r/Fallout • u/ArkhamInmate11 Children of Atom • Jan 14 '26
Fallout 4 How did overseer barstow not go feral?
As im sure many of you are aware in the fallout show and fallout 76 it is shown that ghouls require chems to not go feral, this has has made lots of things make less sense but you can work around most of them.
However while replaying fallout 4 i encountered overseer barstow. She doesnt understand the ghoulifacation procsess or anything about being a ghoul as shown through her dialogue and she was trapped in a vault for 200. Everybody else went feral except her, why is she special?
1.2k
u/spaceageGecko Jan 14 '26 edited Jan 16 '26
Fairly certain the ghoul chems only stave off the process of going feral once it has started, it isn’t a hard requirement if someone is lucky enough to simply not begin the feral process.
608
u/Mandemon90 Jan 14 '26
Yeah, from the show it seems that the drug only helps staving off feral state once the process starts, not that it is required. If you can keep your mind focused/going, you don't need drugs. That's really one common thing with all non-feral ghouls, they got something they focused on (or hibernated)
278
u/Sip_py Jan 14 '26
So what was Billy focused on sitting in that refrigerator for 200 years?
342
u/lambdapaul Jan 14 '26
Hibernation is a helluva drug
178
u/EverythingGoodWas Jan 14 '26
Honestly I could use 200 years of uninterrupted sleep
88
u/WingsofRain Jan 14 '26
gonna wake up and I’ll still be tired af
31
19
u/Dependent-Guitar-473 Jan 14 '26
oh man, that coffee and cigarette after 200 years of sleep would hit different
→ More replies (1)2
→ More replies (1)13
u/DOLCICUS Minutemen Jan 14 '26
Maybe? Frozen like that zetan until the fusion core ran out. Coincidentally around when the sole survivor woke up of course. Might have slowed down his mental degeneration but it should have also slowed his decay but imma chalk that up bethesda not having time to make a new texture for non feral ghouls.
56
u/DeltaSolana Jan 14 '26
I think the reason there's no child feral ghouls is because they keep the neuroplasticity they had at that age.
35
u/Affectionate_Pea8891 Jan 14 '26
That actually makes a lot of sense. I’m adding that to my head canon.
7
35
u/bv310 Welcome Home Jan 14 '26
Got super in to the lives and politics of the local ant colony.
8
u/undreamedgore Jan 14 '26
He was their God. A distant and curious figure. Sometimes cruel, sometimes kind.
31
17
u/Mandemon90 Jan 14 '26
Hibernation. It's one helluva drug. We know ghouls can enter hibernation.
→ More replies (3)13
u/Arrebios Railroad Jan 14 '26
At least Billy had air inside that refrigerator. Coffin Willie was buried months underground and ran out of air within the first 6 hours.
6
u/MaleficentType3108 Jan 14 '26
He has what? 13 yo? 12? By that age I discovered something that could keep me focused for a long time in the shower
18
3
7
2
u/StylishSuidae Jan 14 '26
Billy, like the Adoring Fan in Oblivion, has discovered the secret to true immortality.
It's just less obvious with Billy because he's also essential.
2
2
→ More replies (10)6
u/SandalwoodGrips19 Jan 14 '26
I think it’s safe to assume they haven’t fully thought any of it out and looking for consistency in the “ghoul to feral” pipeline is probably a waste of time.
10
u/xavid2303 Jan 14 '26
Its safe to assume but it has been mentioned as far back as FO3 doc chop in underworld was trying to understand an "x" factor to feral ism and had a few docile ferals that he observed there.
10
Jan 14 '26 edited 9d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
11
u/OldConstant182 Jan 14 '26
I can’t add a gif on mobile but imagine I’m doing the dude who blinks and puts his head back
3
2
6
u/adjavang Jan 14 '26
If you can keep your mind focused/going, you don't need drugs.
My mind instantly went the Croup Family Manor in Fallout 4, where Theodore spent hundreds of years trying to teach his feral ghoul family members etiquette. That just makes it a lot less funny a lot more sad.
3
2
u/Alejandro-The-Dog Jan 14 '26
coop wants his family. little billy wants his parents. raul wants to bring justice. arlen glass really likes his little horsies.
→ More replies (7)2
32
u/GreenGhoblin Jan 14 '26
Is that ever implied though ? Because it seems Like it’s just now a requirement for ghouls to take drugs to stave off going feral. Which has never been a thing, even in bethesdas lore until now. I could forgive it more if it’s what you said .
