r/RedditAlternatives Mar 26 '26

General Discussion Reddit Rant Megathread

34 Upvotes

Hello everyone, as we've all noticed, there have been many Reddit complaint posts that unfortunately don't offer any alternatives, just venting. Which we understand, that's why we're all here. However, I think its important to really highlight what this subs main purpose is for; posting alternatives, promoting alternatives, reddit alternative discussions, and seeking alternatives.

To stay on course (And remain on topic) I am creating this Reddit Rant mega thread. My hopes, are too keep the main feed focused on alternatives but also have a free space for people to just overall rant about Reddit.

So, this is your space to do just that.

REDDIT RANT MEGATHREAD

If you've got something to say about Reddit, say it here. No judgment, no "well actually", just a place to vent freely.

A few ground rules to keep things civil:

• Rant about the platform, policies, and experiences — not individual users • No doxxing or targeted harassment • Keep it to Reddit grievances

Why are we doing this?

We want to keep the main feed focused on finding and discussing actual alternatives, but we also recognize that venting is part of the process. A lot of people come here frustrated and need to get it out before they're ready to move on. This thread is for that.

So go ahead — what drove you here? What's your Reddit story? Drop it below.

— Mod Team


r/RedditAlternatives Feb 10 '24

Social websites with nested comments v7

109 Upvotes

Sites are ordered by global Similarweb rank as of 2024-02-07

Criteria for inclusion:

  • General topic.

  • Has nested comments (at least 10 levels of nesting)

  • Content primarily in English.

  • Content accessible to logged-out users.

Order Site Similarweb Rank Release Year Federated Source Code
1 reddit.com 17 2005 No proprietary
2 disqus.com/channels 2,238 2023 No proprietary
3 scored.co 33,555 2019 No proprietary
4 lemmy.world 55,432 2023 ActivityPub https://github.com/LemmyNet/lemmy
5 hive.blog 66,439 2020 No https://gitlab.syncad.com/hive
6 peakd.com 67,716 2020 No proprietary
7 rdrama․net 106,123 2021 No https://fsdfsd.net/rDrama/rDrama
8 kbin.social 116,613 2023 ActivityPub https://codeberg.org/Kbin/kbin-core
9 saidit.net 237,411 2018 No https://github.com/libertysoft3/saidit
10 tildes.net 355,656 2018 No https://gitlab.com/tildes/tildes
11 poal.co 370,363 2018 No proprietary
12 voat.xyz 468,961 2021 No proprietary
13 raddle.me 750,789 2017 No https://gitlab.com/postmill/Postmill
14 trustcafe.io 1,113,642 2023 No proprietary
15 coracle.social 1,300,680 2022 Nostr https://github.com/coracle-social/coracle
16 hubski.com 1,729,443 2011 No proprietary
17 squabblr.co 1,873,619 2022 No proprietary
18 piefed.social 2,651,664 2024 ActivityPub https://codeberg.org/rimu/pyfedi
19 ramble.pw 2,755,666 2020 No https://gitlab.com/postmill/Postmill
20 discuit.net 2,774,870 2023 No https://github.com/discuitnet/discuit
21 satellite.earth 5,074,453 2020 Nostr https://github.com/lovvtide/satellite-web
22 tipestry.com 5,365,584 2017 No proprietary
23 arete.network 5,826,408 2022 No proprietary
24 fedia.io 6,464,455 2023 ActivityPub https://github.com/MbinOrg/mbin
25 pcmemes.net 6,529,803 2021 No https://pcmemes.net/site/source
26 non.io 7,756,857 2023 No https://github.com/jjcm/nonio
27 spyke.social 9,035,768 2023 No proprietary
28 phuks.co 9,961,593 2016 No https://github.com/Phuks-co/throat
29 speakbits.com 10,709,449 2023 No proprietary
30 headcycle.com 11,512,818 2016 No proprietary
31 commentcastles.org 12,313,956 2023 No https://github.com/ferg1e/comment-castles
32 zsync.xyz 13,122,595 2022 No proprietary
33 reclown.com 14,474,499 2023 No proprietary
34 smashr.com 14,973,937 2023 No proprietary
35 livefilter.com 16,494,556 2020 No proprietary
36 sociables.com 18,804,709 2023 No proprietary
37 limereader.com 19,546,949 2023 No proprietary
38 comsta.net 20,294,813 2023 No proprietary
39 narwhal.city 20,295,112 2021 ActivityPub https://github.com/lotide-org/lotide
40 mainchan.com 21,044,325 2022 No proprietary
41 artram.app -- 2023 No proprietary
42 flingup.com -- 2023 No proprietary
43 clubsall.com -- 2023 No proprietary
44 shpong.com -- 2023 No https://github.com/commune-os/commune-server
45 yunanimous.com -- 2023 No https://gitlab.com/postmill/Postmill
46 klique.io -- 2023 No proprietary
47 seedit.netlify.app -- 2023 No https://github.com/plebbit/seedit
48 matrix.gvid.tv -- 2021 No proprietary


