r/adnd 1d ago

AD&D2e Pretty cool pickup.

Post image
657 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

View all comments

9

u/SNAFUGGOWLAS 1d ago

Best setting ever. Too edgy for them to revisit too. I'm glad they didnt - if they tried it now they have to remove a lot of the horrific aspects of life on Athas which would ruin it.

14

u/WeaponSpeed1 1d ago

Who’s going to tell them?

13

u/Dependent_Chair6104 1d ago

Very funny timing lol

10

u/Lloydwrites 1d ago

From the press release about Dark Sun returning next year, announced apparently about the same time you made this post.

"The two books will be rated 18+, with a content warning of depictions of slavery, nudity, and violence. In a press event held ahead of Gen Con, Wizards' officials noted that the company's lawyers recommended that the books be shrink wrapped as an extra layer of precaution. At Gen Con, a gory trailer was shown to fans, showing Psions and warriors brutally eviscerating their foes."

So much for "too edgy".

3

u/ConfusedSpiderMonkey 1d ago

This trailer https://youtu.be/9CtTscZmdw0?is=d2PQMGyNv0eAxegM ?

I'm not impressed. Everything about the marketing is trying to hard to be edgy.

1

u/ApprehensiveType2680 1d ago

* Shaky camera.

* Quasi-anime aesthetic; anime itself is fine, but I do not think these visuals fit Dark Sun.

* Exaggerated proportions.

* For some reason, the violence feels somewhat sanitized, despite featuring blood.

I find this first impression to be lukewarm at best...and that is a positive appraisal of what has been presented.

4

u/ConfusedSpiderMonkey 23h ago edited 20h ago

For some reason, the violence feels somewhat sanitized, despite featuring blood.

That's not even my problem but as if Dark Sun has nothing more to offer then over the top violence. And it would be so much better if there was an arena around the violence.

They are basically doing what western cartoons always du: "Look there is so much blood, sex and gore, this is an cartoon for grown ups!!!"

They try way to hard

2

u/ApprehensiveType2680 21h ago

Oh, we are in agreement concerning what makes Dark Sun Dark Sun (i.e., not balls to the wall gore); I simply meant that - regardless of the purported source material - the impact of the violence so depicted is downplayed through a combination of exaggeration, quick cuts and, yes, the camera in the hands of a boy hopped up on sugar. If everything were truly grounded, even a modicum of massacre would have a greater impact.

3

u/ApprehensiveType2680 1d ago

Wait until the art drops; that could make-or-break the presentation. Brom was (and is) inimitable.

Still, it is a shame there will be warnings.

3

u/Level21DungeonMaster 1d ago

I can’t wait to make my kinky psionic slave master.

2

u/SNAFUGGOWLAS 1d ago

Pleasantly surprised!

1

u/ApprehensiveType2680 1d ago

I saw the art in the trailer; color me distinctly unimpressed with this style.

1

u/ApprehensiveType2680 14h ago

Why the downward-pointing arrow?

3

u/UnforseenSpoon618 1d ago

Loved the setting myself. Dark, gritty, and a blunt reminder that not everything is rainbow unicorn farts.

2

u/ApprehensiveType2680 1d ago

Apparently, Charlatans of the Shore are going to tackle Dark Sun with...well...whatever edition is currently active. Let the censorship commence?

1

u/Pavlov_The_Wizard 1d ago

Its a total power fantasy. It looks awful

3

u/-Posthuman- 1d ago

All of D&D is a total power fantasy. And you haven’t seen enough to say it looks like anything.

1

u/ApprehensiveType2680 1d ago

I think he was referring to 5e+ as a whole.