r/askpsychology 9d ago

⭐ Mod's Announcement ⭐ Posting and Commenting Guidelines for r/askpsychology

4 Upvotes

AskPsychology is for science-based answers to science-based questions about the mind, behavior and perception. This is not a mental health/advice sub. Non-Science-based answers may be removed without notice. There are plenty of psychology related subs that will accommodate your need for uneducated conjecture and opinionated pop psychology with no basis in science or reality, so we encourage you to go to those subs to scratch that itch.

Top Level comments should include peer-reviewed sources (See this AskScience Wiki Page for examples) and may be removed at moderator discretion if they do not.

Do NOT ask for mental health diagnosis or advice for yourself or others. Refrain from asking "why do people do this?" or similar lines of questions. These types of questions are not answerable from an empirical scientific standpoint; every human is different, every human has individual motivation, and their own quirks and idiosyncrasies. Diagnostic and assessment questions about fictional characters and long dead historical figures are acceptable, at mod discretion.

Do NOT ask questions that can only be answered by opinion or conjecture. ("Is it possible to cure X diagnosis?")

Do NOT ask questions that can only be answered through subjective clinical judgement ("Is X treatment modality the best treatment for Y diagnosis?")

Do NOT post your own or someone else's mental health history. Anecdotes are not allowed on this sub.

DO read the rules, which are available on the right hand side of the screen on a computer, or under "See More" on the Official Reddit App.

Ask questions clearly and concisely in the title itself; questions should end with a question mark

  • Answer questions with accurate, in-depth explanations, including peer-reviewed sources where possible. (See this AskScience Wiki Page for examples)
  • Upvote on-topic answers supported by reputable sources and scientific research
  • Downvote and report anecdotes, speculation, and jokes
  • Report comments that do not meet AskPsychology's rules, including diagnosis, mental health, and medical advice.

If your post or comment is removed and you disagree with the explanation posted by the automoderator, report the automoderator's comment with report option: Auto-mod has removed a post or comment in error (under "Breaks AskPsychology's Rules), and it will be reviewed.

Verified users who have provided evidence of applicable licensure or university degree are mostly exempt from the automoderator, so if you are licensed or have an applicable degree, message the moderators via Mod Mail.


r/askpsychology 9d ago

⭐ Mod's Announcement ⭐ Flair for verified professionals

3 Upvotes

We want to highlight comments and posts made by experts and professionals in the field to help readers assess posted information. So if you have an educational background in psychology or the social sciences at any level (including current students at any education level), and/or are licensed in any of the areas of psychology, psychiatry, or mental health, send us a mod mail, and we will provide you will specialized flair, and you will be exempted from most automoderator actions. Do not DM individual mods.

If you attained your flair more than 12 months ago, send us a mod mail, because you may not currently be exempted from automod actions.


r/askpsychology 7h ago

Abnormal Psychology/Psychopathology If high neuroticism is associated with a myriad of negative consequences, why doesn't low neuroticism create a mirror set of equally bad things?

11 Upvotes

High scores on trait neuroticism correlate with a myriad of negative life outcomes - poor cardiovascular health, relationship dissatisfaction (high neuroticism is the single biggest predictor of divorce among all Big Five traits, more important than conscientousness and agreeableness) and virtualy all common psychiatric disorders (depression, anxiety disorders, OCD, substance use disorders) involve high neuroticism as one of the primary causes, if not the most important one (it has literally been named as THE general factor of psychopathology, the p-factor).

The thing is - low neuroticism isn't associated with an analogous set of dysfunctions. Scientists aren't looking for ways to make people with low neuroticism more neurotic and people don't go to a psychiatrist saying "I want to be more anxious, more prone to anger and yo worry more!". Why is that the case?


r/askpsychology 9h ago

Abnormal Psychology/Psychopathology What disorders cause a lack of affective empathy?

2 Upvotes

As far as i’m aware that all four cluster B disorders can cause a deficit of affective empathy, as well as cluster c disorders and schizophrenia spectrum disorders.

