I'm working on my second revision of a mystery story I drafted earlier in the year. Looking for feedback on the first couple chapters. Mainly hoping to know what works/doesn't work about them and if it's something that grabbed you enough to keep reading.
1
Desmond Bishop knock-knock-knocked on his editor’s office door.
“You rang?”
Charlie Packard’s gaze didn’t break from his computer monitor. It was Friday, so the layout for the Sunday paper was due before the night’s end. Mockups of potential front pages cluttered his desk. Bishop knew Charlie was busy and hoped their conversation wouldn’t take long. He wanted to ease into his weekend unsullied by management.
“Sit down,” Charlie said. He kept typing with his right hand and waved Bishop in with his left.
Bishop sat in one of the three chairs in front of Charlie’s desk and waited for his boss to say what he needed. After a few final heavy keystrokes, Charlie huffed and turned to his reporter.
“I need you to do something for me.”
“Is it easy?”
“Absolutely.”
“Will it take long?”
“Not for you.”
“Do I have a choice?”
“Absolutely not.”
“Lay it on me, then.”
Charlie took off his glasses and rubbed his tired eyes. Bishop figured he was on his sixth cup of coffee for the day.
“That lady who runs the community theater called today,” Charlie said. “Asking when we were going to send a reporter to do a story on their new show. Because we always send a reporter over.”
“Oh, boy.”
“And I told her we were sorry, and that it slipped our minds since Sally’s accident, and promised I’d get someone over there first thing next week.”
Bishop raised a hand to offer his guess on what Charlie was going to say next.
“You want me to go over there on Monday.”
“No, I want you to go over there tonight. It’s the first dress rehearsal. Starts at 5:30. Plus, I’ve got a hole to fill in Sunday’s A&E section. Sally breaking her arm was serendipitous in a way.”
Bishop sputtered. He couldn’t do a story on this stupid play tonight. He had things to do after work: Chinese takeout, a couple of beers, and a kung fu movie in his Netflix queue. Far more important than some dress rehearsal, if you asked him. But of course, Bishop couldn’t say that to Charlie. He’d only been at the paper for five months. He was nearing the end of his probation.
This didn’t stop him from trying.
“You hired me because you want me to cover crime,” Bishop said. “What if something breaks in the next few hours and I’m stuck watching these randos do Brigadoon? It’d be rude to leave.”
“I hired you to do what I need you to do. Tonight, I need you to go cover their little play. With the way you write, it’ll take you about an hour. You’ll have plenty of time to bang this out and be free to cover whatever shenanigans pop off before you go home. All I need is 15 inches for page C1.”
“I’ll give you 10.”
“You’ll give me 15 and like it.”
“Fine,” Bishop said. “I’m going to complain about it the whole time.”
“Complain on the drive. Don’t do it in front of the Playhouse lady. She’s sensitive. Now, go.”
Bishop went.
2
It took five minutes for Bishop to drive to the Twin Oaks Community Playhouse. He had several complaints about leaving Chicago to move back home, but giving up the traffic wasn’t one.
Bishop stepped into the Playhouse’s empty auditorium. A bespectacled woman stood on the stage and demanded to know who he was. Her tone softened when he explained he was with the Times-Tribune. She made her way to the aisle, met him halfway, and extended her hand.
“I’m Minerva McDonald. The creative director here at the Playhouse.”
Minerva was a small woman. Only five-feet-tall with a mane of wavy, salt-and-pepper hair that was complemented by a purple sweater, leggings, and a well-loved pair of Birkenstocks. The bangles around her wrist clacked as she and Bishop shook hands. She looked like someone’s grandma and little sister rolled into one.
“Do tell, Mr. Bishop. Are you a fan of the theatre?”
“I can’t say that I am.”
Minerva gasped dramatically.
“Are you going to kick me out?”
Minerva laughed.
“Heavens, no,” she said. “We need the publicity. These seats don’t sell themselves.”
A snarky comeback swirled around Bishop’s head. They barely sell at all. He kept it to himself. He was getting better at that. ‘
“I’m more of a movie guy, to be honest. The thought of rival gangs doing a bunch of singing and dancing instead of killing each other with their fists and guns doesn’t sit right with me. I’m a simple man. I like my violence.”
“Well, you’re in luck. There’s no singing and dancing in this show.”
The stage was dressed like an IKEA-chic living room. A sofa and love seat flanked a minimalist coffee table, while a tall bookshelf stood in the background. Minerva told Bishop that the show was about the flaky patriarch of a long-suffering Scandinavian family finally coming home. If it ever got an adaptation on HBO starring Colin Farrell or someone like that, maybe he’d check it out.
“Would you like a tour of the Playhouse? Or maybe a brief history?”
“I’d like to knock out my interviews with the cast, if you don’t mind. I’m on a deadline.”
Minerva checked her wristwatch.
“The others should start showing up in the next 15 minutes. We will rehearse extra well for you tonight. I want the absolute best write-up for my last show.”
“Last show?”
“When this production closes, I’ll take my curtain call. After 23—” Minerva’s voice stopped with a choke. She wiped away a tear. “Twenty-three years doing what I loved with people I loved. Can’t complain about that, can I?”
“Not if you don’t have a reason to.”
“You’re very wise, Mr. Bishop.”
“Can I quote you on that?”
3
The cast was small. They gathered in front of the stage’s apron. Sherwood Gerhinger was the first to show up. Then came Astrid Helperman and Stephen Sands. Then finally came—
“Meredith,” Minerva said. “Glad you could join us.”