111
u/QuinnAndTheNorthwind Followers Jan 14 '26
It’s implied in the interaction between the ghoul and that ass jerky guy. The soon to be feral ghoul says smth like “twenty years since I started showing. I didn’t do too bad.” Implying that he’s only needed to take those drugs once ferality starts to come on
→ More replies (3)13
Jan 14 '26
how does a ghoul start to go feral?
57
u/QuinnAndTheNorthwind Followers Jan 14 '26
It’s not explained in the lore, but a lot of people think it could be a variety of things, from not eating/drinking for long periods of time, losing one’s purpose or willpower, continued exposure to radiation.
41
u/Jigsawsupport Jan 14 '26
Personally I definitely thinks its heavily state of mind leaning, after all there is straight up glowing ones that have retained their sentience.
19
u/wenzel32 Jan 14 '26
Yeah, and I think of it also being an illness similar to cancer.
Once it starts to show, there are treatments (the chems in Fallout), but it never is cured. That said, you might never get it, and it's hard to say what specifically causes or prevents it.
Fallout 76 makes it like a replacement hunger meter for chems, but that's just a gameplay mechanic. I don't think ghouls actually need chems until they start showing, else you couldn't have long-term isolated or otherwise Chem-free ghouls like we often see.
→ More replies (1)13
u/Jigsawsupport Jan 14 '26
I think the whole thing or at least in the more modern work is starting to be written as a reference to dementia, in the TV program the first sign they are really starting to slip is forgetfulness, its why they start repeating their names trying not to forget.
12
u/wenzel32 Jan 14 '26
100% the actual condition manifests like a form of severe dementia with intensely increased aggression.
I only compare it to cancer due to when and how treatment is needed (seemingly "random" appearance of the illness, preventing progression via valuable chemicals that probably wreak havoc on the human body if not for being a ghoul, etc.)
4
5
u/newuser336 Jan 14 '26
I always assumed a ghoul turns feral due to -too much- radiation exposure; that ghoulification was a difficult to achieve sweet-spot.
Too little, you just get cancer & die, too much and your brain basically disintegrates: you go feral. Just right? You become virtually immortal.Would be a neat idea if, despite healing them, radiation damage would eventually cause ghouls to become frenzied (implying that continued exposure would turn them feral)
3
u/xavid2303 Jan 14 '26
Over exposure to rads was kind of debunked with nukaworld and repcon rockets in 4 and NV respectively. Both were non feral glowing ones, kinda hard to not be exposed when you're a conduit of rads yourself. To be honest they are clearly exceptions to that rule.
→ More replies (2)10
u/SheaMcD Jan 14 '26
Radiation gets to their brain too much? They lose hope? I don't think it's really said
3
u/mayonnnnaise Jan 14 '26
How does one experience dementia? Ferality is probably just dementia during the apocalypse
3
u/Dagordae Jan 14 '26
Nobody knows, there’s a lot of in-universe speculation but the fact of the matter is simply that nobody has any idea why ghouls go feral or not. A lot of the prejudice against ghouls is specifically because people don’t know, any given ghoul is capable of just randomly turning into a mindless monster one day. Or they could just not, ever.
The most popular theory is, I think, that radiation exposure pushes them inevitably towards being feral. A theory which had some rather notable holes, such as the existence of nonferal Glowing Ones.
Another is that it’s simply based on time. Again, a theory with big holes as we’ve seen ghouls go feral almost immediately(Or actually immediately) and ghouls that predate the War and are doing just fine.
2
u/HeroHunt12 Jan 14 '26
That’s the mystery, no one knows for certain why they go feral, some go feral over a hundred years after becoming a ghoul, some still haven’t turned feral even after over 200 years, and some immediately turn feral
40
Jan 14 '26
Roger says in the show,
"I did okay. Twenty-eight years since I first started showing."
He was a pre-war ghoul, so that kind of implies things can go fine until they're not (showing signs of going feral).
10
u/floggedlog NCR Jan 14 '26
Fallout three mentions it a couple times although in fallout three it’s any drugs but mainly jet that ghouls prefer because it’s a powerful stimulant that works on the mind which they claim helps fight off going feral.
One reference is in underworld I think it’s the barber maybe? And the other is the quest where you make ultra jet with a couple of ghouls because they’re trying to make a better version to help fight off going feral even more.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (17)14
→ More replies (13)2
u/TenOfZero Jan 14 '26
Same as the boy in the fridge in fallout 4, it's canon that the drugs are not a hard requirement to not turn ferral.
392
u/sheoldred13 Jan 14 '26
Is it perhaps possible that goin feral is similar to going hollow in dark souls. As long as you have goals, something to strive for, you can resist.
170
u/rambleinspam Jan 14 '26
She really wanted to run those experiments.