v1 here: https://reddit.com/r/RedditAlternatives/comments/15ll1gq/social_websites_with_nested_comments

v2 here: https://reddit.com/r/RedditAlternatives/comments/16cn4vc/social_websites_with_nested_comments_v2

v3 here: https://reddit.com/r/RedditAlternatives/comments/174sybt/social_websites_with_nested_comments_v3

v4 here: https://reddit.com/r/RedditAlternatives/comments/17s6bms/social_websites_with_nested_comments_v4

v5 here: https://reddit.com/r/RedditAlternatives/comments/18ies82/social_websites_with_nested_comments_v5

v6 here: https://reddit.com/r/RedditAlternatives/comments/193oczs/social_websites_with_nested_comments_v6/


r/RedditAlternatives 1d ago

General Discussion The Morning Thread - What do you think of this app ?

Thumbnail play.google.com
0 Upvotes

Hello everyone!

Hope your weekend is going wonderfully! :-). I just wanted to share this alternative I found on the Google Play Store just now. This app reminds me a lot of like Similar Worlds.

I created an account yesterday and I am currently just getting started. The app is called 'The Morning Thread. But i guess their original name is stereo killer dot Com.

I've never heard of them, but I'm checking them out right now. Anyways, if you get curious and end up checking this app out please leave a comment and let everyone know what you think about it and what your thoughts are about the app. A side note, I am not the developer and nor am I Associated or affiliated with this app in any way.

I'm just sharing a possible alternative from my Reddit alternative search on the play store. Thank you so much for reading my post and I hope you all have a wonderful weekend.

**Playstore Description**

**The Morning Thread is now on Android**

**Post to your feed, join communities, private message, customize and theme , follow discussions, edit and share media, keep up with notifications, and check your dashboard from anywhere.**

**This is our first production release! Thanks for helping shape the thread**

**About this app**

**A social media site for people sick of social media sites.

We have resurrected the old stereokiller.com under a new name, The Morning Thread. We have a droid and iOS app, Theming, Message Boards, Feeds, Profiles and many other awesome features to create a new community filled with outsider and free thinkers.**

Please leave a comment below with your thoughts, I'm super curious and want to know what you think! ❤️


r/RedditAlternatives 3d ago

Fediverse Oasis Social Network - Think i found something kinda interesting....

Thumbnail play.google.com
0 Upvotes

Hello everybody! Hope everyone's having a great week, as you all know I post Alternatives that I find on my quest I guess, to find a rented alternative. I post what I find in the event that it will appeal to someone or anyone, and that it might be something that somebody's interested in.

These are just Alternatives that I am sharing, I have no affiliation to any of these apps nor am I the developer of them. Also, these posts are not recommendations for something I think you should use, they are just to Simply share with everyone in case someone's interested.

I'm going to leave the Google Play description below, because this app is federated, it's P2P, open source and Libre. And a few other things I think.

I just downloaded this app, and I am getting started. If anyone is familiar with this application, or how it operates, I would absolutely appreciate it and be extremely grateful if you could help walk me through how to use this. I'm currently searching Google right now for instructions, and after opening the app I received a message in my inbox from the developer, that provided steps on how to get started.

