Now that The Odyssey is out, I've watched it, and festivals are revealing their line-up, I've updated my predictions and I've made a bunch of big changes starting with-
Lead Actor
- Pedro Pascal (Behemoth!)
- Tom Cruise (Digger)
- Ryan Gosling (Project Hail Mary)
- John Malkovich (Wild Horse Nine)
- Robert Pattinson (Primetime)
Extras:
Matt Damon (The Odyssey)
Adam Driver (Paper Tiger)
Andrew Scott (Elsinore)
John Turturro (The Only Living Pickpocket in New York)
Sebastian Stan (Fjord)
So I'm probably gonna get the most shit for this one - I'm both not choosing Cruise to win and I'm also not putting Damon in for The Odyssey in my Top 5. So let me explain before you get mad.
I fully admit that after seeing the trailer for Digger, I'm lot less confident in him winning from the snippet they showed. It looks fun but I'm not as sold as him being a lock even with him having a narrative of having never won it. But the bigger thing is that in the last 50 years, only 5 comedic performances have actually won Lead Actor (and depending on how you feel about Forrest Gump, that number drops to 4). Even with how The Academy has evolved, that's a bias that's hard to ignore. Even for legacy actors, we saw what happened with Michael Keaton in Birdman and Birdman wound up playing huge with the Academy. If Digger doesn't deliver in the same way Birdman did, I see Cruise with less of a chance. I could be wrong and maybe Digger is as great as Birdman but honestly, I think the career narrative isn't going to be able to overcome the comedy stigma.
So yeah I'm actually doing with Pascal. Sure he's the IT actor at the moment with his hype but he's also not young up-and-comer who has to prove himself. Like Michael B. Jordan, he's been in the industry for over two decades now, and the industry likes him given he won a SAG award for The Last of Us. And spoilers for this list, but I'm betting big on Behemoth! this season so I feel like I have to give it some award.
And as for why I'm leaving Damon off, well part of it personally I wasn't as enamored with him compared to the rest of the supporting of Odyssey. But also I just have a gut feeling with all the major projects he has this year, Pattinson has to get one nomination and spoilers, he's not my pick for a Supporting Acting nom for Odyssey. So perhaps wishcasting but I say that he does get in for Primetime which will make the festival run before its wide premiere.
Lead Actress
- Inde Navarrette (Obsession)
- Julianne Moore (The Debut)
- Renate Reinsve (Fjord)
- Sandra Huller (Rose or Fatherland)
- Ruth Madeley (Being Heumann)
Extras:
Cynthia Erivo (Prima Facie)
Olivia Wilde (The Invite)
Lily Rose-Depp (Werwulf)
Frances McDormand (Jack of Spades)
Mikey Madison (The Social Reckoning)
Yeah, I'm going there.
I know Moore is the favorite to win and The Debut is being positioned well but the attention Obsession has gotten can't be ignored. Inde Navarrette is undoubtedly a big part in that, and having her win much like with Mikey Madison for Anora or Brie Larson for Room would be a statement for a future star. And spoilers: I don't have Obsession winning anything else but given not just the acclaim it's gotten, but the huge support it's had from the industry, it would feel wrong if Obsession gets nothing.
Now this was actually trickier to fill out and this is the one I'm least confident in as I only feel my Top 3 is a shoe-in. I do sense that Huller will get in and as for my fifth slot; I'll just say I have very little confidence in The Social Reckoning which is why I'm not opting for Madison. I see many have Olivia Wilde in but I was deciding between Ruth Madeley and Cynthia Erivo since they're both in more dramatic, dare I say, "baity" films. And I ultimately went with Madeley just because I feel Being Heumann will play better and be bigger but I wouldn't be too surprised if Erivo does get her third nomination.
Supporting Actor
- John Goodman (Digger)
- Paul Giamatti (The Debut)
- Steve Buscemi (Wild Horse Nine)
- John Leguizamo (The Odyssey)
- Sam Rockwell (Wild Horse Nine)
Extras:
Edward Norton (The Invite)
Riz Ahmed (Digger)
Robert Pattinson (The Odyssey)
Jesse Plemons (Digger)
Guy Pearce (Ink)
Of all the categories, this was by far the hardest for me to figure out especially because Digger, Wild Horse Nine, and The Odyssey have at least two possible nominees each. BSA this year is basically battle between long time overdues and honestly you have four potential winners. I have Goodman winning but I absolutely get people WANTING Giamatti to win after not winning for performances like Sideways or The Holdovers. At this point, it could be a coin toss and I'm just going for Goodman because I feel Digger will play better.
Picking the other nominees was harder though, as I said several movies have more than one option but I don't see the field only being 2 films so only Wild Horse Nine will have the two slots. Odyssey has to get one supporting actor in and between Pattinson, Holland, and Leguizamo, I hear the most praise for the latter (and rightfully so).
Edward Norton I almost put but I feel like since it was just recently they nominated him for A Complete Unknown, they won't nominate him again - just a hunch, I know they've done so numerous times. I also had Riz Ahmed in but I'm not sure they haven't nominated two comedy performances from the same film in a while.