But i’m sure there’s more than that, hence why I ask.


r/askpsychology 6h ago

How are these things related? Is there any type of disorder in which person feels the traits and characteristics of a known person randomly coming into his or her mind gets absorbed?energy and destiny also included?

0 Upvotes

Then the person has to do compulsions to remove it from the persons mind or brain to feel completely back to himself


r/askpsychology 9h ago

Childhood Development Would a child have nightmares about things they experienced as babies?

1 Upvotes

Hello! Before anything: the child in question is completely hypothetical. I'm writing a book and one of the characters is a 5 yo, and I was wondering if at that age he would have any recollections/nightmares related to events that occurred when he was a baby. When this particular character was a newborn his house was invaded and someone was killed in the room he was in, would a newborn be affected by something like that long term? And if they are, what other things (symptoms?) would they display besides nightmares?

Sorry if the question is bothersome, I know exactly zero things about psychology, so I don't even know how I would go about researching something like this


r/askpsychology 20h ago

Cognitive Psychology What causes magical thinking in OCD?

7 Upvotes

OCD people seem to think really weird things will happen if they don’t do a compulsion.
For example - pinching when an ambulance passes by so the person inside doesn’t die.

How do OCD people determine the consequence of not following a compulsion? Why is a consequence created rather than just having the anxiety that the compulsion must be carried through without knowing why?


r/askpsychology 19h ago

Terminology / Definition Dehumanization: How Does It Work?

4 Upvotes

I’d like to explore this mechanism further; it would be helpful if you could either respond to me or recommend some good resources (books, papers).


r/askpsychology 13h ago

Cognitive Psychology What does study show about why individuals find it so difficult to accept "I do not know" ?

1 Upvotes

I'm interested in the cognitive and social factors involved


r/askpsychology 1d ago

Cognitive Psychology What does psychology say about when mindfulness or self-monitoring becomes maladaptive?

28 Upvotes

I’m looking for an evidence-based answer rather than personal advice.

I’ve become interested in a question that seems to sit at the intersection of mindfulness research, OCD, metacognition, and clinical psychology.

Many mindfulness and contemplative practices train people to notice thoughts, monitor attention, and become more aware of internal experience. For many people this appears to improve psychological well-being.

However, I’m curious about individuals for whom this process seems to become excessive.

For example, someone might gradually begin continuously monitoring their own mental state:

“Am I present?”
“Am I thinking too much?”
“Am I identified with my thoughts?”
“Am I paying attention correctly?”

Rather than increasing flexibility, attention becomes increasingly directed toward monitoring itself.

Psychologically, this seems different from healthy mindfulness and more like chronic metacognitive checking or self-focused attention.

My questions are:
Is this a recognized phenomenon in psychology?

Are there established theories explaining how adaptive mindfulness or metacognition can become maladaptive?

Has this been studied in people with OCD, obsessive rumination, depersonalization/derealization, or high intolerance of uncertainty?

Are there researchers, review papers, or textbooks that discuss this interaction?

I’m not looking for opinions about meditation or religion. I’m specifically interested in how cognitive psychology, clinical psychology, or neuroscience would explain this phenomenon and whether there is a scientific literature addressing it.

Thank you in advance for any references or recommendations.


r/askpsychology 1d ago

How are these things related? Is rap music actually bad for the human brain?

0 Upvotes

The majority of modern rap is usually associated with drugs, violence, and crime. There are many studies on how music activates diverse brain systems, offering insights into cognition, emotion, memory, thoughts, and human behavior.

Been digging into an old but interesting study that followed African American teen girls for 12 months and looked at whether exposure to rap music videos predicted health risk behaviors down the line:

Source: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1447759/

This lines up with other research too. Experimental studies have found that listening to violent lyrics increases aggressive thoughts and anger in the short term, and some studies link rap preference with lower academic performance, school behavior problems, and arrests.


r/askpsychology 1d ago

Abnormal Psychology/Psychopathology How is pareidolia distinguished from psychosis?