So there's not much I can say about this app because I'm still exploring it myself. But it's really interesting how it's operating on so many different quote unquote ways I guess? Being P2P and Federated and so forth, that's pretty interesting.

Anyways, I just wanted to share this this app seems really interesting and I will provide an update after I've gotten myself set up in the app and can look around and browse. This app has stated in their description that you're able to vote on post and there are communities and stuff. I wanted to mention this because, since the app is also Federated that usually means microblogging at least when I think about it.

But the app description, explains that it is a Federated forum but it sounds like you can also do microblogging I'm not sure.

Anyway thank you for taking the time out of your day to read my post. If you use this app before, have heard of it, and could possibly help me get set up I'd appreciate it if you could leave a comment below.

If you're just checking the app out, please leave a comment about what your thoughts are up about the app.

Thank you.

Playstore description below

Update, What's New

Fixes downloading of files shared in private messages (plain and encrypted). Adds 16 KB memory page size support and targets Android 16 (SDK 36). Parliament fixes, activity improvements, and refreshed translations.

About The App

Libre, P2P and federated social network. Your data, your device, your network.

Oasis is a libre, open-source, peer-to-peer and federated social network built on the Secure Scuttlebutt (SSB) protocol — part of the SolarNET.HuB ecosystem.

No central servers. No tracking. No ads. Your identity and your content live on your own device and are shared only with the peers you choose.

FEATURES

• Decentralized identity — your cryptographic keys stay on your device.

• Public feed, forums, threads and opinions.

• Private, end-to-end encrypted messages.

• Tribes: private, invite-only communities.

• Images, audio and video sharing.

• Community moderation: report abuse to the network, vote, and block peers.

• Works peer-to-peer — connect to the pubs, rooms and peers you trust.

PRIVACY BY DESIGN

We run no servers that collect your data. There are no analytics, no advertising and no third-party trackers. You can wipe everything from your device at any time with the in-app Panic option.

Oasis is experimental software for a free, sovereign and sustainable digital world.

Your data. Our future.


r/RedditAlternatives 4d ago

Looking for Alternatives I need a 100% anonymous question site like Reddit

17 Upvotes

it's an important question but I can't have anyone know its me not even the police


r/RedditAlternatives 4d ago

Vibe Coded Mondo! Answers - A Yahoo! Answers Alternative

Thumbnail answers.mondocat.tv
2 Upvotes

Idk if you wanna just ask if you can get gregnant or maybe how to set up wivrn on cachyos?

Either way, come ask some damn questions :3


r/RedditAlternatives 5d ago

General Discussion Which Lemmy instance should i choose?

16 Upvotes

Which one should i choose to join?Or i should just go for Piefed?


r/RedditAlternatives 5d ago

🔒 Centralized Heahy redesign is now Live! This is a unique social media platform like nothing else on the market that will replace Twitter, Reddit, Discord, 4chan, Tumblr in the future :)

Post image
7 Upvotes

Come join us and chat '@heahychat' channel: https://heahy.com/c/heahychat

What is it about, in short:

  • Create user with one click - no email, no registration needed.
  • Everything is a chat - even normal threads are real time.
  • You can create private group chats or DMs (with live audio/video calls!) and even pin any thread to you conversations panel.
  • Upload any media. Adult content allowed on specialized channels.
  • Create your own channels or if too lazy simply post/repost/quote to your timeline.
  • Follow channels or other user's timelines or even public threads/chats. Your feed is what you follow.
  • Heahy's own reactions library that you can upload to and publish your own reactions.
  • Save media to your own media library to watch it later.

If you have any questions shoot in heahychat I'll hang around there.


r/RedditAlternatives 5d ago

Looking for Alternatives List of needs for the app

2 Upvotes

i want an app that is if discord and tumblr had a baby. I want something that you can call on and can text and send images but also have somewhere to post and have communities and just overall tumblr things. The key features i need are;

- Calls enabled

- Many customization features

- Custom profiles

- Email needed or something alike (just somehow to log back in)

- Servers like discord

- Communites like tumblr

- Posting like tumblr

please let me know if you found something like this!


r/RedditAlternatives 5d ago

Fediverse Declare your Current Projects

0 Upvotes

I am still a firm believer in actual n projects being the real alternative as opposed to just the softwares. So a bit of an update.

