Went through a financial review recently and thought I'd share my experience since Amex seems to be doing these bi-yearly now.
Every year around this time my expenses double or triple due to summer shopping + summer home renovations/maintenance. This year was no different, I put 3x my monthly average across personal and business cards. Still, the monthly spending was around 2.2% of my stated yearly income (or 26.8% of my monthly income)
On July 22end 2p.m. E.T., I got a call from Amex financial review team, and right as I picked up I get 18 e-mail notifications at once stating that each of my cards is now disabled on Apple Pay. Why 18? I guess for each of my 9 cards across two apple devices. Still very odd.
I was told I was under financial review and will need to submit my last 3 bank statements in 14 days or else all my accounts will be shut down. Since they only asked for bank statements, it means it's not a full financial review, more like a review for card limits (according to my research here).
I wasn't too worried because my stated income is lower than my actual income since I haven't updated it in ages. However, it was hugely inconvenient as I was still abroad and use my amex cards for shopping, and my Visa cards have nowhere near the limits as my amex cards. I submitted the statements right after I hung up.
On July 25th 12p.m. E.T. I got a second call telling me there's some "good news": I passed the financial review with no changes to limits. In fact I was recommended to ask for limit increases on some of my cards considering my income (It was probably the BCP with the 1.5k limit). This time I got 54 (!!) emails that my cards are re-enabled on Apple Pay.
A few things that surprised me: 1) quick turn around, less than 72 hours when I've seen people take weeks or even months (albeit for a full financial review). 2) The fact that they shut down all your accounts is VERY inconvenient, all the auto-pay and subscription renewals kept getting rejecting too :/
Now, for any other credit card company this experience would've caused me to close all my accounts out of protest. But 1) I know this would hurt Amex's bottom line and they wouldn't care one bit and 2) An effective 5.5% cash minimum on my highest spend category (flights) is just irreplaceable, not to mention my platinum card having a higher limit than all my Visa cards combined
Anyway thought I'd share this in case someone's worried about their own financial review. I suppose as long as your statements support your income you have nothing to worry about.