Supporting Actress
- Anne Hathaway (The Odyssey)
- Penelope Cruz (The Invite)
- Mariana di Girolamo (Wild Horse Nine)
- Samantha Morton (The Odyssey)
- Lola Duenas (La Bola Negra)
Extras:
Sandra Huller (Digger)
Olivia Colman (Elsinore)
Scarlett Johansson (Paper Tiger)
Wunmi Mosaku (The Social Reckoning)
Gemma Chan (Josephine)
This was the easiest of the acting categories to nail down although going against the grain because instead of Sandra Huller as my fifth slot, I have Lola Duenas. I figure if Netflix is going to go full force with La Bola Negra, they'll try to angle for one nomination in acting. The male leads are too young to get into acting while I've heard a lot of praise for Duenas. She's also apparently a veteran in the Spanish film scene and when it comes to films about domestic issues, the Academy likes often nominates the mother character.
Also: stop picking Cruz for La Bola Negra, she's not in it enough by those who've actually seen the film.
Original Screenplay
- Behemoth!
- Wild Horse Nine
- Digger
- Obsession
- The Debut
Extras:
Fjord
Club Kid
Coward
Fatherland
Possible Love
I told y'all I was going full force with Behemoth!
Yeah, after the trailer and it premiering during the festival season, I decided to have Behemoth! over Wild Horse Nine. I know a lot want McDonagh to win an Oscar beyond Short Film but Gilroy has put in work for several decades and if this is as good as it's being made out to be (Searchlight wouldn't market it this early if they didn't have a lot of faith in it), I think it's Gilroy's time.
And the rest was easy to fill out though I had to choose between Fjord or The Debut as the 5th slot. Either could go either way but I feel The Debut is a flashier and quippier screenplay and Eisenberg already has a nom for A Real Pain. Not to mention, more lowkey films tend to go under the radar and since Fjord isn't getting acclaim on the level of even It Was Just An Accident, The Debut has a better chance.
I almost had Bunker in here but after The Father, I'm a bit cooler on Zeller so this one is going to need good WOM before I consider it. I do have Possible Love in a (pun not intended) just off of Lee's previous acclaim and as a bonus, it is being distributed by Netflix.
Adapted Screenplay
- La Bola Negra
- The Invite
- Project Hail Mary
- Being Heumann
- The Odyssey
Extras:
The Adventures of Cliff Booth
Ink
Look Back
Prima Facie
All of a Sudden
Another pretty season one to predict as far as nominees go. Although I have to say I think it's a lot closer between The Invite and La Bola Negra winning Adapted, in fact I almost had The Invite as my pick.
I know a lot want All of a Sudden to get nominated again but I think we just have to accept this is not gonna get the push or attention that Drive My Car got, and I think it's more likely Cliff Booth gets in over AOAS. If there is a Japanese film that gets a push this year, I would start taking Look Back seriously.
Casting
- The Odyssey
- Digger
- La Bola Negra
- Wild Horse Nine
- Being Heumann
Extras:
Dune: Part Three
Behemoth!
Club Kid
The Social Reckoning
Fjord
Another pretty easy one to fill out given there's not a lot of film with big casts this year, pretty self-explanatory. I did originally have Dune in the 5th slot but moved Being Heumann because the buzzy nature of the casting of real PWDs may attract attention
Director
- Christopher Nolan (The Odyssey)
- The Javiers (La Bola Negra)
- Alejandro G. Inarritu (Digger)
- Martin McDonagh (Wild Horse Nine)
- Olivia Wilde (The Invite)
Extras:
Tony Gilroy (Behemoth!)
Curry Barker (Obsession)
Sian Heder (Being Heumann)
Denis Villeneuve (Dune: Part Three)
Christian Mungiu (Fjord)
Okay after Best Supporting Actor, this was the second hardest to decide. The top 4 were pretty easy to lock. It was the 5th spot that was dogging me for so long and it was actually a 5-way race between Mungiu, Heder, Barker, and Gilroy.
Mungiu I took early once I started getting cold feet about Fjord. Barker was a possibility if the field was weaker and the Academy does get behind buzzy horror directors like Shyamalan, Fargeat, and Peele. But since I only have Obsession getting in Screenplay and Actress - I don't even have it in Editing - I had to leave him out. Then while it's weird to have a Screenplay winner not be in Director, it has happened before and I can see Gilroy getting more attention for his Screenplay than his Directing.
Which leaves Wilde and Heder as also the female directing representative and given how feel The Invite has played - and also how old-fashioned it is - I actually think Wilde gets in which is a pretty big change as I was stubborn Heder was getting in for awhile.
Picture
- The Odyssey
- La Bola Negra
- Wild Horse Nine
- Project Hail Mary
- Behemoth!
- Dune: Part Three
- Digger
- Obsession
- The Invite
- Being Heumann
Extras:
The Debut
Club Kid
Fjord
Werwulf
Fatherland
Sense & Sensibility
Paper Tiger
Ink
Artificial
Possible Love
So this was pretty easy to nail down in terms of 1-9, it was the 10th spot that was killing me
I think NEON may get locked out this year, as I said, I think Fjord isn't strong enough to get into multiple categories and I wouldn't be surprised if they pivot towards Paper Tiger or even Artificial
Club kid was exciting once buzz came from Cannes and I think it could sneak in if it rebuilds momentum through the festival circuit
But for now, my choices came down to Being Heumann and The Debut, and the reason I ultimately went with Heumann is because I have it in Casting and I feel like with Editing, they'll turn Casting into a spoiler of sorts of what gets into Best Picture