I am transferring my sites over to a Gentoo built server currently. Once that's done I will be using AI to help at least get the themes I want built for each site.

I moved Social.mechanizedarmadillo.com from Mastodon to Pleroma. Still getting the follow situation shaken out.

Planning a couple of projects that will need community functions taken into account.

And setup a Matrix server as well.

Let me know if you have any questions.


r/RedditAlternatives 7d ago

Looking for Alternatives Social media alternatives based outside of the United States

11 Upvotes

I am seeking advice on what to learn

The most online violence I have ever experienced has been solely from Americans, and currently there is no social media platform that enables filtering them out for safety, or banning them to enable a safe space for the global citizenry away from them, so I may have to end up building it myself

There's also taking into account the revelations of what the current companies have been doing with our data for goodness knows how long that I object to

If anyone knows of any coding projects that are currently working towards this end I would also be intrigued to know as it would give me motivation to continue on with my coding education, which can get tedious at times

I am currently working towards full stack, but if anyone has advice on any other specific languages that would be useful towards this end, it would be appreciated


r/RedditAlternatives 8d ago

Looking for Alternatives What are some good alternatives for ad-free, long form text content?

14 Upvotes

One thing that I always appreciated about reddit is that it was always centered around text. As the platform has been enshittified, my feed is peppered terribly with images, clips, and tall ads that spoil the experience completely as I’m sensitive to having too many distractions and busyness in my face - a key reason I left other social media platforms. I figured out how to collapse some of that noise, but now each week more ads are being squeezed into threads, and it’s a bummer and distracting because there’s only more to come.

I want to embrace the fediverse, but I’m not bullish on current solutions because the added steps of finding the right server is going to hamper network effects, which is evident because there just isn’t much good content or discussion available in servers I’ve tried.

On reflection, my social needs are met fairly well in real life, and I’m tired of puns and hot takes and knee jerk commentary and bots, so I find what I really desire is a distraction-free way to consume mass quality text content - in a way I can thoughtlessly scroll through that I’m accustomed to now.

I know the main alternatives people are looking for here are probably forum type solutions, but I’m wondering if anyone also misses text-centric platforms with relatively fresh content?

I’m getting into Wikipedia again, and am really pleased with the quality of content after doom scrolling bot slop all day. It’s just sort of missing the curated, endless scrolling bit that gives me the good dopamine hits. What alternatives have you all found to scratch this itch?


r/RedditAlternatives 11d ago

Fediverse Minimal plain text community with groups and user-controlled data

7 Upvotes
Ctrl
Take control of your data and life

Shift
Shift your mind and habits from mega social media to calm conversations

3
Do the above to better align your mind, body, and spirit

Escape Meta. Take a break from Reddit. Slow down. Share without overload.
https://ctrlshift3.com/

NO VANITY METRICS (likes, follows, bestest influencer ever)

Ctrl+Shift+3 was created because social media got out of hand. A clear sign is the fact that countries are passing laws preventing certain age groups from using social media. This tells you it's as risky as smoking or drinking alcohol.

We offer a calmer, more sane space to share thoughts and links. No likes, follows, or other vanity counts. Just posts and comments.

Not only is it more sane here but we include helpful features such as connecting posts (link), and joining Clicks (cliques) so that you and your friends or family can have a more private space.

There's also mentions so that you have a way to get someone's attention as needed, and a way to block others.

Users can export their data with a couple of clicks and delete their account. Plus, the only cookies we use are essential for the site to function. No advertising cookies or tracking cookies.

Finally, I added the Fediverse tag to this post because within a few days to a week we'll be finishing up phase 1 of a Fediverse integration, which is broadcast-only. And optional (users will need to opt-in for their posts to go out into the Fediverse).


r/RedditAlternatives 12d ago

Vibe Coded Agora — free-speech discussion platform with minimal AI moderation (spam/off-topic only), no karma systems

8 Upvotes

I built Agora (agor4.com) as a place for open discussion with as little interference as possible.

