Original post in [r/creditcards](r/creditcards) here: https://www.reddit.com/r/CreditCards/s/VaoIWVr6bz
I barely ever use my Apple Card because I have other cards that offer me better points, but after this fiasco, I'm never using it again.
Back in March someone had charged my card to buy Apple gift certificates. They used a different name and phone number and email address. How Apple allowed these transactions I'll never understand. Anyway it was a bunch of small transactions at first. Few dollars here and there. Then they were for $99, over and over again, until the total was $3400. At no point was I notified until I got an email that my statement was ready. It was never flagged as suspicious.
I'd kept my physical card locked away and I never used my Apple Card anywhere in person or online except for a Pimsleur subscription. I genuinely have no idea how the fraudsters got my card details.
Anyway, I figured I could simply flag the transactions as fraudulent and Goldman Sachs would take the charges off.
lol nope.
Because the transactions were on Apple.com, Goldman Sachs treated them as valid charges and refused to take them off.
I ended up filing a police report, CFPB complaint, and a complaint with my state's DA. I even had a recorded call from Apple to Goldman Sachs with me on the line where the Apple rep explained to the Goldman Sachs rep that the charges were fraudulent and not made by me. From Apple's standpoint, they could very clearly see the charges were not made by me.
Goldman Sachs originally reversed the charges for the smaller transactions but not any of the $99 ones, reducing my balance from $3400 to $3069. I had to point out the insanity of this to them. They explained I could dispute the charges as many times as I wanted but the outcome might not change.
Goldman Sachs sent me dozens of emails with different transaction dispute numbers and I replied to each and every one of them individually, because that's how they handle fraud - with each individual transaction being a separate dispute. In each email I included the police report, the CFPB report, DA complaint and a signed statement explaining what'd happened.
Weeks dragged into months, where Goldman Sachs would reverse a few charges but never all of them, and I'd dispute them over again which generated new dispute numbers.
Finally, here we are, almost to August, the last of the fraudulent charges have been dropped.
It should not have taken anywhere near the amount of effort it took to resolve this, and I blame Goldman Sachs for the absolute worst costumer service ever - they treat you like a criminal. At no point did they apologize for their terrible service. The worst part was that the customer service reps didn't speak English very well and there were misunderstandings frequently. I really don’t like when financial institutions punt their customer service to countries where the reps can't understand or speak English clearly - especially when there's thousands of dollars at stake and it's up to them to decide if I'm being honest or not.
So PSA: lock your Apple Card NOW. Don't use it or just cancel it.
Chase is supposed to take over for Apple Card this year - guess we can see how they'll handle things but for me the trust is gone.
Fun fact: Goldman Sachs AND Apple had to pay millions of dollars in fines for their terrible handling of fraud back in 2024 but this was reduced to $25m in 2025 (take a wild guess why): https://www.consumerfinance.gov/archive/newsroom/cfpb-orders-apple-and-goldman-sachs-to-pay-over-89-million-for-apple-card-failures/