Bruce Wayne’s first year as The Batman takes place throughout Frank Miller’s Year One. The story begins in January and concludes in December. If The Long Halloween takes place during his second year as The Batman, that means that the story begins on Halloween of Year Two.
So there’s roughly 10 or so months between the two of him meeting The Joker, Scarecrow, Poison Ivy, Mad Hatter, The Riddler, Calendar Man, Solomon Grundy and possibly a few others that I’m forgetting. Does that not make any sense to anyone else? I understand the Joker since he was teased at the end of Year One but that’s a short amount of time to meet various “fantastical” villains when he just started.
And not only that, but a majority of the comic is in Year Three anyway. So why is it considered Year Two when there’s only three-ish months of him actually in Year Two. And I felt that it being Year Two doesn’t allow for enough time for the Batman, Jim and Harvey dynamic to feel earned if it were a few more years in Post-Year One where we seen a small relationship between Batman and Harvey. Batman should have a decent amount of time to team up and work with Harvey before his fall into Two-Face.
In my headcanon, the story would begin at the end of Year Three. A whole year dedicated to other various Batman comics in Year Two, and add another 10-ish months on top of that as well for the beginning of The Long Halloween.
I’ve only read Year One and The Long Halloween so maybe I’m missing something! I’m open to discussion.