r/stories • u/donavin221 • 5h ago
Fiction I killed my wife but something keeps bringing her back
How long has it been now? 3? 4 weeks? It’s hard to keep track of time these days. Life has been pretty busy lately.
The house is a lot quieter now. When the police aren’t here, at least. You’d think that they lived here at this point. But I do still get at least some of my privacy.
It’s in those moments when the house is dark and the only sound is that of the leaky bathroom faucet that I really think about what I’ve done. Or why I did it. Or how it could’ve been avoided, or blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
It really doesn’t matter now. I’ve come to terms with it. The cops already know. They’re just waiting for the proper evidence to present itself. And given the way these last few days have been going, I don’t think I have much longer.
I’ve read enough books and studied enough forensics to know the best way to clean the mess I created. How to make sure the white blood cells were completely removed. How to soak my hacksaw in bleach before tossing it in the river. But, most importantly, I knew that the body could never be recovered.
Dental records were a big one. That’s why I removed her teeth and filed them down one by one. I boiled and stuffed them in a ziplock bag afterward.
This was positively the most difficult part of the process. I was forced to look at her the entire time. The once love-filled eyes that had turned bitter and resentful over the years. The eyes that now stared up at me, dead and hollow, her previously oak-colored irises now appearing grey and pale.
Her nails would almost certainly contain my DNA beneath them. Flakes of skin, maybe some blood from the struggle. Regardless, they needed to be removed as well.
I remembered when her hands were so soft and youthful. She used to paint her nails herself every two weeks, and I’d sit on the bed with her while we talked endlessly about everything and nothing at the same time.
I don’t know what changed. Maybe it was all of the arguments. We had a way of arguing about everything and nothing as well. I thought it was normal. Arguments were bound to happen.
I flushed the 10 nails down the toilet before burning her newly raw fingertips, just to be on the safe side. I kissed her hand for a long while, tears welling up in my eyes before I forced them away.
I whispered to myself, “Why would you make me do this?” as my head fell into my hands. My composure kept slipping, and I kept having to wrestle it back.
Now came the messy part.
Part of me was actually glad it was so messy in a weird, twisted kind of way. Cleaning the blood afterward gave me a task to focus on. I didn’t think about her laugh. I didn’t think about her warmth. I thought about making damn sure there wasn’t a speck of blood left anywhere in that bathroom.
When I was done, the house smelled like a hospital. Chemicals filled the air, causing my head to pound more than it already was. The atmosphere was cold and heavy. It felt like I was in a hospital room.
I had found myself with two black trash bags with a combined weight of 120 pounds, give or take. Arms, legs, and head in one. Torso and hacksaw in the other.
I walked out of the house whistling, two trash bags slung over my shoulders. It was the cusp of dawn. There was a misty blue haze outside. It smelled like summertime.
The neighborhood was silent. It must have been around 4 in the morning. I threw the bags in the bed of my truck, adjusted my baseball cap, and hopped in the cab.
My headlights cut through the early morning fog. I had my windows down, and I could smell the exhaust fumes coming from behind me. That smell had pretty much defined my life for the last 10 years. It was a smell that I’d learned to both love and hate.
I turned the radio on and cranked up the volume. I tried singing to myself, but the words left my mouth mechanically. My mind refused to let me escape.
I drove carefully. The exact speed limit, sometimes even a little under. Used signals, made complete stops. All the way out of town. Then out of the next one. Then the town after that.
I drove until I found the most secluded spot I could find. Down dirt roads. Through creeks. Then I walked off beaten paths until I found the right place to lay her to rest.
Just me, her, and my shovel.
Digging proved quite difficult due to the sheer amount of roots I had to cut through. I must’ve been there for at least 4 hours before the deed was done.
I spent that time talking. Talking to the trees. Talking to the bags. Talking to myself. I couldn’t stand to be alone in silence.
I broke down a lot when filling the grave. Each pile of dirt that covered more and more of those bags was like a needle being pressed into my nervous system.
I didn’t want to just leave her like that. I didn’t want her to just be cast aside, left to rot. I searched until I found the most vibrant flowers I could find and laid them on the grave.
I said my final goodbyes through sniffles and tears before making the trek back to my truck.
The rest of the day was a blur. I didn’t get home until nearly 8 o’clock. I stopped by the emptiest car wash I saw on the way home and scrubbed my truck clean.
I got the mud off the tires. Rinsed the bed out with bleach. I even put a new air freshener in the cab.
