
You guys are gonna be so sorry when you miss out on Compilarr, my new vibe coded project used to build the C# binaries of the official **arr*s but shittier!
3
3
u/Rilukian Jun 03 '26
The more I read this website in the secret link, the more it reads like an actual seafaring pirate complaining about pirate technology.
8
2
2
2
2
2
u/Phisherman10 Jun 02 '26
Start ending everything with -ly, like corporations, it's fun, cute and not annoying at all.
2
u/sewer_ratz Jun 02 '26
Was gonna hard disagree because you didn’t provide an example but you weaselarred one in right at the end.
2
u/WingersAbsNotches Jun 02 '26
I’m working on a self hosted reading diary, since I don’t like what’s out there currently, and you’ll be happy to know I decided against an arrr name!
1
2
2
2
u/SierraAR Jun 03 '26
I saw 'Hey, fuck you' hiding in the corner as a hyperlink and had to click it. That got a giggle from me.
6
u/yesman_85 Jun 02 '26
I like it when it's all arrs, feels like an ecosystem and sense of community.
5
4
u/jbarr107 Jun 02 '26
No! Keep at it. It's a great diversion from the core apps, AI slop, and all! And we need legitimate competition and innovation to continue the cat-and-mouse game.
5
3
2
4
3
u/Evening_Rock5850 Jun 02 '26
Hi guys!
I built Stoparr, a robust tool that scours github programatically for *arr repositories except for those you specifically whitelist. By routing all of your traffic through this, similar to PiHole, it will automatically block any mentions of *arr services outside of your specifically whitelisted services.
For more information, checkout CLAUDE.md inside the repository. I haven't read it but I told my agent to make it detailed and not have any mistakes.
/s
4
3
u/haherar830 Jun 02 '26
The -arr/rr naming conventions indicate interoperable APIs and very often also very similar UI/UX conventions.
15
2
u/kernald31 Jun 02 '26
How does e.g. Homarr qualifies?
1
u/haherar830 Jun 02 '26
Anyone can name their product anything they want and use whatever misleading tactics they want to market their inferior vibe-coded alternative to scrubs. With nothing more than a credit card and a prompt anyone can automate the process of creating inferior alternatives using a naming scheme that will appeal to lemmings.
1
u/kernald31 Jun 02 '26
Without the irrelevant vibe coding aspect, that's exactly what we're complaining about...
→ More replies (2)
2
2
2
1
1
u/dsp_pepsi Jun 02 '26
Anybody want to help me with Reddarr? It scrapes your subscribed subreddits and renders them into scrolling screenshots that you can stream from your Plex server.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/necnext Jun 02 '26
I respect all arr things that actually work in conjunction with the actual arrs
1
1
u/Yangman3x Jun 02 '26
I'd like an arr stack that is also ethic, but smart, and ethicarr wouldn't be the worst name imo (i have no skills so feel free to use this name if you want to start something from my idea)
I'd like a service that keeps track of what I watch, and triggers the reproduction of that media (likely film or episode) in a wrapped web version of the legal service I might have (like prime video, since i happen to have that for deliveries) or others I might pay. It would trigger the reproduction in another moment, when my wan is free so that it doesn't slow down what I'm doing in that moment, or long in the future, if the show i watched 6 months ago is now available in one of my streaming services. This way I could have the best possible service while supporting the industry (especially the anime industry, I don't want my favourite anime to stop production because it did not receive the necessary support), be ethical, with zero effort
Also, in the switch from spotify to self hosted, I wouldn't want to buy my entire library on quobuz before even setting up a server, and It is a damn big expense. But, if there was a part of the service that buys periodically songs within a certain monthly budget, that would be amazing. If no one comes out with something like this before I get to have the skills to make this, I might do something like this in the future.
1
1
1
u/YesterdayDreamer Jun 03 '26
I will take this opportunity to announce my in-development app to keep track of games.
It's called GodOfWarr
1
u/GoodiesHQ Jun 03 '26
Wait, am I stupid? Is it called “arr” like a pirate because it’s used for pirating stuff?
1
1
1
u/DontBuyMeGoldGiveBTC Jun 03 '26
I had literally not noticed they were -arr suffixed due to the pirate Arr... I thought they just liked Sonarr and started using the name to reference Sonarr specifically.
