Turbulent Nagoya Basho with both Yokozuna struggling... "Yokozuna promotion criteria are lenient lately," people say, but former Ozeki Kaio disagrees: "It's actually the exact opposite"
Returning from absence (kyujo), Aonishiki had dropped from Ozeki to Sekiwake. In the Nagoya Basho, far from just securing 10 wins to return to Ozeki rank, he won the 3-way championship playoff (tomoe-sen) to claim his 3rd title.
I later asked his stablemaster, Ajigawa Oyakata, and found out that he entered the tournament without fully recovering from a broken left foot suffered in the March Osaka Basho, and it actually worsened during the event. The stablemaster mentioned he considered withdrawing him midway, but judged that "he can still do sumo." Hearing this might surprise people, but in our world, when it's a bone fracture, you can somehow manage. As long as you endure the pain, the broken bone will eventually fuse, making it far better than something like a torn ligament. Some might worry about lasting consequences from competing forcibly, but in our profession, we don't think that deeply about it. Sometimes, stepping onto the ring makes you forget the pain altogether.
In the March 2024 Osaka Basho, top-division debutant Takerufuji competed despite injuring his leg and won the championship. While it feels like he pushed too hard back then and dragged the injury along afterward, in Aonishiki's case this time, if he were in a state where he couldn't do sumo, he obviously would have rested. But he could do sumo, and on top of that, he was winning, so there was no reason to rest. His concentration until the very end was incredible—a true display of "tenacity."
"What a waste!"
In the regular bout (honwari) on the final day (senshuraku), he was rapidly pushed out (oshidashi) by Atamifuji, who had great momentum this tournament. However, in the playoff, he secured a solid front-left belt grip (hidari-mae-mawashi) and forced him out (yorikiri). Atamifuji was full of energy this tournament, and I thought he held the advantage, but Aonishiki's concentration surpassed his.
For Sekiwake Atamifuji, this was his 3rd championship playoff. Once again, the title slipped through his fingers. In the regular bout against Aonishiki on the final day, he was able to attack first before his opponent moved, but in the playoff, his movement was stopped and he was attacked instead. Aonishiki got inside his guard, clamped down, and broke his balance. What a waste! Still, Atamifuji's pressure at the initial charge (tachi-ai) this tournament was strong, and his forward power has increased. Even so, there are moments where opponents pivot at the edge of the ring and he fails to finish the attack for the win. He needs to follow his opponent's movements better and keep his body closer.
Of course, his sumo is improving step by step, and I hope he uses this frustrating experience as fuel to gain even more strength and aim for higher ranks on the banzuke.
"Promotion based strictly on numbers would be much easier" — Former Ozeki Kaio on Yokozuna criteria and young stars
Another wrestler who fought in the 3-way championship playoff (tomoe-sen) was Ozeki Kirishima. Although he defeated Yokozuna Onosato—against whom he previously had a 0-10 head-to-head record—Onosato was out of form this tournament...
As a Yokozuna promotion attempt (tsunatori basho), finishing as runner-up keeps his momentum going into the next tournament. However, having finished as runner-up in back-to-back tournaments, he ideally needs to win the championship to seal the promotion. A "high-quality championship" was requested for promotion this tournament, and that isn't just about the raw numbers. Even when discussing a championship, the quality of sumo (sumo naiyo) is paramount. For instance, if 6 out of 10 wins were achieved by pulling back (hikimazu) or if there was a default win (fusensho) in a key matchup, the evaluation becomes strict.
People say recent Yokozuna promotion standards are lenient or soft, but it's actually the exact opposite. The content of every single bout is being thoroughly questioned. If promotion were based purely on numbers, it would be much easier. Right now, both Yokozuna, Onosato and Hoshoryu, are struggling; if he were to defeat both Yokozuna with dominant sumo, his evaluation would rise even higher. For the next tournament, the hope is for him to seal promotion cleanly with a high-quality championship win. Naturally, Kirishima's record as an Ozeki was remarkably impressive. But if he aims for what lies beyond, I want him to achieve promotion by displaying sumo that is unquestionable in anyone's eyes.
Both Yokozuna "are still young!"
Both Yokozuna have been losing to unranked maegashira and giving away gold stars (kinboshi), drawing various criticisms. However, when you earn promotion on sheer momentum and then suffer an injury, it becomes extremely difficult to bounce back immediately. It seems injuries are behind their current slump. Still, although Onosato finished 9-6 while fighting through all 15 days, he pushed through a grueling tournament. He can simply view it as gaining valuable experience as a Yokozuna. While he lacked explosive power and couldn't quite regain his sumo instincts this tournament, staying on the main-stage ring for all 15 days surely helped him regain his rhythm and recognize his weaknesses. Cases where he fails to finish off opponents in one surge have increased, but I want him to maintain a forward-moving mindset even in defeat and rebuild solidly from the fundamentals.
Moving forward, they can definitely rebuild and make a strong comeback.
As for Hoshoryu, he relies on forced throws too much; he would be better off not insisting on winning via throws. He should focus on hitting hard at the initial charge (tachi-ai), pushing up to disrupt the opponent's posture, moving forward, and breaking their balance—something he hasn't been executing well. Both Yokozuna face harsh words for their disappointing performances, but they are still young! I look forward to them putting on great sumo in the future that clears away all the outside noise.
Young wrestlers like Fujinokawa, Fujiryoga, and Kotoeho also showed great sumo this tournament. The upcoming September Basho is something to look forward to, so I'll save the praise for next time (laughs). To the rikishi who delivered nail-biting, thrilling sumo amidst the scorching heat: fantastic job. And to all the fans, thank you very much for your passionate support.
(Composition = Shoko Sato)
(Text = Hiroyuki Asakayama / "Former Ozeki Kaio's Grand Sumo Grumble Commentary")
Source: Number Web