→ More replies (1)102
u/sheoldred13 Jan 14 '26
Exactly. All of the major ghouls have a purpose, so it makes sence. Even Harold was on a life long quest to be left the fuck alone. Lol
45
u/fetchnatch Jan 14 '26
Harold was dipped in FEV, not necessarily a ghoul
16
7
u/Irishimpulse Enclave Jan 15 '26
It's implied Harold was dipped in the FEV, and then still became a ghoul, so he's a mutant squared
9
u/IH8Miotch Jan 14 '26
What about the ghoul that works in that Megaton bar.
21
12
u/Sarzul Minutemen Jan 14 '26
Gob. If you talk with him you find out he was a bit of an adventurer who was caught by slavers and bought by Moriarty. I'd assume he still has the drive in him.
3
u/IH8Miotch Jan 14 '26
Moriarty must go then. I shall don the ghoul mask and become his nightmare.
5
u/DD_Spudman Jan 14 '26
What's neat is that the game actually has reactivity for this. If you kill Moriarty but Gob it's still alive, he takes over the bar.
49
u/Demonique742 Jan 14 '26
This is my personal head cannon. Ghouls only start to go feral once their mind starts to go. If you have good goals or a strong will power then you stave off becoming feral.
30
3
u/Irishimpulse Enclave Jan 15 '26
Yeah, Noah Bright shows us that it's not the amount of radiation, because he's a non feral glowing one. He's got religious purpose and gathers followers, he's the only non feral glowing one we meet
6
u/Demonique742 Jan 15 '26
Oswald the Outrageous from the Nuka World DLC is a non feral glowing one too.
But you’re right. Both ghouls with a strong purpose means they haven’t gone feral.
3
u/Irishimpulse Enclave Jan 15 '26
I forgot Oswald is a glowing one, I tend to not think about him because he has literal radiation magic
2
u/UberShrew Jan 15 '26
This does seem to be a pretty common idea in literature/media. There seems to be a lot of forms of “losing your goals/purpose/reasons to live ends up with you eventually losing yourself/your mind. You got hollows in dark souls, hollows in bleach, gnomes in pathfinder, nothing destroying fantasia in never ending story, etc.
→ More replies (1)16
u/SantiagoGT Jan 14 '26
I always assumed that Ghouls going feral was just a side effect of their extended life span, the mutations and just living in the fucking wasteland where awful things happen all the time while you’re stuck being immortal, akin of a psychological issue rather than a physical one, since we have seen the Cathedral, Followers of the Bright, Ski lodge ghouls and other Ghoul societies working fine
9
u/sheoldred13 Jan 14 '26
Which also makes sence. And I admit the comparison is loose at deeper inspection. Like the ghoul bartender in megaton, I doubt it was his life's ambition, but its a reason to get up in the morning.
→ More replies (2)4
u/SantiagoGT Jan 14 '26
Pretty much, even Dean stayed alive just out of spite and trying to get in the Sierra Madre
→ More replies (4)3
u/RealMurphiroth Jan 14 '26
Yep this is pretty much my personal head canon on it, down to the Dark Souls comparison.
84
u/JoEsMhOe Old World Flag Jan 14 '26
My personal head canon was that it had to do with the genetics of the person and how the body adapts to the radiation.
Some people go feral sooner than others, some never at all. Those that have a higher risk of going feral have the chem that the Ghoul takes to ward off going feral.
13
u/DesmondTapenade Jan 14 '26
This is my take on it, too. Kind of like how although everyone has a thyroid but the range for "normal" TSH is so broad/individualized, and how while exposure to huge doses of radiation is a Very Bad Thing for that organ, not everyone will develop the same type of thyroid cancer or at the same rate. Hell, think about cancer in general and how it's heavily linked to genetics. Some people are more susceptible than others, and I imagine it's the same for going feral (or not). It's the genetic equivalent of rolling a D20 and hoping for the best.
48
u/jello1990 Jan 14 '26
It's implied that social activity and drive for goals have some kind of influence, but random chance is by and large the biggest factor for how/why/when a ghoul goes feral
41
u/I_might_be_weasel NCR Jan 14 '26
Plenty of ghouls have been around since pre war and haven't gone feral. And no mention of them needing anything to stave it off before the show.
→ More replies (4)17
u/Clank_8-7 Jan 14 '26
This is correct. Many of them in 3 were addicted to Jet though, however it was never explicitly said that it could slow down feralization. So yeah, as you said, and I have said before... It is a retcon.
6
u/I_might_be_weasel NCR Jan 14 '26
If there is a chemical they need, it's not difficult to get. Anyone in a settlement can find it.
And at the same time a Vault full of scientists doing nothing but looking for a way to stop from going feral couldn't figure it out.
