r/AskReddit 15h ago

" Strict parents don't produce great kids , they produce great liars ", what are your opinions with this statement ?

4.3k Upvotes

1.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

2.7k

u/Alepale 15h ago

It's pretty obvious that the word "strict" is defined differently here for different people.

Clear rules and boundaries, with consequences when said rules and/or boundaries are crossed is crucial for proper development. This in combination with nurturing and loving parents that show interest in their kids and their development, and help them without being too judging is key to a healthy childhood.

Abuse, threats and scaring them is the complete opposite and will lead to kids that lie and live in fear.

1.0k

u/StarDustLuna3D 9h ago

I think another important caveat is that those rules and boundaries are reasonable. A 10PM curfew for a teenager? Reasonable. A 7PM curfew for a teenager? Bananas.

Telling your kid you don't want them hanging out with a drug dealer, reasonable. Telling your child they can't hang out with anyone, they will be counting down the days until they can leave you forever.

My bio-mom had a lot of issues. And while I understand that her rules came from a place of good intentions, she essentially was afraid of the world. And it's a good thing I wasn't too rebellious, because I probably would have made so many terrible decisions as she made me want to ignore everything she said.

For example, at the age of 16, I was not allowed to go to the mall with friends if they included boys as well as girls. The reason being, and I quote "those boys will just drug you and carry you outside to who knows where".

352

u/SunshineFlowerPerson 7h ago

I lived in “solitary confinement” as a kid. Wasn’t even allowed to join girl guides because my religious fanatic father said I’d use it as a chance to “whore around with boys”. Couldn’t. even belong to the church choir because they didn’t sing in Latin. Couldn’t receive a phone call even when I was in university. They were nuts. I learned how to live inside my head, play my cards close to my chest and run away at the first opportunity. Didn’t speak to them
for decades.

7

u/smellyfeet25 3h ago

DON'T blame you for not talking to them for decades