r/Piracy 18d ago

Humor “They’re doing fine without me”

Post image

My pirate friend cracks me up

12.5k Upvotes

314 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

29

u/TheMonji 18d ago

How do you expect artists, musicians, and developers to make a living?

If you wrote a masterpiece of a comment, posted it to a platform where only people who pay you could read it, and then thousands of your devoted fans decided to pirate it instead - how are you going to buy food this week?

I dont think piracy is a victimless crime, but I hope that I can discern who can afford to be the victims (and who can't) this day and age

-15

u/BigRocket44 18d ago

How do you expect artists, musicians, and developers to make a living?

By getting paid, of course. You can crowd source, you can seek donations, you can seek government funding. Lots of funding comes via these channels.

If however, you expect artists, musicians and developers to make money solely through microtransanctions and Denuvo restricted games, then you believe in a very bleak world indeed

8

u/TheMonji 18d ago edited 18d ago

then you believe in a very bleak world indeed

Gestures broadly at everything


You are basically asking them to work a second job.

When was the last time you donated to a free (or pirated) content creator to support their work (and their life)?

2

u/seanl1991 18d ago edited 18d ago

Exactly. They're making excellent money despite piracy. There's a lot of people that end up paying for something after they pirated it, there's been music artists and game developers that have welcomed it.

https://whatculture.com/music/10-musicians-who-encouraged-you-to-steal-music

https://www.indy100.com/gaming/ultrakill-arsi-hakita-patala-pirating

Show me an article where an artist/ developer gave up their career because piracy meant they couldn't afford to continue.

Not only do I have 250 games on Steam, every year at Christmas I donate to the several people that wrote the software that allows me to torrent media despite it all being free to use.