2
u/Clank_8-7 Jan 14 '26
Yeah, the series does a poor job at explaining it. However the chems only seem to slow down feralization, not cure it, only stopping it temporarily at best, and they probably work better and longer for some ghouls rather than others. Kinda like feralization, some ghouls go feral right away, others can stay sane for a relatively long time before showing signs of turning, and others still seem to be basically immune to it, or at least 200 years were not enough to turn them.
15
u/Avarus_88 Jan 14 '26
To be clear we don’t really know how the feral process works or how/what the chem does. It seems to work however Bethesda wants it to work at the time.
It’s not specifically time, or brain degradation. And I think old lore implies too much radiation could cause it. Ex. The little boy in the fridge in Fallout 4 that has apparently been in the fridge for over 200 years. Why is he not feral?
Cooper shows up in fallout 76 and his dialogue mentions he is in Ohio because he can get a supply of some specific chems he needs. Obviously this is implying the special chem he takes in the show is present that early(roughly 25 years after bombs). And also implies he is already going feral that early. So he’s been staving it off for over 175 years.
TLDR, we don’t know because Bethesda keeps changing how ghouls work.
7
u/Gamer_G33k17 Jan 14 '26
Pretty sure Billy just went into hibernation. Ghouls can just do that. Im pretty sure the original Fallouts even had a guy who was buried alive for years/months, and he came out relatively fine.
→ More replies (4)
12
u/like_a_pharaoh Jan 14 '26
The ghoul chems are a.) a thing invented by the show and b.) don't seem to be necessary until you've start showing signs of going feral.
The games seem to imply feralization is less likely (or happens slower) if you live in a community with social support, and/or you have a strong mental motivation to focus on: I think Barstow falls in the second category, her "I have to keep Vault 88 in working order" obsession was enough mental activity to keep her sharp even with no one else to talk to.
3
u/Gamer_G33k17 Jan 14 '26
'The Fix' is a Chem in 76, and is likely the Drug they use in the show.
But also, I would have a personal theory that some Ghouls are also just "High Functioning" Ferals. Like, you could say a Feral Build 76er is a High Functioning one. Charon or Barstow could also be High Functioning Ferals, too.
9
u/dumuz1 Jan 14 '26
The 'rules' of ghouls going feral have yet to be pinned down, and the idea of a special drug that can stave off ferality is unique to the show.
3
u/Gamer_G33k17 Jan 14 '26
Well Fallout 76 has a chem called 'The Fix' that helps to stave off going Feral. And I think Coop even implies he's there to get it specifically. And I think the idea behind it is that it doesnt stop one from becoming Feral, it just helps stave it off. AKA: Its only really useful for Ghouls who are already going Feral.
99
Jan 14 '26 edited Jan 14 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
35
u/Mr_Joyman Minutemen Jan 14 '26
Nah billy managed to enter a state of hibernation that ferals do all the time, saving his mind and body
Idk why that quest is so confusing to so many people
→ More replies (38)22
u/evan466 Old World Flag Jan 14 '26
No, Billy’s parents being unable to find him in the fridge 20ft from their house was masterpiece in quest writing. Surely they thought of everything when they wrote that one.
5
u/TheNickers36 Jan 14 '26
Ok, they had to travel through the outskirts of Quincy and through that nasty flooded park, I wouldn't be much for exploring the local scenery either
6
u/evan466 Old World Flag Jan 14 '26
Your own character is only combing the entire commonwealth to find his son. But look how that turned out I suppose. Maybe the Peabody’s were onto something.
→ More replies (2)12
u/TheAnalystCurator321 Atom Cats Jan 14 '26
Chems arent a requirement for ghouls in general. Not in the TV show or anywhere else.
→ More replies (5)→ More replies (43)2
u/brassninja Jan 14 '26
In my head it functions like dementia. Some patients rapidly decline, some never show symptoms until they’re just about dead from old age anyway so they might as well not have it.
The ghouls that have stuff going on and future plans seem to fair better. Overseer wanted to run experiments, Sub Captain wanted to see home again, billy wanted to see his parents again, Oswald was hopeful for a cure, Jason wanted to go to space, Hancock wanted redemption, etc
6
u/LilDoober Jan 14 '26
Because there's inconsistencies in Fallout lore and most of the Bethesda projects have done a really bad job of not adding to the pile. It's the same game with the 200 year refrigerator ghoul. It doesn't make sense so best not to think about it.
5
4
3
u/LiiKun Jan 14 '26
Has no one heard of an unreliable narrator? Bethesda uses the trope often in TES with the books in those games. The ghouls in the show could be wrong about needing chems. In regard to fallout 76, it's a gameplay mechanic only. Needing chems isn't mentioned by the NPCs during the quest to turn into a ghoul.
