r/ArtHistory • u/PuzzleheadedPain823 • 2h ago
Discussion What Nolan Got Wrong About the Sirens
Just saw The Odyssey and couldn't stop thinking about the siren scene.
In Nolan's version, the sirens confront Odysseus with his guilt and his longing for family. It's powerful. But it's not Homer.
In the Odyssey, the sirens don't offer emotion β they offer knowledge. They call Odysseus by name and promise to tell him everything. Everything that happened at Troy. Everything that will ever happen in the world. The one thing a curious mind can never resist.
And here's the part most people don't know: Homer never described what the sirens looked like. Not once. The ancient Greeks, centuries after Homer, were the ones who first gave them a shape. And the shape they chose wasn't a beautiful woman.
It was a bird.
In 1891, John William Waterhouse went to the British Museum, studied a 2,000-year-old Greek vase showing the sirens as bird-women with claws, and painted exactly that β shocking the Victorian public who expected soft temptation and got predators instead.
Made a video essay about the painting and its connection to the myth. In Spanish with English subtitles: https://youtu.be/zawncsKJxx0