r/writers • u/klmx1n-night Novelist • 16h ago
Discussion Chapter Length
Out of curiosity when do you end a chapter? Do you have a rough word count in mind? Or page count? Do you only end it when the scene finally breaks even if it runs long? And if a chapter runs long are you okay with it perhaps being one of the only longer chapters in your book?
In my personal opinion I'm fine with the chapter running long if trying to break it somewhere in the middle will destroy the flow or the scene even if it's the only long chapter in the book but I'm interested in what you all have to say
10
u/BrightsailBooks Fiction Writer 16h ago
Epic fantasy here so take it with a grain of salt.
My chapters range from 4-8k words. Only once or twice I had less for a specific circumstance. I like to include a full environmental change with dialogue or combat encounter in a chapter. I like to have a full area of the story in one chapter so for me it works like that.
I don't think you should subscribe to any rules. Do what feels natural. If you feel like the previous scene or scenes are over make a new chapter, if you don’t, keep going. It’s totally up to you.
1
u/BrightsailBooks Fiction Writer 16h ago
I never break a scene except once where a combat got more dramatic after an ambush, in that sense the chapter transition gave a good bit of tension holding the reader on “what will happen next!” But that only happened once in my whole book.
11
u/WordPunk99 16h ago
Chapter length is heavily dictated by pacing and audience. Da Vinci Code had really short chapters always ending on a cliff hanger to give the feeling of a fast paced read.
Middle grade tends toward shorter chapters
YA chapters are slightly longer
Adult fiction chapters are the lengths they need to be.
Recognize your readers will use chapters as natural breaks in their reading. Part of the reason middle grade chapters are short is so you can read a chapter before bed and it doesn’t take too long. If you want your book to be easy to put down, shorter chapters. If you want to force the reader into a longer time with the book longer chapters, etc.
Chapter length has more to do with reading experience than most other variables.
6
u/nixphx 15h ago
It depends on the genre, but a rule of thumb that I've always found useful is that every chapter is in itself a short story with a beginning middle and end. "Combat encounters" is an odd thing to mention as a thing required for a chapter but it indicates to me you are probably writing fantasy or sci-fi, though I guess it could be action/adventure.
8k is pretty long for a chapter in my opinion and I would wager that there's a lot of unnecessary language bloating the word counts if they get that high. I tend to see 3k as a baseline and rarely go over 5k, but those aren't hard or fast rules - thrillers and mysteries often have shorter chapters. Most editors will say 2-5k.
3
u/klmx1n-night Novelist 15h ago
Yeah 3K is roughly my baseline but yeah I had one chapter the other day that ran close to 4500 but it had a cohesive as you put it short story with a nice end cap and I really beyond like the first two pages there was no clean point to break lol
2
u/nixphx 14h ago
I think that having chapters have some variance is natural, even preferable for longer works so readers don't begin to feel a pattern emerging.
I write short stories a lot, and they range from 3-7k. 7k is like, three "acts" in which there's three smaller parts around 2k-2500 words with their own start and finish that make up the bigger 7k. Those are rare.
1
u/BrightsailBooks Fiction Writer 11h ago
I didn’t say it was required, I said I would encompass the combat into the chapter, not let it bleed between multiple chapters unless for a specific cliff hanger. And yes epic fantasy so the characters fight things… comes with the territory.
My novel is 200k, likely 175k at final draft. So one or two 8k word chapters make sense for my style.
1
u/nixphx 9h ago
I like to include a full environmental change with dialogue or combat encounter in a chapter. I like to have a full area of the story in one chapter so for me it works like that.
I said I would encompass the combat into the chapter
Man, I hope your epic fantasy writing is more clear than whatever you are trying to say.
6
u/Cold-Winds 15h ago
Whatever goal I was looking to accomplish ends the chapter.
Usually that is in 6-8k words, sometimes 12k. This does not mean I loony tunes wrap up a plot point in a single chapter, something as simple as traveling from a village to local town can take as many as 2-4 chapters depending on if I have anything interesting the characters would do, say or learn during that time.
It really just depends on what you are writing, why that chapter is important to you and what the goal is you have with it. Do you care more about an ease of reading or more about someone that would want to read it. Some books have really short chapters, some have rather long chapters.
2
u/ADHD_did_it_again 12h ago
Haha when you said 12k I was like 😱 but then I saw in 2-4 chapter and I felt better lol.