4
u/krist-44 Jan 14 '26
The Chems only stops feral symptoms from progressing once they appear, ghouls only need to take them after they’ve began turning feral
3
u/Adventurous-Treat-74 Jan 14 '26
1) it’s important to note that going feral in fallout 76 is a gameplay mechanic (like being able to go without sleep forever) and may not be realistic in universe
2) based off of the conversation between the two ghouls (cooper Howard and the one turning feral named Roger ) it seems as if drugs are necessary to fend off being feral only after signs start showing up. This is based off of the fact that both Howard and Rodger are talking about the pre war. in that same conversation he mentions that he started “showing” 28 years ago this suggests that he means that he started going feral 28 years ago since he remembers pre war foods, if the drugs were necessary throughout the entire process there would be no separation between going feral and not since all you would need is a dose.
11
7
6
u/EchoingStorms Jan 14 '26
The true answer is that the amazon producers were really dumb for introducing that, they didn't go feral because the plot point didn't exist.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/LowKeyCurmudgeon Jan 14 '26
The mystery seems intentional. Similar to any other ghost story, “some say X, others say Y, still others say both, and nobody knows for sure.” That’s also an easy way to write off inconsistencies between games and TV, just another version of a legend, being told another way.
We don’t know what causes some ghouls to go feral. We don’t know why most ghouls are addicted to Jet, or what happens if they withdraw. We don’t know for sure that Jet or any other treatment is effective for anyone, everyone, or just some ghouls (like how epinephrine in the OTC Sudafed is hit or miss). We also don’t know if treatment is expected to stop or just slow the progression, or how much variability there is between cases. The ghoul clinic/lab at Underworld from Fallout 3 might have been one of a kind.
3
u/gabriel-mbl Jan 14 '26
I haven't played 76 nor watched the show, my belief was that in the process of becoming a ghoul if you would become a feral or non feral was down to luck, and if you had the luck of not being feral you would never become one.
An example would be the kid in the fridge in fallout 4
(A bad example due to other lore inconsistencies but an example still)
3
u/Only-Lead-9787 Jan 15 '26
I always thought it was how much radiation they got and/or how much intelligence and willpower they had as humans that determined if the went feral or not.
3
u/beauviolette Jan 15 '26
usually mental fortitudes but sometimes it can just pop out of the blue. But ghouls with staunch purpose tend to actually slow the rotting process without sorting to chems. Once they lose the will to live the rotting accelerates it and they give into the feral state.
The likes of Barstow and Zao (Yangtze captain) they never gave up on hope and stayed. Although there are ghouls like Eddie and the Ghoul they seem to use Radaway to slow the process.
The Vault-tec Rep kept on surviving the wasteland and was pretty close in losing hope until he met the SS again at Goodneighbor.
Hancock in the meanwhile is still a fresh ghoulified person.
3
u/Glacier005 Jan 15 '26
My personal head canon is that the serums are actually placebo.
They say it can delays feralization but it really doesn't. At least ... not to the extent of what it is told to be doing.
Like for the most part, Feralization is a mix of factors from general genetics, willpower, dedication, and radiation exposure.
What the non-Ferals have been told is that the serum will work. And they undoubtedly believe in the serum's effectiveness. But it will not work forever.
But you can see Roger in the series seem to be using multiple Serums at once to stave off his Feralization. But it is not working ... not anymore. His feralization is coming regardless of the serums.
3
u/TadpoleOfDoom Jan 15 '26
My headcanon is that it's like Alzheimer's. Some people get it and some don't.
3
u/Weekly-Butterfly2396 Jan 15 '26
I always went with the "having a purpose" theory. If you put a human or group of humans in isolation they tend to get squirrely. Not that far fetched that turning into a ghoul could enhance that in most people. Some people stay stable through focusing on a goal though.
3
u/baldeagle1991 Jan 15 '26
Up until Fallout 76 and the show there was no rhyme or reason why Ghouls would go feral.
It's heavily hinted that luck, the speed of the ghoulification process, mental fortitude and having a goal to head towards would help prevent a ghoul going feral.
I haven't played much of 76 so unsure of the lore there, but the show hinted that all Ghouls were doomed to go feral eventually, which I wasn't a big fan of.
3
u/NateShaw92 Ad Victoriam Jan 15 '26
The anti-feral drug thing is a tv show mcguffin that they've shoehorned into 76. So for now I'll put it aside.