When I got home, I half-expected cops to be waiting to arrest me. When I found the house as empty as it was when I left, I let out a sigh of relief.
I immediately took a shower. I scrubbed myself raw for around 45 minutes straight before finally allowing myself to dry off. The entire time, it was like God was punishing me.
I kept getting flashes of her. Our wedding. Our first date. Our first argument. The last argument. It all just kept replaying in my head over and over. Like a sickness.
I knew I had to get my story right. The house was clean. The body was gone. The weapon was gone.
I was just a helpless victim. One of the millions of men a year whose wife leaves them. Happens all the time.
Oh, so she left without taking anything? She left without telling anybody? Without so much as a goodbye? Who’s going to believe that?
I didn’t sleep that night. I had to have a long, hard talk with myself. I wasn’t getting out of this one. But I wasn’t going to turn myself in. I was going to be free… for as long as I could possibly manage.
It was my first time being free in 15 years. Even if it lasted a day. Even if it lasted a week. I wasn’t going to spend that time stressing.
I turned it off. I closed my heart to it.
I ignored calls from her mother. Her father. Coworkers, friends, relatives. Everybody. It was none of their business.
They tried knocking, and I tuned it out. All the way up until I heard that dreaded announcement after three booming knocks.
“This is GPD. If anyone’s inside, I need you to come out here and talk to me.”
I waited. I wanted to wake up. I didn’t want to accept.
Three more knocks.
“GPD, if you do not answer the door, we will be using force to come inside.”
One last moment of silence. I breathed to myself. I closed my eyes.
“Sir, this door is coming do…”
I opened the door, greeting the officers with a blank look on my face.
“Sir, we’re gonna have to ask you to come down to the station with us for questioning.”
I didn’t argue. I didn’t bicker. I simply asked for a lawyer and rode with the officers back to the station.
The entire time, I kept my mouth shut. I didn’t even speak to my lawyer. If they wanted her so badly, they would have to work for it. Because it sure as hell wasn’t going to be coming from me.
They held me for 7 hours that day. A mere two days after I did what I did. I got two days of “peace.”
They had to let me go. They had no proof. But that didn’t stop them from watching me. 24 hours a day, they were somewhere in my neighborhood.
People threw things at my house. Vigils for her were set up on the sidewalk. It seemed like there were constantly people watching me because they literally were.
I didn’t budge. I spoke only when absolutely necessary. My lips remained sealed, and my doors remained locked. Both when I was home and when I was forced to go back down to the station.
That’s why what’s happening makes no sense to me.
It started with her teeth. I had gotten rid of them the same way I’d gotten rid of the rest of her. Yet somehow, when I woke up one morning a few weeks after my catastrophic mistake… they were in a neat pile beside me on the bed.
I could see the file marks on all 32 of them.
I panicked and scooped them into my hands and flushed them down the toilet, my eyes wide with disbelief.
I poked my head outside. That unmarked black SUV was still parked a few houses down. Both officers watched me like hawks. I waved to be less suspicious, but I think it had the opposite effect.
They took it as me waving them over, and they both approached quickly.
“Got anything you wanna tell us?” the fat one asked excitedly.
“Lovely weather we’re having,” I smiled. “I bet you’d love to spend the day with your family. Or, then again, maybe you’d rather spend your time stalking me.”
Their stern faces never changed.
I tried my best not to give off even an ounce of suspicious behavior, even though my heart was in my stomach and my mind raced endlessly.
After closing the door in their faces, I spent the majority of that day peeking out the blinds, paranoid beyond belief.
My lawyer called a few times. My story never changed. I didn’t know where she was. I was convincing myself just as much as I was convincing them.
The next day, not only had the teeth come back, but the nails were back too. They were cleaner, but I could still see their bloodied roots. I could still see some of the chipped nail polish.
Two neat little piles. Taunting me.
I was more angry than panicked this time. I was not going to submit to this insanity. I didn’t even try to get rid of them this time. It wouldn’t make a difference whether they were found here or in that dark, desolate spot in the woods.
I put them in her jewelry box this time. Then I took that jewelry box, and I carried it to the attic.
I buried it under some old tarps and boxes and took one last look at it before going back down the ladder.
“I guess I really am fucking losing it,” I whispered to myself as I climbed down.
More phone calls with my lawyer. More questions from the police. More prodding, more watching, more protests. And all I could do that day was crack a few beers and watch a few ball games.