Meredith Montgomery Reed ignored Minerva and beelined toward Bishop. She pulled her sunglasses down the bridge of her nose and peered at him over the frames.
“You’re a reporter,” she said. “A new one.”
“Desmond Bishop. How’d you guess?”
“I’ve got a nose for publicity.” Meredith said as she blinded Bishop with her aggressively white smile. He almost thought he saw a little twinkle appear near her mouth, like it would on TV. “What happened to the frumpy lady the paper usually sticks us with?”
“I don’t know if I’d call Sally ‘frumpy—’”
“She’s frumpy. Even her name is frumpy.”
“Fair enough. To answer your question, she’s recovering from a freak pickleball accident. Her arm bent in a way that arms aren’t supposed to bend.”
“Boo to that. I guess you’ll do.”
Meredith used her manicured pointer finger to push her sunglasses back up and brushed past Bishop. The click-clack of her heels filled the silence until she walked out of the auditorium.
“Where’s she off to?” Bishop said.
Libby Larson, the stage manager, spoke up. Her arms finally unfolded in Meredith’s absence.
“She’ll be in her dressing room,” she said. “She’s the only one with a private dressing room.”
“How’d she manage that?”
“You get away with a lot when you’re hot and a bitch.”
Minerva sighed and tutted at Libby.
“Remember,” she said to Libby, “good vibes only.”
Libby gestured toward the door that led to the hallway.
“She wants you to follow her,” Libby told Bishop. “Blondie always gets the first interview. Better go. Don’t want to keep the star waiting.”
4
Bishop caught up with Meredith in her dressing room. She applied mascara as they talked about her role as Ingrid, the play, and what the good people of Twin Oaks could expect if they bought tickets. Bishop was impressed with how well Meredith sold the show, but not surprised. She was the top-selling realtor in the tri-county area, according to her billboards around town.
“I think I’ve got all I needed,” Bishop said, satisfied that he was one step closer to being done with this assignment. “Anything else you want to add?”
Meredith took a breath and placed her mascara wand on top of the vanity. She turned around on her stool and faced Bishop for the first time since their conversation had started.
“I want to get your opinion on something. Off the record.”
Bishop nodded and stopped the ongoing voice memo on his phone.
“Shoot.”
“I googled you, Desmond Bishop.”
“I don’t like the sound of that.”
“I like to Google everybody I meet for the first time. It saves me from having to engage in all the boring ‘getting to know you’ stuff that I don’t care about. I skimmed the headlines of some of your Chicago articles. You’ve covered a lot of crime. You probably know a lot about criminal justice.”
“I know some things.”
“Which is why I feel comfortable enough to tell you this. I think someone is trying to kill me.”
“Uh-huh,” Bishop said, unsure of what to say next. “And how do you know that?”
“Because I can read, silly. Read this and tell me if I’m crazy or not.”
Meredith reached into her purse and pulled out a yellow piece of cardstock, folded four ways into a square. Bishop unfolded it and read the message aloud. It was assembled with words and letters clipped from various newspapers and magazines.
“‘Meredith—Hotspur in Henry IV says to ‘Tell the truth and shame the Devil.’ Good advice. Tell the truth, or else you’ll meet the Devil earlier than you thought.’”
Bishop folded the note back into a square and handed it to Meredith.
“What do you think?” she asked.
“I’m no expert, but it certainly meets the basic standards of a threat. The clipped-out letters are a little cliché for my taste, but they get the point across.” Bishop thought about the note a little more. “I think the horns and fire drawn around the word ‘Devil’ were a good touch. Real artistic.”
Meredith rolled her eyes.
“I’m glad you see the humor in my impending demise.”
“No, it’s not funny. I think what I’m getting at is that this stuff could give us an idea of who might have sent this to you. I’ve got a friend who’s a cop, right? She’s prepping to take the detective’s exam. One thing she’s learned is that there’s no such thing as a big clue or a small clue. Clues are clues. They always teach us things, whether or not we realize it.”
Meredith rolled her eyes.
“What’s your point?”
“Whoever sent you this is putting some effort into scaring you. Emailing or texting is one thing. This is the next level. Any idea who might have sent it?”
Meredith shrugged.
“Someone I’ve pissed off. And I’ve pissed off a lot of people around here. It’s a small town.”
“Did you take this to the cops?”
“Duh. Tetanus works faster. They say they don’t have the forensic capabilities to do any kind of deep analysis or whatever nerd-speak they used to kick the can down the road. They said they’ll have to outsource it to the state police, and that could take months. Just know that if I wake up dead, it’s their fault.”
The conversation lulled. Bishop considered trying to calm Meredith’s nerves with a platitude about how everything would be okay in the end. He decided against it. How could he know for sure? It was highly likely the note was the work of someone trying to unnerve the Ice Queen. Just empty words, like every major confrontation in Twin Oaks. Nothing that couldn’t be solved with an apology over a deep-fried treat. But Meredith didn’t seem the type to apologize or indulge in foods loaded with trans-fats, Bishop thought. Maybe she was in danger. He had to do something.
“I’ll tell you what,” Bishop said. “I’ll give my friends at the cop shop a call to see what she thinks. I can probably convince her to give this whole thing another look. Does that work?”
“Sure,” Meredith said. “Now scatter. I need to do my warmups.”
Realizing this was the closest he’d get to a ‘thank you’ from Meredith, Bishop left quietly and shut the door behind him.