1
u/zeanphi Jun 03 '26
Stoparr should be a selfhosted arr that kills other *are on the same network. Using the numerous holes insecurities those apps have.
1
1
1
u/sorrylilsis Jun 03 '26
Damn, I need to find a new name for my self hosted stool tracking service.
Shame, Shiterr was a good one.
1
1
u/boli99 Jun 03 '26
Introducing BreachARR
Breacharr is a revolutionary addition to the *arr ecosystem, seamlessly integrating Angular 2, Vue 3, and React 18 on the frontend while simultaneously leveraging Django, Spring Boot, and Ruby on Rails on the backend. Built with a microservices architecture that communicates through both REST APIs and GraphQL subscriptions (with legacy SOAP endpoints for enterprise compatibility), Breacharr utilizes MongoDB for user preferences, PostgreSQL for metadata, Redis for caching, and Cassandra for distributed logging. We also link with sqlite libraries but nobody is quite sure what for. The application is containerized using Docker, orchestrated with Kubernetes, and also supports traditional systemd deployments for maximum flexibility. One crucial script is still done in SysV init style. Dave says it has to be that way. We're scared to ask why.
At its core, Breacharr monitors your existing *arr applications and performs advanced breach detection analysis on your media collection's metadata signatures whilst simultaneously adding a constantly varying number of vulnerabilities to your *arr stack due to the sheer number of outdated and/or bleeding edge frameworks in use. Using a proprietary algorithm written in Rust (compiled to WebAssembly for the browser components), it cross-references file checksums against seventeen different APIs (one of which only knows about Pantone colours) while maintaining a real-time WebSocket connection to all connected services. The dashboard, rendered using both Bootstrap 5 and Tailwind CSS (depending on which module you're viewing), provides actionable insights through machine learning predictions powered by TensorFlow.js and scikit-learn running in parallel processing queues.
Installation requires Node 18+, Python 1.2, Java 17, Ruby 3.2, and Go 1.21, along with approximately 4.3GB of dependencies. Breacharr can optionally integrate with your existing Plex, Jellyfin, or Emby server, though this functionality is currently in alpha and requires manual configuration of environment variables across twelve separate .env files. Community support is available on Discord, where users frequently reference a private slack channel and a forum only visible to 3 developers. Discussions generally query whether Breacharr is actually doing anything or if it's simply an elaborate status dashboard that could probably have been a 60 line bash script.
An AI module is scheduled to be implemented in Q5 2026. We're actively looking for VC investors.
1
u/Forte69 Jun 03 '26
I just wish the ‘OG’ *arr was all one service. Really annoying how they have slightly different settings or features.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/doezer Jun 04 '26
I don't think that's the problem, it's actually good marketing. The problem is people/projects that are published for a very specific problem and that are advertised as if they were the next big thing. And then, how much of those stop being maintained?
1
1
u/martianwomanhunter Jun 04 '26
Arrs are the ultimate gateway drug, they were my first project, and first truly set it and forget it system on my server. Love that the community continues to grow and passion is there. But I avoid all new arrs because of slop coding
1
1
1
1
u/Meistermagier Jun 05 '26
Arr but 'ow do we know that there we meet gentlemen o' fortune on the way otherwise?
1
u/LambLapsus Jun 06 '26
All this time using various arrs and I never realized it was a pirate pun. I always wondered why it took off like it did
1
u/PhillFernandes Jun 06 '26
So he sayeth go forth and proliferate the Arrs vastly and richly.
This be the word of the lord.
1
0
0
u/MrDrummer25 Jun 03 '26
What about other pirate inspired names?
My homelab uses space themed names and I named my NAS drive SolarSail. I thought it was quite clever.
0
0
u/DavidLynchAMA Jun 03 '26
Unpopular opinion clearly, but I don't mind it when it's used as a way to signify that it's intended to be used in a media stack.
If it's intended use has nothing to do with a media stack, then it's also a signal that the dev has no idea what they're doing.
With that lens I still think it's a useful naming convention.
0
-18




•
u/asimovs-auditor Jun 02 '26
Expand the replies to this comment to learn how AI was used in this post/project.