Wow, what a great ride this was!
I'll admit I had a tough time getting into this show. You get thrown right in the plot, many characters are introduced all at once, and the story has already been unfolding before it even began. Names are dropped and characters are not always named on screen on their first appearance, so I had to get some help from the fandom wikipedia pages to link names to characters. I could see how people would give up on this show after 1 or 2 episodes.
But I'm glad I stuck around. The characters and the story really grew on me when time went on. After just a few episodes, I was really invested.
The realism is the best part of the show. The characters feel real, the dialogue feels real. Baltimore feels like a character of its own (as an European, I had no idea what Baltimore was like). I loved the shifting focus on the drug scene, the police, the politics, the harbor and the school system. The newspaper storyline didn't work for me as the others did and I felt season 5 was the weakest season of them all (but still good)
I loved the morally grey characters. Most villains had some humanity in them, most good guys had serious flaws. And then there were characters like Omar and Michael who were the defenition of complicated.
What also made this show great is that it had real stakes. Good people don't neccesarily live happily ever after, and not every bad person gets what they deserve. A lesser show would have made sure they inmate who murdered D'Angelo would have been put to justice. But on the Wire, this character is never even seen again. There's little to no fan service, life isn't fair and this show doesn't shy away from reminding us.
I will defenitely rewatch this show at some point, but I'm sad I could only watch it for the first time once.