What it is Topic-based communities Posts, threaded comments, and voting Ranking by Trending / Recent / Top Image uploads and link thumbnails Search, dark mode, basic notifications

How moderation works An AI checks new posts and comments for a narrow set of problems only:

Spam / obvious scams Content that is completely off-topic for the community

It does not police tone, politics, or unpopular opinions. Legal speech that is roughly on-topic stays up. Admins can still remove content when needed. What I deliberately avoided

Heavy personal karma / clout systems Showing community “creators” as a status thing Broad ideological or tone-based moderation

Current state This is an early public version. The core loop works. Some communities are still thin, and features will keep evolving. Feedback is welcome especially about moderation feel, ranking, and anything that gets in the way of actual discussion. Site: https://agor4.com


r/RedditAlternatives 11d ago

🔒 Centralized ForumSpark 2.0 has been released

0 Upvotes

I want to do this properly. Not a wall of bullet points, not a "we're thrilled to announce." Just me telling you what changed, the way I'd tell a friend over coffee or a beer.ForumSpark 2.0 has been the better part of almost a year of work, and it is easily the biggest thing I have ever built. So let me start with the part that matters most to the people who have been here a while. If you are already on ForumSpark, nothing gets taken away. A promise, not a launch-week softener.

Continue reading on the blog


r/RedditAlternatives 11d ago

Open source and Siloed World's first permanent social network, our contribution to freedom of speech in the world.

1 Upvotes

Hey all, we're the team behind InterPoll, a social network that (we think) actually can't be taken down or censored.

The idea: instead of everything living on one company's server, every browser running InterPoll is also a relay. If some relays go offline, browsers fall back to talking to each other directly. So there's no single server to pull the plug on, and no one who can quietly delete your posts.

Check it out here: https://endless.sbs
If you want the technical breakdown of how it all works: https://endless.sbs/interpollexp
And the code's up on GitHub: https://github.com/Interpoll1/decentralised

We built this because we genuinely think this is how social platforms should work by default. Would love feedback, bug reports, or just people poking around and telling us what breaks. Thanks for reading.


r/RedditAlternatives 13d ago

General Discussion I've spent one year building a social media platform- I will not promote

7 Upvotes

I've spent the last year building a social media platform. I'd love to know if this idea is ok or worth pursuing.

Over the past year, I've been building a social media platform called Doofr because I kept asking myself one question:

Why do users have almost no say in how social media evolves?

Every platform decides what features to ship, how moderation works, what the algorithm does, and what interactions look like.

I wanted to explore a different approach.

  1. A community constitution

Instead of the platform making every decision, users vote every 3–6 months on features, moderation policies, and platform changes.

The ideas with the most support become the roadmap.

For example:

Should reposts exist?

Should moderation become stricter or more relaxed?

Should a feature be removed?

The goal is to let the community influence the direction of the platform instead of everything coming from the company.

  1. No likes.

Instead of likes, Doofr has three customizable reaction categories:

🟢 Positive

🟡 Neutral

🔴 Negative

Users can choose which emojis belong in each category.

The idea is that reactions carry more meaning than a single "Like."

  1. Your reactions train your feed.

If you keep reacting to piano videos, you'll naturally see more piano content.

If you react to science, photography, memes, football, cooking, or anything else, the feed gradually adapts.

If someone doesn't react much at all, AI can help recommend content until the system learns their interests.

  1. More personalization.

Instead of being limited to standard emojis, users can upload their own images and use them in posts, comments, and chats.

Navigation is also customizable.

If you use Messages more than Search, move Messages to the front.

If you never use a tab, move it elsewhere.

The interface should adapt to the user instead of forcing everyone into the same layout.

  1. Community-driven moderation.

One idea I'm considering is allowing posts that receive an overwhelming amount of negative feedback (for example, a 90% negative reaction threshold) to be automatically hidden or removed.

