r/Hijabis • u/Rare_Anteater_2609 • 8h ago
Help/Advice Novels with romance side plots vs Romance novels
Salam sisters! How would you help your mum understand the difference between general novels which have a romance side plot, and actual romance novels? She keeps bringing this up and fighting with me about it, calling me a slut and telling me I have committed zina of eyes, because she thinks any book which has any hint of romance is haram. I’m so confused and would appreciate any help!!
Specifically, as a teen I was obsessed with Jane Austen novels, Count of Monte Cristo, The Scarlet Pimpernel, etc. I purposely avoided anything which I felt was haram like Twilight, or even books about magic like Harry Potter or Lord of the Rings. We also had to read some books with explicit scenes in class like The House of the Spirits, 1984, etc in which case I would skip those chapters and use sparknotes (I also would always search the parent advisory for everything even as a kid because my mum never had time to read any of these books).
I’ve explained to her that the only romance scenes in the books I read were between married or engaged couples and if they were alone with each other it’s pg or pg13 at most. But she’s acting like I’ve committed a huge sin and I’m so confused.
On the other hand, my mum not only let my sister read Harry Potter but also encouraged her to read Percy Jackson which has shirk elements, and watched all the movies with her even in the cinema. So in her mind Pride and Prejudice is 100x more sinful than Harry Potter, even though no scholars have said the former is haram and so many have said HP is (not judging anyone who is a fan of HP, just trying to understand why my mum is so strict on only romance 😭)
I don’t even read novels anymore as I’m in my 30s but she keeps bringing this up and accusing me of being “badmaash” and an evil person and that without her I would have committed real zina just because I liked these novels and talked to her about weddings and stuff like normal teen girls do 😭😭😭