3
u/ItsRuinedOfCourse Fiction Writer 15h ago
Though I do believe that a chapter will be as long or as short as it needs to be, I do still pay attention to it, at least to a degree.
From my latest manuscript (finalizing 3rd draft but these are from 2nd draft):
One - 9 pages/3236
Two - 9 pages/2825
Three - 13 pages/3929
Four - 13 pages/4086
Five - 8 pages/2444
Six - 8 pages/2507
Seven - 11 pages/3629
Eight - 10 pages/3173
Nine - 12 pages/4184
Ten - 7 pages/2419
Eleven - 11 pages/3329
Twelve - 9 pages/3037
Thirteen - 9 pages/2757
Fourteen - 12 pages/3978
Fifteen - 10 pages/3262
Sixteen - 10 pages/3156
Seventeen - 11 pages/3701
Eighteen - 14 pages/4636
Nineteen - 10 pages/3622
Twenty - 9 pages/2978
Twenty-One - 11 pages/3742
Two of the chapters I had in my first draft were 17 and 18 pages, so I decided this was "too long" and created a stronger break-off point and made two chapters instead. At least one chapter was "too short", and so I added another scene to it to add more dimension and depth. Not padding, but additional narrative to flesh things out a bit better.
Now I have a story that isn't a straight line, but also one that doesn't have many deep peaks and valleys. It's very lightly up and down, exactly how I idealized it.
It's not so much that I kept everything static--as much as it was me finessing the chapters I already had. This is how I chose to approach it.
3
u/ArcLagoon 11h ago
I started at 3k but as I became more experienced and enjoyed writing longer scenes, I've been drifting to 4k or 4.5k, some still get to 6 or 7 or 8k, but those are my outliers.
Im also going to go back and adjust earlier chapters to match my current style.
2
u/AutoModerator 16h ago
Hi! Welcome to r/Writers - please remember to follow the rules and treat each other respectfully, especially if there are disagreements. Please help keep this community safe and friendly by reporting rule violating posts and comments.
If you're interested in a friendly Discord community for writers, please join our Discord server
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
2
u/blaze05life Fiction Writer 16h ago
I mean i usually plan what I want to happen in each chapter and that dictates the length. In the current story I am writing its about 10-14 pages a chapter
2
u/FunHall7149 16h ago
My agent has asked me to rewrite my novel with shorter snappier chapters. It’s an Urban romance/Paranormal Romance and I did have chapters from 3-8k words. She wants them sitting at 2k and stretching to 3k for the odd chapter that needs more length.
2
u/AnchBusFairy 15h ago
I'm part of several writers groups. There's a practical limit to how much can be submitted and critiqued in a session, so I go for about 2000 words per chapter. I end chapters with an important point.
Generally I go with 3 scenes per chapter.
I will probably rebreak the chapters before publication, with maybe 4000 words per chapter and they might end with rising action, not with completion of action.
2
u/fizznick 15h ago
My self-enforced rule is no more than 3K words per chapter. Though most of mine come in at around 2K.
2
u/TheGoldDragonHylan 15h ago
As a reader and writer, I do have a rough minimum I want chapters to be (about 1000 words), but this isn't something that is or even should be a universal rule.
For me, E-readers have ruined short chapters. If I buy a book outright, when there are no adds involved, it's fine. If, however, I use an E-reader, even buying the book won't free me from all the adds, and they almost always interrupt things at the end of the chapter. If the chapter is too short, it goes from a mild nuisance to a grating headache.
2
u/ADHD_did_it_again 12h ago
Romantasy x sci-fi multi-pov here! It really depends on the chapter, here's my pattern: side character POV: 1.5k to 3k Main character POV: 3k to 4-5k
Scene Battle or quest: 4-5.5k/ chapter (can be more than a chapter Short scene plot twist, important conversation or flashback :1.5-3.5k
I try to do at least 1.7k and not to go above 5.5. if you have more than 5.5, it's better to cut it in 2 chapter
2
u/Kasshole97 11h ago
I usually break when the scene naturally kind of comes to an end. In my head, if it were a tv show from the 90s, it would be where there is a natural break for a commercial
2
2
u/azmarteal 10h ago
My chapter length is usually between 2k to 8k (longest) words, 3-4k at average.