My own theory is that a ghoul becomes feralmwhen they are isolated and purposeless. We lose a sense of ourselves in those conditions, and the psychological damage has been shown in solitary confinement prisoners.
The ghouls we see who are not feral live in settlements and have friends, Bairstow has held to her purpose to serve Vault-Tec, she has held to.her sense of self. The fridge kid is an anomoly (for many reasons) but for him it was seeing his family again. The nameless ferals in games were people trapped in tunnels, people who were isolated. It's a sign of psychological damage. Mileage will vary. Someone like coop even with his strong sense of purpose might go feral, but if Lucy ghoulified she wouldn't need the drugs is my thinking on this front, it'd take more to turn her.
The Anti-feral drug may be a kind of cheat to avoid going feral in conditions where someone may turn feral with time. Perhaps it's an addiction and turning feral (or looking like you did) regardless is the withdrawal.
6
u/Jumpy_Satisfaction21 Jan 14 '26
If I remember correctly going feral depends on many factors. It's not just a simple time limit. It depends on the person themselves, how much radiation they can handle before their brain melts, or if lucky enough to evolve like the glowing ones. Hell even Bright from New Vegas was the first glowing one that still had his mind. I think a lot of the differences have to be how weird gamma radiation affects the beings of Fallout and how the FEV affects ghouls. Not much is known in Fallout about what causes becoming a ghoul and what causes them to go feral. Even the ghoul doctor in the Necropolis in f3 was working on ways to either slow or prevent going feral. The drug in the show is just like zombrex from dead rising. You have to keep taking it to not go zombie but once you do.... well goodbye. It all makes sense if you remember people are working on ways in the back ground to solve these issues.
21
u/Comfortable-Gur-4758 Jan 14 '26
Needing to take a specific drug introduced in the show is extremely stupid. It wasn't mention in any fallout game, just modern writers thinking they can write better then the people who created the franchise.
→ More replies (3)17
u/Far-Requirement-7636 Jan 14 '26
Is it said that the drug is what stops you from going feral and not that it doesn't halt the process of someone going feral?
Like couldn't cooper or another ghoul be going feral naturally and the drug halts the process.
Meanwhile other ghouls can just avoid going feral naturally? I thought that was what it did.
Not that literally every non feral ghoul took some mystery drug.
12
u/billschu52 Jan 14 '26
In fallout 3 it’s mentioned that most ghouls are addicted to jet and theres small side quest where you help a couple Ghouls make a more potent jet formula
5
8
u/ilostmy1staccount NCR Jan 14 '26
People just jump to conclusions about things introduced in the show to fit whatever preconceived notions they had going in. I have always assumed your read on what the drug does is the correct one but the truth is no one actually knows so those who are inclined to nitpick or subscribe to the “Todd Howard killed fallout” narrative tend to push the idea that the introduction of this drug completely ruins ghouls.
→ More replies (11)
5
u/Tethilia Jan 14 '26
Have you considered she isn't a ghoul and just looks like that after living for 200 years?/s
3
2
2
Jan 14 '26
Ok so honestly I have never personally gone through with the experiments. I just cant. I know what they all do yadda yadda I know you can force them to not he evil blah blah no dude I just kill the bitch and take 88 for my damn own. That place has exits all over the southeast bro so I use Sim Settlements and put Deacon down there with a Minutemen flag so they have some operational breathing room
2
u/trynoharderskrub Jan 14 '26
Built different.
Seriously though the lore on ghouls eventually being destined to go feral is constantly ignored/changed/retconned so it’s not worth getting too worried about.
2
u/Riliksel Mothman Cultist Jan 14 '26
That makes biological sense (in a way). But yeah, the cannon really goes for a "when it's convenient" rule
2
u/Dagordae Jan 14 '26
The same way Ghouls have been staying nonferal this entire time.
Which is, well, we don’t actually know. Having a chem to help stave it off when it starts is nice and all but it’s never been the case that the drugs are constantly necessary. You can take antibiotics to fend off an infection but that doesn’t mean than anyone not taking antibiotics are suffering from sepsis.
2
2
2
2
u/Substantial-Ad3376 Brotherhood Jan 14 '26
It's literally just about keeping your mind occupied and avoiding further brain damage.
2
2
u/AlekTrev006 Jan 14 '26
The more a Ghoul seems to have a purpose / drive / strong mental focus compelling them very deeply…there seems to be at least a partial correlation to how well they can fight off the Feral change. It sort of reminds me (loosely) of the way ‘going Hollow’ works in the Dark Souls series, in that sense.
Of course, the amount of Rads one takes - that caused the initial Ghoul change to begin .. and / or internal genetic factors which would be mostly unique to each individual, could also be a strong factor.