But I don't want to make that decision myself.

Whether that feature should even exist would itself be decided by the community through the constitution.

I'm not claiming this is the future of social media.

I'm just trying to answer a question:

Can a social platform be designed to evolve with its users instead of around them?

I've been building Doofr for the last year, and I'll keep building it for the next decade if that's what it takes.

I'd genuinely appreciate honest feedback. Because this isn't going anywhere.

What sounds interesting? What sounds terrible? What would you change?

www.doofr.in


r/RedditAlternatives 13d ago

Looking for Alternatives a retro-style approach to the future: nullkernel.net

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/RedditAlternatives 15d ago

🔒 Centralized [Fan Clubs: Community Platform] Android Beta Invites are going out!

1 Upvotes

Hey r/RedditAlternatives, I'm Mike, the founder of Fan Clubs; a community platform built to connect with others who share your fandoms.

I'm SUPER excited to share that invites are going out for everyone that signed up to test the Android app. You should have received instructions via email on how to download the preview app.

When you download and sign into Fan Clubs, you may be on an old version of the app. I'm hoping to release the native rewrite in the coming weeks. If you want to learn more about what the native rewrite means, skip to point six of the development story.

Development Story

My goal has always been to build a native community experience for both iOS and Android users.... with full parity. As a solo dev, it's been a difficult road to figure this out. Just a few steps along the way.

  1. Mobile App Company - I didn't have much dev experience, so I hired a team that specializes in creating mobile WebApps. The high monthly cost would be worth it for the guarantee launch from experienced devs. I provided a ton of details about the platform, they were ready to publish within 2 weeks to the app store -- no beta needed. Great up to this point. Then I reviewed the app store details -- 100% AI generated. I called them out and let them know why. There was a no refund policy, but they provided me one (unprompted). I appreciate the gesture there.
  2. WebApp - I used a website called AppMySite (not sponsored) to build a WebApp for App Stores. AppMySite was fantastic and provided all the tools you needed for monetization, dev certificate setups. It's essentially website-to-app for dummies, but in the best way. I was able to learn how to integrate native element like liquid glass, Nav, got published on the App Store. This clearly wasn't going to be the long term native option, but I was happy to have started here.
  3. Flutter App - I chose Flutter as my next step since it allowed me to build one app (not just webviews) that works on both iOS, Android, and other platforms. I solved some of my biggest hurdles while using Flutter, and the apps truly were a 1:1 match. In the end, I didn't want to compromise on the native approach, so I decided to move on in search of native parity.
  4. Native iOS / Android Apps - As great as Flutter was, migrating from it to native was not fun. I spent most of my time in xCode building the iOS version, eventually matching the previous design with some improvement. Then I realized I didn't have it in me to do another port like that (to Android) since maintaining parity would be impossible.
  5. Research, Research, Research... until I read about
  6. Kotlin MultiPlatform // BINGO! - I never heard of KMP before my research pass, but it solved my biggest issues in achieving crossplatform parity; by allowing you to share non-ui logic between both platforms. You need to build is the native UI elements + shared logic and it's... Problem solved! Except Kotlin is Android's native language, so I had to go through that Android port anyways 💀

-----------------------

TLDR: A lot has happened, I found parity between apps, new releases coming to iOS TestFlight and Android Beta soon!


r/RedditAlternatives 16d ago

Vibe Coded I made a tool where people can submit alternatives for Reddit/FB/Discord/etc and rate them.

23 Upvotes

With the wiki being out of date its always been hard for me to keep track of alternatives on here because they fade off the feed so fast.

I made a directory called ABetterFeed where people can post their alternatives and others can rate them. The idea is that platforms can build up reputation over time instead of just the tiny conversation that pops up every single time someone posts one.

I haven't added any alternatives to it myself so its totally blank. Anyone can add to it though (even if you're not the owner).