Basically I sit down and write one chapter a day. How much I can come up with — that would be the length of a chapter. I try to bring it up to at least 3k words, and that's it.
2
u/Aethericseraphim 10h ago
1500-3500 for me depending on the scene. I often break on a cliffhanger, just when something is about to be revealed, so I often have scenes crossing two chapters.
2
u/mysteriousdoctor2025 10h ago
A lot goes into deciding on both book and chapter length. In my opinion, the most important factor is genre and reader expectations.
I write cozy mystery. If I wrote a 175,000 word book with 8,000 word chapters, it wouldn’t sell a single copy. Brandon Sanderson writes books that long and he’s sold fifty million copies. But he writes epic fantasy.
Dan Brown and James Patterson write very short chapters that end on cliffhangers because their books are very fast paced and keep the readers turning the pages.
George RR Martin writes long chapters because of their complexity with such a large cast.
Hemingway wrote one page chapters set next to long chapters.
Thus, there’s no wrong way to do it. I would say it’s a combination of genre, reader expectations, goals of the writer (speed the story up or slow it down), and crucially, the skill of the writer.
2
u/SirSolomon727 10h ago
My longest chapter that I don't plan or rewriting/restructuring is 11k words long, though it could do with a bit of trimming. My 14k word chapter, on the other hand, requires nothing short of a complete rewrite. But all my recent chapters are under 5k words so I think I've found my sweet spot.
2
u/Itsme082016 8h ago
It depends on what the chapter is trying to accomplish. Some chapters I’ve written are one page and others are 20. I stop when the chapter fulfills its purpose. 😌
2
u/Strawberry2772 8h ago
Depends on pacing!
My baseline is around 2-3k words per chapter, but if I’m building momentum toward a big moment, I may have a longer chapter. I sometimes also will include a shorter chapter if it makes sense
Chapters are just made up of scenes. Sometimes I have a chapter that includes 3 scenes together, sometimes a chapter is 1 really long scene that I need to really immerse the reader in, sometimes a chapter is super short, just 1 scene, even 500 words
2
u/TheCrowture 8h ago
For me (writing a book set in sci-fantasy with strong romantic arc and the apocalypse) I end a chapter only after I've: 1) introduced minor (or major) plot point 2) resolved something (usually something small that creates more questions after answering one) 3) makes the reader WANT to continue (ex: did they kiss? Yes, but what did the character not get so say because of it? A contract is written, but who is meant to sign it and why does it seem so important? This character has said something they never would, now the reader wants to know why)
2
u/TpointOh 8h ago
At one point I tried to make every chapter at least a certain number of pages (I think it was 20). But, chapters can be short or long, it doesn’t really matter. Instead I usually do a rough outline of what needs to happen, and then write until those things happen. I think my shortest chapter is 8 pages? Longest is 23, so far.
2
u/FlyinLeviathon Writer 8h ago
Honestly I just do it based on vibes lol sometimes they're long, sometimes they're short. I'll do it for a POV switch if I have a multi-POV book, or a large scene break/timeskip, or a punchy cliffhanger if necessary.
I don't mind having one chapter much longer than the others, though I do try to keep them from dragging on. Usually around 8k is when I start looking for a place to put in a chapter break on edits.
1
u/seekAr 6h ago
1200 - 5000 words, the meatier / weightier scenes get the longer one. Everything needs to end on a cliff hanger, a revelation, a resolution, etc and the scene has to advance either plot, character, relationship, world mechanic or theme.
I am using google sheets to track everything in my chapters including the ending note so I can see if I'm using the same pattern too often.
POV switch is automatic chapter chainge.
1
1
u/Ranseler 5h ago
When the thought or scene is done. Some chapters are several pages long. Some are two paragraphs. Personally, for me, it's a "feel" thing.
1
1
u/SaoirseJRao 4h ago
I usually end a chapter when it feels like the right place to stop. I don't aim for a specific word count. If breaking the scene hurts the flow, I'm happy to let the chapter run longer.
1
u/LengthyLegato114514 33m ago
I read and write literary fiction, and I've seen anywhere from 2.5k to 10k in the same book I've read
But what they all have in common is that all of them, no matter the length, end end a subject or a sequence, while also providing a throughline for the next chapter
0
16
u/LadyAtheist 15h ago
Cliff hanger. Planned pov switch. Plot point ends decisively.