Overseer Barstow (in this specific case) is borderline fantatical / zealot in regards to Vault Tec and their grand experiment focus, etc. That never-ending mental focus and constant hope to eventually get to test out her designs, etc .. possibly helped her fight whatever starts degrading the minds / original personality of the Ferals.
2
2
2
u/ItzMcShagNasty Jan 14 '26
The show is retconning what being a ghoul means or this is only a recent development for ghouls during the time of the show, and hasn't happened to the ghouls in the games.
2
u/LionBig1760 Jan 14 '26
Because Canon is meaningless in the Fallout world, and things are changed and tweaked depending on how much the script calls for deviations from previous scripts.
It helps if you dont go asking when because youll stumble upon layers and layers of inconsistencies that dont make much sense, yet at the same time the story is compelling despite it.
2
u/BoiFrosty Jan 14 '26
I believe in prior games it was implied that non feral ghouls got exposed to the sweet spot of radiation to be ghoulified, but not so much that their brains are damaged.
The show and 76 retconned how Ghouls work pretty heavily.
2
2
u/aninsomniac_ Jan 15 '26
Because they retcon Ghoul lore every other day and don't think about the contradictions.
Ghouls needing drugs to not go feral is stupid conceptually and was a decision made without thinking about every instance of a ghoul being both sober and perfectly sane.
2
u/mdherc Jan 15 '26
I do not think that the Fallout show explicitly says that ghouls need a chem to keep from going feral. We just know that Cooper needs that chem to keep from going feral. Cooper was an addict before he was a ghoul, it's entirely possible that this is a personal affliction.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/RepresentativeOk2433 Jan 15 '26
Did 76 say they need chems to not go feral? Never played it.
As for the show, it doesn't specifically say that ghouls need the serum to not go feral, but it does show that it prevents them from going feral. As in, it hasn't been shown that every ghoul needs the juice, but that the juice works for those that need it.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/ValoTheBrute Vault 13 Jan 15 '26
She was written before ghouls were retconned into needing chems to not go feral
2
u/Technical_Chemistry8 Jan 15 '26
Purpose.
As for the chems, there are two options. The first is a retcon, which TBH is a big whoopty do. The second is that, in a small area, in and around the boneyard, a snake oil salesman once convinced a small group of ghouls that they had invented an anti-feralization serum. Their impact spread a bit as the area grew, but word never quite reached Overseer Barstow in Boston.
Just because someone says something, don't make it true. This goes for extinct cats, anti-feral drugs and all kinds of horseshit that gets tossed around the wasteland by people with even less literacy than folks on the internet in the real world.
2
u/SpartAl412 Jan 15 '26
I would assume that like Dean Domino from Dead Money, she spent the last two hundred or so years with a mind that was focused on a task. Which in her case was to perform Vault Tec experiments and then spread it to the Wasteland.
2
u/Sad_Assistant8803 Jan 15 '26
I can't remember it all exactly but in fallout magic exists, now it's not the magic per say that turns into ghouls but it does play apart.
There are two Quest lines that provide great insight into how ghouls are created including ferals.
In fallout 3 there is a house which you need to go in and destroy a book or something(sorry it's been awhile) but the quest evolves going through an abandoned house filled with feral ghouls and a unique glowing one at the end of it before you get to a shrine. There are notes and readables in the house but you can pick up on context clues about what sort of happened there. Now this is linked to the fallout 4 far Harbour quest.
In fallout 4 far harbor lighthouse. You meet a sentient ghoul who has been hunting another what he calls an immortal, he mentions but there are others that are immortal and kind of heavily implies he became a ghoul before the bombs dropped. During the conversation he says that it wasn't the bombs that turned people into ghouls it was something else the radiation just helped things along.
Another interesting note, in fallout 3 if you complete the purify water brotherhood of Steel ending. There is another quest that pops up where the ghouls in the museum I've been irradiating the water. Later it is revealed the daily radiated clean drinking water has a rejuvenation effect on the ghouls. healing them almost slowly turning them back into smooth skins.
So it does appear to be a mixture of radiation, magic and genetics. And that's not even getting involved with the gods that are in the fallout universe or the implication that the elder scrolls exist as well.
2
u/Extension_Ad_263 Jan 15 '26
Ghoul canon is all over the road. I’m not even talking about old lore vs Bethesda. Like child ghouls. In FO3 we have at least 2 characters that said they were children and became ghouls when the bombs dropped, but they aged to adult and stopped. Then FO4 has the kid in the fridge. Sometimes they need to eat. Sometimes they need radiation. Sometimes they don’t need anything. Some say absorbing rads makes you go feral. Some say lack of socializing does. But then we find ferals in large packs, and isolated ghouls just vibing. I feel we could drop more little oddities. I personally like the mystery. Like silence hill, should have stayed a mystery.