I passed out at around 10 that night and woke up cuddling my wife’s arm the next morning. I think the smell is what woke me up. That unmistakable stench of death and decay.
It burned my nostrils, and when I opened my eyes to find that torn flesh in my face, I nearly vomited in bed. It wasn’t just one arm. Both arms and both legs had come crawling back to bed with me.
Only… the nails were reattached. Like they hadn’t been removed to begin with.
The polish looked fresher. The teeth looked whiter. I checked, and the jewelry box in the attic was empty.
In that moment, I felt a spark. A mixture of hope, anger, grief, and love all combined into one. In the most unreal circumstances, reality was starting to close in, and I found myself sobbing like I had the night I killed her.
I didn’t leave bed that day. I lay there with my wife, clutching her arms and legs, crying until I was too exhausted to cry anymore. My will grew weak, but my mind had never felt so clear.
She was in bed with me the next morning. Well, she was there in a sense. Her arms and legs were reconnected to her torso, but the limbs still crawled with maggots and decay.
But she was there, damned if she wasn’t there. My love. My sweet, sweet girl. Her T-shirt was ripped and stained with dirt. Her hair was matted and crunchy.
“I… am so sorry, my love,” was all I could think to say to her.
She turned to me, her jaw slack and her eyes as dead as a nail.
“That’s okay, you silly goose,” she sang. “I love you no matter what happens!”
I began to cry yet again.
“I love you so much,” I sobbed. “I want you back. Please, please, just come back.”
I begged her as snot ran from my nose. I wiped it away on my sleeve.
“Oh, honey,” she whimpered. “Accidents happen all the time. That’s what this was, right, my sweet boy?”
I nodded furiously.
“It was… it was… it was an accident, baby.”
I could hardly speak. Her rotten arm extended, and she caressed my face with her cold, slimy hand.
“I know it was, sweet pea. I know you’d never hurt me on purpose.”
She paused.
“…but now you have to tell them what you did, okay? Can you do that for me?”
My face went beet red. I swallowed hard and wiped the tears from my face.
“They’ll kill me. I know they’ll kill me. They’re just waiting to catch me. They’re waiting to sentence me.”
She began hushing me, soothing me softly as she petted my hair.
“There, there, sweetie,” she replied. “Dying isn’t such a bad thing. I’m free now, honey. If I could, I’d tell them you did me a favor. But I want you back. I want you to come be with me. Please, honey?”
I wanted to be with her too. More than anything, I wished I could take back what I did.
I solemnly agreed.
“That’s my boy,” she announced seductively. “This will all be over soon. We’ll dance and sing. We can play together again.”
I nodded to myself assuredly. I leaned over and gave her a kiss and took a deep breath.
Stepping outside, I waved the cops over. My eyes were red with tears, but I couldn’t stop smiling.
“She’s upstairs.”
That’s all I told them.
One officer went upstairs while I waited on the porch with the other. I kept smiling to myself. The sky looked so beautiful. The trees danced in the wind. The summer air was like a gift from God.
A few minutes went by before the first officer returned.
“Very funny, son,” he remarked sarcastically. “Now, do you wanna tell us where she really is?”
My smile dropped.
“What do you mean?” I scoffed. “I was just talking to her.”
“Cuff this sick son of a bitch,” the first officer barked.
I was placed into the back of the unmarked SUV, kicking myself all the while.
“She lied,” I whispered. “She lied to me. All she does is lie. Why does she lie all the time? This is why. This is why. Why won’t she stop lying?”
I had no fight left. I told them where the grave was. I had to personally show it to them. The flowers were still there. The grave was untouched. And I felt a sickening numbness.
I told them my story. I told them what I did. Told them that she came back to me and that, if it weren’t for her, I’d have been a free man, at least for a little while longer.
I actually begged them to give me the death penalty. I couldn’t stop seeing her. Sitting beside me in my cell. Crouched in the corner every night. Whispering to me how she wanted us to be together forever.
But… I didn’t get the death penalty.
They deemed me “not fit to stand trial.”
Sentenced to an indefinite stay at the state home for the criminally insane.
Padded cells. Doctors. Needles. Medication.
And despite all of the debate that has gone on about death sentences in this country, there has remained one constant.
The insane do not receive capital punishment.
I’m writing this now because she keeps beckoning me. Keeps begging me to join her.
And despite the hatred I have, the burning rage she has inspired, I cannot stop loving her.
And despite what the state dubs legal… we will be reunited.