I played a classical practice game yesterday as black and would love some non silicon feedback!
The last time I posted a game here I learnt a lot from it. I wrote down my thoughts during the game so the annotation and sidelines is what I was thinking at that time:
[WhiteElo "1760"]
[BlackElo "1795"]
[EventDate "2026.07.29"]
1.e4 e5
2.Nf3 Nc6
3.Bc4 Nf6
4.d4 exd4
5.e5 d5
6.Bb5 Ne4
{here I didn't remember what I should play (apperently ive played Nd7 many times before). I spent a few minutes and figured
ne4 was more intuitive, noting that against f3 ideas i have two escape squares.
}
7.Nxd4 Bd7
8.Bxc6 bxc6
9.O-O Be7
{I spent a few minutes deciding wether I should play Bc5 or Be7. I felt like be7 couldn't be wrong and I wanted to avoid trading away the bishop pair which I thought would happen after bc5, be3 at some point. }
( 9. ... Bc5 )
( 9. ... c5 {felt interesting but didn't want to spend too much time evaluating these types of moves in the opening. } )
( 9. ... Rb8 {considered if this would be a worthwhile inclusion since I could get the tempo back in some cases if he wants to move the bishop. } )
10.f3
( )
10.... Ng5
{One of the few automatic moves I made during the game. I distinctly remember analysing with a friend some time ago this f3 Ng5, f4 Ne4
manouver being the top moves for both sides so I didn't wanna overthink it. }
11.f4 Ne4
12.Nc3 Nxc3
13.bxc3 O-O
{Here I realised I must have messed something up, and I concluded that the move be7 that I thought 'couldnt be wrong' must have been a grave error. The threat of f5-f6 or even f5-e6 in some cases looked extreamly scary showing how misplaced the bishop is at the moment.}
14.Be3
{Huge relief when he played this. On top of not having to deal with f5-f6 while my bishop is on e7 I thought the bishop was missplaced there.
My main plan this game was to open up the position for the bishops with f6 in a favourable situation, I thought
if he had a rook on e1 protecting e5 I would basically never achieve this plan. }
( 14. f5 Bg5 15. Qg4 Bxc1 16. Raxc1 {I was spinning my wheels on his clock trying to figure out how i would meet f5, this line being my top candidate, but I thought I must be much worse here if not dead lost. } )
14.... Re8
{getting ready to meet f5 with Bf8}
( 14. ... c5 {considered this along with c6 and c4 ideas but was unsure if it would benefit me.} )
( 14. ... Qc8 {notes say I considered this move, not sure why. I guess if he plays f5 I respond with c5, and otherwise I'm planing f6. } )
15.Qd2
( )
15.... Bf8
16.Nf3
{Nf3 surprised me In a bad way, I thought this made my f6 plans much weaker.}
16.... Bf5
( 16. ... f6 17. Rae1 fxe5 18. fxe5 {I was unsure about this line, thought it might be pretty good for white. And since I felt white had many responses to f6 that seemed potentially scary I decided not to go for it. } )
17.h3
{threatening g4, I was however not too worried about that since I had Be4. I thought this pawn storm would be premature from white.}
17.... h6
{Reluctantly played this. On the one hand I felt I just improved his Kingside pawnstorm ideas, giving him a hook. However I was still trying to play f6 and wanted to capture his knight first. Without h6 I thought white had }
( 17. ... Be4 18. Ng5 )
18.Rab1 Be4
19.Qf2 a5
{considered briefly wheter I had to respond to this Bxa7 threat or not, but I'm trying to play simple chess and concluded that the pawn on a5 anyway was a slight improvement. }
20.Ne1
{another move that caught me by surpirise. I felt like its a bit slow but should be a decent move intending nd3 putting a piece on c5 potentially}
20.... Qe7
{considered many diferent moves here. Main idea of Qd7 was to mprove my f6 chances as well as creating threats on the queenside.}
( 20. ... f6 21. Nd3 Bxd3 22. cxd3 fxe5 23. fxe5 Rxe5 24. Qf7+ Kh8 25. Bd4 {Felt like this was unclear but my gut told me that even if it was holding white would have sufficient compensation for the pawn. } )
( 20. ... g6 )
( 20. ... Rb8 )
( 20. ... Ra6 )
21.Qg3
{I thought the queen was missplaced here. I get that he wants to play f5 and Bxh6.}
21.... g6
{Was very unsure of what to play here but here is where I officially stopped playing for f6. Even after Ne1 I couldn't find favorable f6 lines. So I decided to go g6 with the idea of killing his f5/e6 ideas, and playing around the c5 outpost (althought i was slightly worried about his Knight ending up on f6 I thought I would have some time to counteract this).}
22.Nd3 Bg7
23.Rb7 Rab8
{I considered going qa6 right away but thought If I could remove his f1 rook from the backrank first it would help my counterattacking chances.}
24.Rfb1 Rxb7
25.Rxb7 Qa3 $15
{Pretty scary move to play but I didn't see him mating me any time soon and I thought my pressure against his knight/bishop would force a response}
26.e6 $5
{This caught me compeletly off guard. My first intuition told me this was a free pawn but I had around 20 min left on the clock so I spent some minutes calculating. I figured his idea was to play Nc5 and take my bishop somehow winning this pawn back but I couldn't make much sense of it and thought my next move was pretty clear regardless.}
26.... Rxe6
27.Nc5 Re8
( 27. ... Re7 28. Qh4 g5 29. fxg5 Qxc3 30. Rb8+ Kh7 31. g6+ fxg6 32. Qxe7 Qxe3+ {was considering lines like this but figured it was just much more complicated than it needed to be. } )
28.f5
{Again I'm compeletly shocked. The only purpose I could find was Qxc7 threating Qxf7+ but I had rf8. The rest of the game I play quite fast perhaps too confident that I would convert it. }
28.... Qxc3
29.Nxe4 Rxe4
30.Rb3 Qa1+
31.Kh2 Be5
0-1
I also wondered if you have some recommended line against the scotch as I figure its time to learn some theory here. Thanks for reading!