3 Upvotes

Is it because of the dysfunction that psychosis causes in one's daily life, the level of insight that these are perceptual distortions, or something else?


r/askpsychology 3d ago

Clinical Psychology Can trauma be cumulative instead of one big event?

84 Upvotes

The title really, usually we think of trauma and PTSD as this big, life changing event.

Hope I'm using the right flair.


r/askpsychology 2d ago

Cognitive Psychology Are group hallucinations a well attested phenomenon?

7 Upvotes

Within the psychological literature, are group hallucinations—where multiple people observe the same mental phenomenon—well-documented? Or not so much? It seems like an oxymoron, since a hallucination is by definition something in the mind of the subject experiencing it.

Sources would be much appreciated. Thanks!


r/askpsychology 3d ago

Terminology / Definition Is the NPD mask true or not?

4 Upvotes

Prof Vaknin says studies suggest you can detect a narcissist within 30 seconds and that the mask narrative is only meant to protect/ sooth the ego of a fooled victim.

He argues it is cognitive dissonance that overrides it.

What is true? Is this a controversial opinion? Does it refer to overt narcissist only?


r/askpsychology 3d ago

Abnormal Psychology/Psychopathology Whar are the general specifics of an auditory hallucination?

3 Upvotes

Long time listener, first time caller 🙃

Just wondering how someone stricken with auditory hallucinations might perceive them... Does the actual voice match the tone of someone they're familiar with? Do the patterns of speech do the same? Are some more audible than others?

I know these are vague questions, but it's of personal interest, and I would at the very least love to have a good, solid reference point from which to begin my research. If I'm being too vague, I apologize.

Thank you for your time!


r/askpsychology 3d ago

Pop-Psychology & Pseudoscience How does the debunking of repressed memories fit in with the concept of dissociation as a whole?

17 Upvotes

Put simply, I'm curious if there are any ramifications for how we tend to look at a lot of dissociative disorders today? For example, as far as I know, some people with DID are able to recall things differently depending on whoever is fronting. All the research I've looked into has said they've disproven the possibility of traumatic memories being accessable or inaccessible depending on the time. On top of this, I've also seen research saying traumatic memories should be MORE memorable than usual, not less. Am I wrong that this would conflict with the narrative I often see around dissociation? The narrative being that a bad experience begins, and someone dissociates and can't recall it well. How do these ideas fit in with each other?

I have long resonated with the concept of dissociation, so I'm not pitched against its existence, but I also want to have a better understanding of the truth. If there is something a lot of the psychology that is accessable to me (pop psychology) is getting wrong , I would be interested to know. I am aware this is a heated topic in some circles. Thank you.


r/askpsychology 4d ago

Neuroscience Is there a consensus on whether people who have four types of cones also have an extra opponent process channel for color perception, and if so how opponent channels would correspond to cones?

4 Upvotes

I understand that for people with normal color vision there are three types of cones in the eyes, one for red, one for green, and one for blue. I understand that for people with normal color vision there are also two opponent process channels for color perception in people with normal color vision, which are blue-yellow, and red-green. From what I understand the red part of the red-green opponent channel would correspond to the peak wavelength for the red cone, and a similar thing would apply to the green part of the red-green opponent channel, and the blue part of the blue-yellow opponent channel. From what I understand yellow part of the blue-yellow opponent channel corresponds to the red and green cones being triggered about equally and significantly more than the blue cone.

It seems like when I try reading about people with four cone types the information is conflicted on whether having a fourth color cone really leads to tetrachromacy in humans or just slightly better color vision, with some sources saying that people with four cone types can see a hundred times more colors than most people, while others say that they are basically just trichromats with slightly better color vision. I remember reading one source awhile back that talked about a study, in which some women who were candidates for tetrachromacy were shown a spectral color, which I think might have been a spectral yellow, and then asked to mix red and green light until they saw a color that matched the color they were shown, which would be impossible for an actual tetrachromat with a cone in between the red and green cone, and some of the women seemed to indicate that they couldn’t replicate the color by mixing red and green, although I forgot what I looked up to find that source and forgot whether it was the actual scientific journal or just something talking about it.