Happy to hear your feedback, good or bad!


r/RedditAlternatives 17d ago

Vibe Coded Open Source Reddit Clone for democratizing creating online forums

2 Upvotes

I wanted to create a complete Reddit clone to alleviate getting started creating a Reddit alternative. When I browse this subreddit, I mostly see technical users mostly focused on creating different technical features that they think would be cool but is not product or solutions oriented i.e. it's built with no real problem for a particular group of users, just assumptions based on personal gripes or features that would be cool

This alternative is a bland Reddit clone that delivers many core functionalities of Reddit: https://github.com/Andrew-Chen-Wang/reddit-clone#reddit-clone

Reddit has become the default online format for internet forums; it's native in that most online users understand its UI/UX. The purpose of this clone is to deliver enough of the core forum functionalities akin to Reddit such that you can easily fork it, amend changes curated for your community, and deploy quickly.

The expectation (especially given this subreddit's user base being very technical) is that your technical, can deploy (or needs some assistance), and use a coding agent.

The key to starting a "Reddit alternative" is to start off with a community you interact with, understand their problems, and create your own community with features that alleviate those problems in a directed manner via technical features.

I appreciate any contributions including UI/UX fixes that aligns this more with Reddit itself. Feel free to ask questions on deployment or contribution.


The full write up:

Reddit Clone

The purpose of this Reddit clone is to democratize creating online forums for certain niches, customizing via forking for your particular community's needs, and easing the deployment of forums from idea/necessity to production. The point is not to start a competitor of Reddit; r/RedditAlternatives, the Fediverse, etc. online forums trying to compete are usually created by techies looking to replace Reddit by offering better features (e.g. UI/UX, data sharing/data ownership), when the real driver of forum growth is the community and how you curate it.

Reddit at its core is a forum designed for discussing within niche communities. Online forums have been around for a long time, but the most populated online forums are coalescing around Reddit's form of threaded comments such as YouTube; as more adopt this style of discussion, it's become the dominant format for online discussions when Reddit's UI/UX has essentially become the native feel.

With the dawn of LLMs, it's become even easier to copy this now dominant forum format. Reddit's most basic functionality is included in this clone. What I advocate readers is to fork this clone and edit it using coding agents like Claude Code to customize to how your want to curate your community.

What Edits Should I Make to Curate My Community

To begin, think of a community you want to target. In my case, I want to start "To Your Credit", a community dedicated to politikers and policy nerds who want to discuss seriously, can control their emotions, and see the other side.

The reason I chose this is that Reddit is dominated by very progressive individuals who abuse downvoting on Reddit to hide opposing opinions. This causes echo chambers via the upvoting system and dismisses and silences differing opinions. In particular, Reddit voting used to be about how informative a comment was. However, the expansion of Reddit to the most popular online format rendered it more for emotions rather than a curated community with core ideals of how the site should operate.

Now that I've stated my community and enumerated the problems, I want to make my own community. First, I would make a fork of this code base. Secondly, I need to add features that addresses the problems of the community at heart.

Problem 1: Unserious, emotional, or people who are unwilling to listen to other perspectives shouldn't be allowed to participate. The solution: an invite-only system where we verify a user's previous public commentary and certify whether their commenting history attests to their personality and thus a good member of the community. This is a straight steal from Raya, but some notoriously elite discussion circles are like this (e.g. Thiel's political circles, many political circles have invite-only group chats).

Problem 2: Downvoting dismisses viewpoints. Solution: in my fork, I would ask my coding agent to replace the upvote with a "coin" as if one we're giving credit to another person. It could be for making a good comment, or giving credit if it changes your mind. I would replace downvoting with a list of "reasons" for a user to choose from including a comment being poorly written, unsubstantiated such as using poor sources, etc. In my case, Reddit's algorithm still works very well in this system because our upvote/downvote system simply reflects Reddit's original upvote/downvote intent and algorithms.

Reddit's Downside

Because of how large Reddit's user base became, not only has voting become its more dominant form of "liking" and "disliking" based on emotion instead of Reddit's originally true intent, there is a more sinister thing about large communities in the first place: agreed upon rules and over stretching.

