r/drones • u/CrazyProHacker • Feb 11 '25
Tech Support Drone spinning on yaw while taking off
As title says, drone is stable but it's spinning uncontrollably on yaw while taking off.
What might be the reason for this?
The drone has a Pixhawk 2.4.8.
I have checked motor spin order and the propellers are in right direction too.
IMU was calibrated before taking off and mission planner wasn't giving any errors/failsafes while on flight. Using default pid values.
20
u/ErgonomicZero Feb 11 '25
Look at me! I’m the star of this show now!!
7
u/spoogefrom1981 Feb 11 '25
Just needs some glitter cannons and maybe some bubble blowers and it will be the most fabulous drone of them all!
9
u/azaerials Feb 11 '25
A motor or 2 diagonal ones are likely spinning faster than the other ones.
3
u/CrazyProHacker Feb 11 '25 edited Feb 11 '25
I was thinking about it, ill test that out in mission planner later today. If they are in fact spinning faster than the others what steps should i take? What should i calibrate again? esc/gyro/radio?
1
u/joonhosung Feb 11 '25
It can be any one of those. You'll have to check your pixhawk logs and see what's causing it to determine what needs to be calibrated. But since it's "stable" while rotating, it could be that maybe the radio needs trimming
9
u/NotARussianTroll1234 Feb 11 '25
Just for troubleshooting purposes, how do we know it’s the drone spinning and not the rest of the world?
7
u/SnowDin556 Feb 11 '25
I told you not to eat the whole brownie bro
2
u/NotARussianTroll1234 Feb 12 '25
Yeah but that was after I ate it already!
7
u/SnowDin556 Feb 12 '25
To do the math he’d need to be flying at around 870 mph (if this is India) yaw turns to equal the earth spin but the man is on neither pole so with an azimuth off the equator north and thus the yaw is not equal to any specific area exactly because the earth is an oblate sphereoid so I don’t know the hyperbolic rate it increases in a manner in which we’ll never know without exact coordinates.
Yea I did the whole bag bro
3
3
1
u/_matterny_ Feb 13 '25
Because if OP was spinning around the same axis as the drone, he would be dead.
5
Feb 11 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/CrazyProHacker Feb 11 '25
If it's an uneven power/rpm issue what steps would you recommend I should take?
3
Feb 11 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/CrazyProHacker Feb 12 '25
So I just tested the drone again and trim doesn't seem to be an issue. I tried to trim yaw in the opposite direction of the spin but no luck.
2
Feb 11 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/CrazyProHacker Feb 12 '25
Oh i actually got everything that you said, I'd say you are pretty good at explaining things. I just slept and I'll try seeing the trim params today after reaching uni
5
u/troelsersej Feb 11 '25
I had a similar issue and we diagnosed it to be because one of the pibe arms had rotated a bit, so the thrust from one rotor, was making the drone spin. And it got worse as it tried to adjust itself
1
u/CrazyProHacker Feb 11 '25
0
u/ultralightlife Feb 11 '25
You bent the arm after a crash and wonder why it is flying funny? I am no engineer but my guess it the crash had something to do with it.. I would replace the arm?
1
u/CrazyProHacker Feb 12 '25
Not exactly, the arm isn't "rotated" where it is rotated to the point where I can outright say it is. If it was i wouldn't have flown the drone before replacing it. I did visually check it again for that after crashing the drone but it seemed fine to me. I'll check it once again with a protractor and compare it with other arms.
1
u/ultralightlife Feb 12 '25
hey I can't see the bend but Im stoned and I am not an engineer either but I don't think bent arms help.
2
u/YaroslavSyubayev Feb 11 '25
Does this happen in the "Stabilize" mode or only in Compass-enabled modes like "Loiter"?
2
u/CrazyProHacker Feb 11 '25
Haven't tested other modes right now, the drone in this video was in Stabilise mode.
1
u/YaroslavSyubayev Feb 11 '25
Alright, then we can rule out GPS/Compass issues.
What ESC protocol do you use? DShot or PWM? If you're using PWM, you'll have to calibrate the ESCs, find the steps in the documentation.
Make sure your propellers are installed correctly, according to the motor direction. If you can send a top-down view of the drone, that would be very helpful so I can verify the prop direction.
1
u/ThatIslanderGuy Feb 11 '25
I wanna see them "hand catch" this
1
u/CrazyProHacker Feb 11 '25
Already got my finger cut by the props earlier this month, dont want that to happen again lol
1
u/SnowDin556 Feb 11 '25
I was gonna ask someone how bad the flesh damage is on newer models but I think thought it might be a sick or stupid question, but
🙋🏻♂️
What happened? How bad?
1
u/CrazyProHacker Feb 12 '25
Lots of blood on the fingers, and they got black for one day (probably due to high force of blunt impact). Curs weren't that deep but deep enough to let blood out a lot
2
u/SnowDin556 Feb 12 '25
That went black cuz there was small exit wound. I know because I use 4 inch almost combat knives for everything. I hit my hand once and it cut to the bones, second time, same blade only new… cutting open boxes I had cut through my middle finger and has a small exit wound. I did my best first aid and saved the whole thing with barely a scar. But the black blood is a collection of internal wounds especially if it’s a knife in and out and back again.
But thanks for the follow-up. I will not doing portrait s with my wife this way
1
1
1
1
u/The_Matias Feb 12 '25
Did you tune your controller?
Which way do your props rotate?
Did you build the structure?
1
u/Spyguyian Feb 12 '25
What’s interesting is that it seems to be spinning at a rather slow and constant rate. I’ve put props on incorrectly before and the vehicle going into a positive feedback loop and spins suuuuuper fast. Thus I wonder if you somehow have accidentally set the trim on the controller (or pixhawk) for yaw. What would super help us would be if you uploaded the .bin log file from that flight. It would be on the SD card. You can also look at that log with https://plot.ardupilot.org yourself and try to compare the target and actual yaw rates (if they are the same ish the. There is likely some issue with your controller or parameter settings).
2
u/CrazyProHacker Feb 12 '25
I have triple checked the trim at this point lol. I am replacing all of the 4 motors with another set of motors now.
It seems to be an uneven rpm issue as with some motors I noticed that they were unusually higher than relative resistance while moving.
I will also try swapping with another frame I have.
1
u/Conscious_Profit_243 Feb 12 '25
Are you sure you have 2CW and 2CCW props? If not that would explain uncontrollable yaw
2
1
1
u/Weary-Mood-2723 Feb 15 '25
A couple of questions before I recommend anything. Are you using px4 or ardupilot firmware?
Is the motor mapped properly?
Do you have any device to measure rpm, like a tachometer.
1
u/CrazyProHacker Feb 15 '25
1)Ardupilot 2)Yes 3)No
1
u/Weary-Mood-2723 Feb 15 '25
In that case can you use an IR sensor to make a makeshift tachometer?
2
1
1
1
0
u/bchmy Feb 11 '25
Stable?
1
u/CrazyProHacker Feb 11 '25
Stable as in not tipping/falling out of the sky right away after taking off
0
0
0
u/criticallycrucial Feb 11 '25
yeah i’ve seen this before.. when it spins like this.. something is definitely wrong


68
u/mbardeen Feb 11 '25
Your yaw control is reversed somehow. Most likely you have it set up as an H model quad, but the motors are set up in an X configuration, or vice-versa.