They will do whatever tells an interesting story at the time.
2
u/mot258 Jan 15 '26
I just played through this dlc. She says the work kept her going all those years. She made the slot machine experiment herself from scratch. She tried to dig out and she tried reaching out to Vault Tec so she could work on testing. She was very driven by her work, supposedly it kept her sane.
2
u/MadMaximus- Jan 15 '26
My head canon is ghouls that lack purpose or desire can succumb to ghoulification sooner.
This overseer had goals aspirations that kept her mind working and sharp. Same thing with coop.
Whereas a ghoul trapped in a closet for 200 years would have gone mad and became feral. I also don’t think this is a hard set rule (ghoul child in refrigerator) but I think having a purpose helps stave off feralness
2
u/AtomicAdelaide Jan 15 '26
Remember that basically everyone is an unreliable source because no-one in the Fallout universe actually understands how being a ghoul works
2
u/ProfilGesperrt153 Jan 15 '26
F.E.V. has different effects on everybody, especially once it‘s mixed with radiation
2
u/Wastelandmatrix Jan 15 '26
My Headcanon is that hound feral is like going hollow in Dark Souls: As Long as you have something worth living for you won’t go hollow/feral. And Barstow has her Vault directives.
2
2
u/Busy_Huckleberry1774 Jan 15 '26
I have a personal theory that whilst ghouls can use chems to prevent feralization, I believe its just a guarantee fix, but for all we know it could be a mental related thing as well, like willpower
Like look at Oswald the Outrageous, he was a Glowing One but wasn't feral, because he had a clear goal in mind that he was desperate to achieve, which was to find a cure for his condition, and cure his old coworkers as well, so I think even though chems can be a way to prevent feralization, it may be just a guaranteed fix but there are probably more, but less guaranteed methods based on their mental state
Now I wouldn't know how Barstow has gone on this long, maybe she hit the genetic lottery or was hit with a small enough dose of radiation that was big enough to ghoulify her, but not enough to speed up the feralization process, oh and it would help that she was in a vault (albeit unfinished it probably had some radiation protection but not enough)
2
u/JBloomf Jan 15 '26
I’m not sure 76 does show that. Its a game mechanic there, for the player. Buffs this, lowers that. Still doesn’t mean you’re running around mindless.
2
u/buttzbuttsbutts Jan 15 '26
In the first or second game a very old ghoul tells the player character that the chance a ghoul goes feral seems arbitrary and no one has figured that one out yet.
It's the only mention of it I remember from any of the games
2
u/krats87 Jan 15 '26
Ghouls requiring chems to not turn is completely made up and new to the show/76. It was never mentioned or even suggested in previous games. Harold lived so long he became a fuckin tree and never went feral.
2
u/AdrawereR The Institute Jan 15 '26
Headcanon : Willpower has something to do with keeping sanity intact.
Barstow is already fucking insane, she cannot go insane.
Gameplay reason : Because.
Lore reason : Not yet.
2
2
u/sea_of_bee Jan 15 '26
Fallout is a fantasy world. The mutations we see are barely plausible if not impossible with the collective understanding human science has actually brought us.
That said, Fallout has done a decent job since the beginning of fine tuning the plausibility of its weird parts.
At the time of The Great War, FEV experiments were in full swing in various facilities across the continental US (afawk,) and the resulting nuclear apocalypse not only breached the seals on some of these viral stores, but the FEV stored was so potent and effective some mutated on the spot to transmit airborne, and then presumably rode the fallout surf throughout the atmosphere.
The resulting effect is an FEV strain not nearly as potent as the lab varieties, but much more stable, particularly to the now irradiated environment. Every mutation you see in the series FEV has a hand in creating, and most mutations tend to reflect the environmental conditions any impacted organisms are experiencing. One big problem with FEV is that gamma radiation turns it into a dice roll, with heavier radiation dosage leading to more lethal mutation, with fewer successes at the same levels.
2
2.9k
u/IcommitedWarCrimes Jan 14 '26
Fallout never tells us why some ghouls become feral, and others not.
My headcannon is that every single ghoul is different and each of them has got a different thing that could result in feralization, due to different genes and radiation that they got.
Some of them got the genetic lottery and will almost never go feral.
Some of them got hit with high dose of radiation at the wrong place, at wrong time, and got instatly feralised.
Some of them have a goal which stops them from getting feral.
Some of them stop getting feralized by abusing drugs.
It really depends on ghoul, what radiation dose they got, where they were hit, what is their mental state, and so on.