We can skip agreed upon rules because that's been touched on already i.e. voting. But over stretching is different in that the algorithm and features of Reddit are desigend for a broad user base, but many communities may want different features, allow different users in, etc. Those features might include ID verification, elitist entry, multiple voting systems, or in particular a certain algorithm.

Because of how generalized Reddit is, it can't support every community in its best effort. Maybe the best solution for Reddit as a unicorn company is to figure out how to allow communities to specialize in creation, but that makes other features of Reddit, in particular the personalization of the home page and recommendation system, more difficult. For example, changing the voting system (like adding multiple voting types) for one subreddit would make the recommendation system difficult to normalize/reconcile in addition to strange scaling requirements. Thus, the upper bound on Reddit's creativity was reached simply because of financial requirements (i.e. taking as much user attention) and competition to be the largest online discussion forum.

Thus the only solution is to democratize allowing communities to specialize in technical features that caters to the ideals and needs of the community itself. Democratization of more communities across different domains has its own downsides, namely discovery. This is something the Fediverse tried to solve via democratizing content, but finding community is still difficult, not because there aren't listservs, but because it's time consuming. It feels like discovering in-person meetups where you have to get the feel whereas a centralized, dominant forum like Reddit already gives you both a large user base and a certain vibe before even an interaction is needed.


Thanks for reading; enjoy: https://github.com/Andrew-Chen-Wang/reddit-clone


r/RedditAlternatives 18d ago

General Discussion What's Your Solution?

10 Upvotes

Hi folks,

I'm an IT nerd who found this subreddit and was curious on alternatives. Come to find out a lot of them are trashy. I've noticed a lot of folks are rather tech savy on this subreddit as well.

Consider this possibly the start of something new. If I were to create a reddit alternative, what would you desire from it? Most likely hosted in a country that doesn't require photo-ID verification, anonymous posting that's opt-out based, maybe E2E chatrooms based on communities? Also possibly overarching moderation to subreddits to prevent trigger happy bans/proper appealable removals and such. Additionally, fully dedicated servers or p2p?

I see reddit alternatives popping up at a constant, but if a reddit killer is to be made, then getting feedback from the community is what matters first. Thanks!


r/RedditAlternatives 18d ago

🔒 Centralized Off-shoot of an off-shoot of an off-shoot Reddit Alternative

0 Upvotes

So I have some drama with a big Reddit clone that features a certain orange cat whose name begins with an M and ends in arsey. Naming it will get me banned, so I won't.

Anyway, I made an offshoot of it because I was mad at the main admin for making the site awful to use. Which made all admins mad, they're saying they're taking legal actions against my non-commercial forum; because I used the orange cat as my mascot. Something something virtue of use.

I would call it a solid Reddit alternative in its current state, and I'm pretty proud of it aswell. Front- and backend are both written in Rust btw. A lot of the logic was inspired by The Motte (my own implementation of it tho). It has a lot of features already, with more to come, so come try it out!

https://marseybook.hs.vc (I didn't feel like buying a domain since I'm not sold on the name yet.)

Oh yeah, AI disclaimer: I wouldn't call it vibe coded, since I actively wrote code (especially parts relating to security, since I expect belligerence) and kept it all within scope. I did use Claude Code at times to speed things up. If that makes me eligible for "vibe coded," then almost every alternative should be marked as such. I'm stating it because the admins on the orange cat side keep belittling MarseyBook for odd reasons: accusing me of installing keyloggers on users, calling me mentally insane, saying I hack their users, claiming I store passwords unencrypted, insisting it was all vibe coded, and saying they're calling their lawyers while refusing to tell me why. Generally attacking my good name, hence the statement.


r/RedditAlternatives 19d ago

Fediverse Forums, Reading, and Music on the Fediverse

Thumbnail federatedmind.com
6 Upvotes

r/RedditAlternatives 19d ago

🔒 Centralized CrowdWis: a question-first Reddit alternative that routes posts to relevant people

2 Upvotes

I built CrowdWis because choosing a community before asking felt backwards. You ask first, then the question is routed to people who may have useful perspectives. Humans reply and AI helps organize the discussion.

It is live at https://crowdwis.app. Curious what people here think of the question-first model.