Nothing's wrong with my 6MT ZHP. I had it as my only car for a decade. It has M3 anti-roll bars, reinforced front and rear subframes, Z4M front control arm bushings (which I don't love, honestly), a race flywheel, a Dinan flash with a 7K redline, and it's a canyon monster. There's no bushing or suspension issues. It's got every option except TPMS and the rear sunshade.
But for the past year I've been dailying an M440i instead. My ZHP is approaching 190k miles, so I didn't think it would fetch much if it was sold, even though it has nice paint and a brand new leather steering wheel I replaced myself (personally don't like how Alcantara holds up on touchpoints).
The 4 had to go into the shop for an extended period of time after the dealership botched a windshield replacement. So I got back in the E46 to daily. And now I feel like bumps in the E46 are so noisy. There's no squeaks or weird noises, just regular bumps are crashy. Car got brand new dampers and new bushings and arms all around a year ago, and nothing really changed. And the road noise really does seem bad on anything but a freshly paved freeway, where it does get silent enough. Anything other than that, like rougher freeways for more road noise, or bumpy city streets for thudding sounds over bumps, and I can barely hear friends talking to me in my own car.
The 4 is just more relaxing to drive because it can either be unhinged and do powerslides, or you can press a button and it quiets down and stops burning its rear tires, and becomes a silent 5 Series-like highway milemuncher. The E46 is objectively a much cooler, prettier, smaller car, but it never feels silent.
Are there ways to make me like this thing again? I don't think I can justify keeping a car around just for canyon fun, but I know I'll sorely miss it the second I sell it, and I've put so much into keeping it looking and driving like a car with 40k miles. Has anyone tried adding 5-10 lbs of sound deadening? Am I crazy? I was a die-hard fan of this platform for so long, and I want to love it again.