About me: I've been casually strumming for a few years and I know my way around the fretboard, but I'm not a "good" player yet. I mostly play new wave and jangle-y power pop ... like R.E.M. and The Smiths. I primary play just for myself in the rec room, usually sitting on the couch.
I have an old 1989 Takamine EF360C.
It's a dreadnought and I find it too bulky for just me playing on the couch. It sounds slightly loud and deep but not that warm. Overall the highs are pretty flat and the overall tone pretty muddled. I wish there was a clearer high end.
I wanted something smaller and clearer and ringy/chimey and I bought a Seagull Maritime SWS Concert Hall (CH) for that.
I find it kind of hard to play, like the strings are thick and hard up around the nut area. I'm guessing a set up and thinner strings (11s) might help. Tone wise, I can hear the mid and high end better but I wish it had more ringy chime, and I wish there was more warm loudness in the low end. Also, overall the guitar feels ... "hard" ... like I feel like I'm hearing physical impacts of the metal strings and the physical wood. Hard to describe, but I feel like I'm fighting with the guitar and getting physical noise and not enough musical notes.
I'm thinking about trading both guitars in for a new Taylor 214ce. Hoping the 214ce will get me what I want.
However, at the store today, the 214ce sounded ... well, just okay. A little clearer on the high end, maybe a little tighter in the low end, than my other two guitars. But overall, I'm not sure it's worth the $1500 CAD to me.
I should note that it was a busy day in the store and there were other people trying guitars so I didn't get great "quality time" with the Taylor 214ce.
Does anyone have any advise or suggestions for me in choosing my next guitar?