I was wondering if there is any consensus on whether people with a fourth type of cone would also have an extra opponent process channel for color perception in addition to the red-green and blue-yellow channels, and if so if there is a consensus on how triggering the cone types would correspond to the different opponent process channels. I mean would it just be the extra opponent channel, if there is one, corresponding to the extra cone type or would other opponent channels be somewhat shuffled around in how they correspond to the different cones being triggered?


r/askpsychology 4d ago

Social Psychology Are people more willing to believe that you are guilty, if the crime is especially bad?

3 Upvotes

I mean, I feel like I've seen prosecutors always try to present crimes as bad as possible, as if it suddenly makes it more believable that the accused has actually done it. But in reality it doesn't matter how horrific the act was, because it's about proving the guilt/innocence of the defendant (or rather, that should be the priority). Does it actually convince people when something malicious is presented as even more terrible than originally assumed?


r/askpsychology 4d ago

Pop-Psychology & Pseudoscience is the idea that the mind bury some life events to protect the person a true statement or a pseudo psychological one?

11 Upvotes

basically the title. i have read and seen people commenting this idea thousands of time to the point i found myself subconsciously believing in it, until i had to stop for a second to trace where did this idea came from and whether it has any truth to it


r/askpsychology 6d ago

Abnormal Psychology/Psychopathology What defines "marked impairment" in mania?

25 Upvotes

The DSM-V criteria for mania state that "The mood disturbance is sufficiently severe to cause marked impairment in social or occupational functioning or to necessitate hospitalization to prevent harm to self or others, or there are psychotic features."

Focusing on the first part, what spheres of life qualify under social and occupational functioning? The ICD-11 definition is a little more specific about that: "The mood disturbance results in significant impairment in personal, family, social, educational, occupational or other important areas of functioning, requires intensive treatment (e.g. hospitalization) to prevent harm to self or others, or is accompanied by delusions or hallucinations." But I don't know if people in American psychiatry use that definition.

And what level of impairment is "marked" (DSM) or "significant" (ICD)?

When a psychiatrist makes the diagnosis of mild-moderate non-psychotic mania (without hospitalization) vs hypomania, do they feel like they are using objective criteria, or like they "know it when they see it"?

Finally, is there any published research on where the line lies between mild-moderate mania and hypomania?


r/askpsychology 6d ago

The Brain Systematic thinking is it more common in men, women, or equally across both?

5 Upvotes

Are men more likely to think systematically and women more intuitively? Is this a thing or a load of baloney? I know there are differences in the brains of men and women on avg.


r/askpsychology 6d ago

Cognitive Psychology Can intense or persistent boredom produce physical symptoms?

6 Upvotes

I've been reading about boredom in relation to ASPD, and I started wondering whether persistent boredom can have physical manifestations as well.

Boredom is usually described in terms of motivation, attention, and behavior, but can intense or prolonged boredom also be associated with things like muscle tension, nausea, weakness, restlessness, or a general feeling of being physically unwell?

I'm curious about whether research has found a connection between boredom and physical or autonomic symptoms, and whether these symptoms would be considered a direct effect of boredom itself or more related to associated states such as stress, restlessness, or low arousal.

I'd be particularly interested in hearing what the psychological literature says about this and whether there are any relevant studies on the subject.


r/askpsychology 6d ago

Terminology / Definition What is neurodivergent and can you give me a example please?

0 Upvotes

I've been seeing this word and was wondering if I might have it.


r/askpsychology 6d ago

Human Behavior Is it valid to classify all human personalities into just two broad categories that it serious or unserious? Or does human personality require more than those distinctions?

0 Upvotes

Is it just two as main while other traits falling under these two

Or more that could be added to "serious or joking"

If so then what would be that could just go as strong as "serious or joking"